Police v Casino Bar (No 3) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2012-485-1491 [2013] NZHC 44

UNDER  the Sale of Liquor Act 1989

IN THE MATTER OF     a decision of the Liquor Licensing

Authority [2012] NZLLA 723 dated

27 June 2012

BETWEEN  NEW ZEALAND POLICE Appellant

ANDCASINO BAR (NO 3) LTD First Respondent

CGML LIMITED Second Respondent

EARL FORRESTER HILTON Third Respondent

Hearing:         19 November 2012

Counsel:         T G H Smith & S Kennedy for appellant

M Bendall and B D Jones for first respondent
A G Sherriff for second respondent

Judgment:      4 February 2013

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

Contents

Background to the appeal ................................................................................................................. [1] First alleged error of law: incorrectly narrow assessment of “suitability” ................................ [28] Second alleged error of law: failure to acknowledge status of Police reports ............................ [42] Third alleged error of law: LLA wrongly rejected CGML objection ......................................... [57] Consequential error: immediate issue of the licence .................................................................... [70] Outcome ........................................................................................................................................... [78] Costs ................................................................................................................................................. [79]

NEW ZEALAND POLICE v CASINO BAR (NO 3) LTD HC WN CIV-2012-485-1491 [4 February 2013]

Background to the appeal

[1]      On 27 June 2012, the Liquor Licensing Authority (LLA) issued a decision in which it granted an application by the first respondent (CBL) for an on-licence under the Sale of Liquor Act 1989 (the Act) in respect of an adult entertainment venue in central Wellington known as “Calendar Girls”.1   Its decision was to have immediate effect.

[2]      On the basis of serious concerns about the suitability of the applicant, the Police had opposed the grant of the licence.   The second respondent (CGML), a member  of  the  Chow  Group  of  companies,  also  opposed  the  application.    Its objection acknowledged  that it was a competitor of CBL, but sought  to pursue grounds of objection unrelated to the adverse effects of competition from CBL on its own operation.   The third respondent (Mr Hilton) also lodged an objection to the application.  The LLA treated that objection as having no status because it had been received out of time.

[3]      Despite the matters raised in opposition to the application, it was granted by the LLA without convening a hearing.  The Police then appealed the LLA’s decision. The  appeal  is  brought  under  s 139  of  the Act  which  confines  such  appeals  to questions of law.   The Police have raised a series of questions of law as to the manner in which the LLA dealt with the application and its grounds for granting it. CGML presented argument in support of the appeal.  Mr Hilton took no part in the appeal.

[4]      CBL had lodged its application with the District Licensing Authority (DLA) on 30 March 2012.  The application described a Ms Le Prou as the sole director and shareholder of the applicant company.  In accordance with the statutory requirements for the grant of a licence, the application confirmed that there was no reason to believe that the applicant was not a suitable entity to hold a liquor licence.  It made

no reference to Ms Le Prou’s husband, Mr James Samson.

1      

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Police v Casino Bar (No 3) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Police v Casino Bar (No 3) Ltd, the New Zealand Police appealed a decision by the Liquor Licensing Authority (LLA) to grant an on-licence to Casino Bar (No 3) Ltd (CBL), a company that intended to operate an adult entertainment venue in Wellington. The Police opposed the grant of the licence due to concerns about the suitability of the applicant, particularly the involvement of Mr James Samson, the husband of the sole director and shareholder of CBL, Ms Le Prou. CGML Ltd, a member of the Chow Group of companies, and Mr Earl Forrester Hilton also lodged objections to the application.

The court examined several legal issues, including whether the LLA had incorrectly assessed the "suitability" of the applicant, whether it had failed to acknowledge the status of Police reports, and whether it had wrongly rejected the CGML objection. The court found that the LLA had adopted an unsustainably narrow approach to the assessment of "suitability," focusing solely on the manner in which the business would operate, rather than considering the full range of factors relevant to the suitability of the applicant. The court also found that the LLA had erred in failing to properly consider the Police reports and in wrongly rejecting the CGML objection, which focused on the unsuitability of the applicant due to Mr Samson's connection with it.

As a result of these errors, the court granted the appeal, quashed the LLA's decision, and revoked the licence purportedly issued in terms of it. The court noted that while this decision would cause disruption to the business of CBL, it was necessary to ensure that the licensing process was conducted lawfully. The court also indicated that it would consider costs, with a provisional view that the Police were entitled to costs on the appeal from CBL.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.