Police v P HC Wanganui Cri-2008-483-33

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WANGANUI REGISTRY

CRI-2008-483-000033

NEW ZEALAND POLICE

Appellant

v

P

Respondent

Hearing:         1 April 2009

Counsel:         H C Mallalieu for appellant

Respondent in person

Judgment:      7 April 2009

INTERIM JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[1]      On the first call of a charge of male assaults female, Mr P   pleaded guilty in the District Court at Marton on 19 November 2008.   The entirety of the sentencing notes are as follows:

Mr P  , you are 46 years of age.  You have never previously appeared in Court for any matter involving violence so you are not a person, by my estimate, who is violent by nature or by inclination.  What I will do is enter a conviction and order you to come up for sentence if called upon within six months.  That means if there was a repeat episode of some sort between you and the victim then you could come back to Court and be sentenced on this matter.  Stand down.

NEW ZEALAND POLICE V P HC WANG CRI-2008-483-000033  7 April 2009

[2]      With the consent of the Deputy Solicitor-General, the Police have appealed against this sentence as being manifestly inadequate.  In R v Wilson [2004] 3 NZLR

606, the Court of Appeal has suggested the following approach to  an appellate assessment of whether any particular sentence is manifestly inadequate:

[41]      Whether a sentence can be said to be manifestly inadequate turns first on the maximum sentence for the particular offence; then on a consideration  of  comparable  sentences,  to  the  extent  that  those  are considered to be appropriate; and above all, the focus is required to be on the totality of the offending and the culpability of the offender in the particular case.

[3]      Whilst addressing what is important in the case of the particular convicted person is important, clearly the Police pursue such relatively unusual appeals also because of the unhelpful precedential effect of an aberrant sentence.  Recognition of that fact is reflected in the approach that adjustment to a manifestly inadequate sentence is to be by no more than the minimum extent necessary to remove the manifest inadequacy: Sipa v R (2006) 22 CRNZ 978 (SC) at [9].  Further, the Court can have regard to what would amount to the imposition of an injustice on the offender if there is an increase in sentence in circumstances rendering that unjust in the circumstances as they appear at the time of the appellate reconsideration.  Here, it was submitted for the Police that a period of imprisonment was the appropriate sentence.

[4]      However, Mr Mallalieu  acknowledged  the  need  to  consider  whether  that would cause injustice, in line with the approach of the Court of Appeal in R v Donaldson (1997) 14 CRNZ 537 at 550.   There can never be any notion of an estoppel in respect of sentencing because of the ever-present prospect of an appeal from a manifestly inadequate sentence.  Nonetheless, there is scope for recognising serious unfairness where a convicted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Police v P HC Wanganui Cri-2008-483-33 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZHC 420
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand considered an appeal by the New Zealand Police against a sentence imposed by the District Court at Marton on a man named P, who had pleaded guilty to a charge of male assaults female. The police argued that the sentence of a conviction with a deferred sentencing was manifestly inadequate. The legal issues before the court were whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate and, if so, what the appropriate sentence should be.

Dobson J considered the maximum penalty for the offence and compared it with similar cases to determine whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate. The court acknowledged that the circumstances of the offence were serious, and the consequences of domestic violence are widespread. The court found that the District Court judge had not considered the purposes and principles of sentencing, and the sentence was extraordinarily lenient. The court was concerned that the judge did not consider the victim impact statement and report from a victim adviser. The court agreed that the sentence was manifestly inadequate and found that a term of imprisonment would have been appropriate.

However, the court deferred its decision on re-sentencing and ordered a pre-sentence report to be prepared, as the offender had made significant positive changes since the offence. The court considered that imposing a sentence at that time would cause a substantial injustice. The court directed that a full pre-sentence report, including an appendix on the appropriateness of the offender's present domestic situation for a community-based sentence, be prepared. The court also reserved consideration as to whether a further hearing needed to be convened or whether the matter could be dealt with by way of a telephone conference.

The final orders of the court were to adjourn the appeal pending the issuing of a further memorandum by the court after production of the Probation Officer’s report, to be followed within seven days by any supplementary submissions the appellant wishes to make, in light of this interim judgment and the content of that report.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established