Police v D HC Wellington CRI 2005-435-7

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CRI 2005-435-7

NEW ZEALAND POLICE

Appellant

v

D

Respondent

Hearing:         18 October 2005

Counsel:         Mr N P Chisnall for appellant

Mr P Stevens for respondent

Judgment:      21 October 2005 at 10.15 am

JUDGMENT OF LANG J

Solicitors:

Crown Solicitor, PO Box 10-357, Wellington

Mr P Stevens, P O Box 516, Masterton

POLICE V D  HC WN CRI 2005-435-7  21 October 2005

[1]      This is an appeal by way of case stated.   The informant appeals against a decision of Judge Thomas in the District Court at Masterton dismissing an information alleging that on 9 October 2004 the respondent, Mr D   , drove a motor vehicle whilst the proportion of alcohol in his breath exceeded the legal limit.

[2]      Two issues arise for determination.   The first is whether Mr D    was given the required ten minute period to request a blood test after having provided a positive evidential breath test.  If he was not, the second issue is whether the Judge took into account s 64(2) of the Land Transport Act 1998.  Section 64(2) provides that it is no defence that the procedural requirements of the Act have not been strictly complied with so long as there has been reasonable compliance with those requirements.

Factual background

[3]      The facts, as found by the Judge and recorded in paragraph 4.1 of the case stated, are as follows:

4.1.1On 9 October 05 the Defendant was observed by Police to be driving a motor vehicle on a road, West Street, in Greytown.  Police stopped the Defendant using red and blue flashing lights and the Defendant was requested to undergo a Breath Screening Test (Breath Tests) Notice (No. 2) 1989, rendering a “Fail General” result.

4.1.2The Defendant was required to accompany the Police Officer back to the alcohol bus at the Greytown Police Station and was given oral advice of rights arising under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act

1990 at the roadside.  He agreed to accompany and at the bus was given written advice  under  the  New  Zealand  Bill of  Rights  Act

1990, which was also read to him.   The Defendant underwent an

Evidential Breath Test in accordance with the 1989 Notice that returned a positive result of 865 micrograms of alcohol per litre of breath.     The  device  used  was  supported  by  a  certificate  of compliance.

4.1.3The Defendant was told of the result and re-advised of his rights under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.  He was read the Advice of Positive Evidential Breath Test form.   The 10 minute period started at 7:37pm and finished at 7:48pm.  The Defendant did not request a blood test.

4.1.4For the time referred to, the Defendant was sitting on a seat next to the evidential breath-testing machine directly inside the front door of the bus.  The Defendant asked whether he should go for a blood test and was advised he could seek legal advice.  The Defendant had a

conversation with the arresting…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Police v D HC Wellington CRI 2005-435-7 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NZHC 136
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves an appeal by the New Zealand Police against a decision made by Judge Thomas in the District Court at Masterton, dismissing an information that the respondent, Mr D, drove a motor vehicle with a breath alcohol level exceeding the legal limit on 9 October 2004. The primary issues in this case are whether Mr D was given the required ten-minute period to request a blood test after providing a positive evidential breath test, and if not, whether the Judge appropriately considered section 64(2) of the Land Transport Act 1998, which addresses reasonable compliance with procedural requirements. The High Court, upon reviewing the case, found that while the District Court Judge's conclusion that the interruptions during the ten-minute period were sufficient to render the breath test result inadmissible was open to her, the inquiry did not end there.

The High Court noted that the District Court Judge failed to consider the reasonable compliance provisions of section 64(2) of the Act, which could potentially mitigate the procedural defect identified. Although this issue was not raised by either party in the District Court, the High Court opined that it should have been considered by the Judge. The Court held that in cases where a prosecution is flawed due to non-compliance with statutory requirements, and the statute provides for no defence in cases of reasonable compliance, it is necessary for the Court to consider reasonable compliance irrespective of whether it has been raised. The High Court concluded that the decision to dismiss the information was reversed, and the matter was remitted to the District Court for further consideration of the reasonable compliance provisions.

The Court did not make a definitive ruling on the application of section 64(2) to the facts of the case, as the case stated did not provide sufficient information to do so. Instead, the Court emphasized the importance of the District Court Judge, who had the advantage of hearing the evidence and forming her own impression regarding the events that occurred in the police bus, to undertake this task. The High Court's decision highlights the need for careful consideration of both the procedural requirements and the reasonable compliance provisions when dealing with cases involving evidential breath tests and the right to request a blood test.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established