Plus Construction Company Limited v JL Trustee Nominee Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2022-404-2305

[2023] NZHC 1986

BETWEEN PLUS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED
Plaintiff

AND

JL TRUSTEE NOMINEE LIMITED

First Defendant

SUN HEE LEE
Second Defendant

JUNHO LEE

Third Defendant

Hearing: 26 June 2023

Appearances:

G K Holm-Hansen and J D van Riele for the Plaintiff J P Nolen for the Defendants

Judgment:

28 July 2023


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE C B TAYLOR

Application for Summary Judgment


This judgment was delivered by me on 28 July 20223 at 3:00pm

pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

…………………………. Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Hesketh Henry, Auckland, for the plaintiff

K3 Legal Limited, Auckland, for the Defendants

PLUS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED v JL TRUSTEE NOMINEE LIMITED [2023] NZHC 1986 [28

July 2023]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Paragraph

Introduction  [1]

Background  [2]

PCCL’s application for summary judgment  [9]

JL Trustee, Ms Lee and Mr Lee’s opposition  [11]

Legal principles  [12]

Analysis  [15]

JL Trustee submissions  [17]

Is there a joint venture arrangement?

Breach of the joint venture arrangements, set-off and counterclaim by JL Trustee            [25]

PCCL’s submissions  [29]
Is there a joint venture arrangement?  [29]

Breach of the joint venture arrangements, set-off and counterclaim by JL Trustee            [33]

Conclusions in relation to the joint venture arrangement, and JL Trustee’s set-off

and counterclaim  [39]

Is there a joint venture arrangement?  [39]

Breach of the joint venture arrangements, set-off and counterclaim by JL Trustee            [41]

JL Trustee’s submissions  [46]

Interference in contractual relations  [46]
Knowing receipt  [49]

PCCL’s submissions  [52]
Interference in contractual relations and knowing receipt  [52]

Conclusions in respect of interference in contractual relations and knowing receipt  [56]

JL Trustee’s submissions  [59]

Oppressive contract  [59]

PCCL’s submissions  [63]
Oppressive contract  [63]

Conclusion in respect of oppressive contract  [66]

JL Trustee’s submissions  [68]

Is PCCL’s entitlement to repayment subordinate to the interests of other parties
and is it prevented from enforcing the Loan Agreement?  [68]

PCCL’s submissions  [72]
Is PCCL being prevented from enforcing its rights against the defendants?  [72]

Conclusion in relation to PCCL being prevented from enforcing its rights against
the defendants  [74]

Result  [77]

Orders  [78]

Introduction

[1]                 Plus Construction Co Limited (PCCL) seeks summary judgment against JL Trustee Nominee Limited (JL Trustee), Sun Hee Lee (Ms Lee) and Junho (Bruce) Lee (Mr Lee) for amounts owing under a loan agreement entered into with JL Trustee and guaranteed by Ms Lee and Mr Lee.

Background

[2]                 PCCL, and its wholly owned subsidiary Plus Pacific United Limited (PPUL), and JL Trustee, and its wholly owned subsidiaries Western Properties Limited (Western) and Wadier Henderson Limited (Wadier), are involved in two property developments. The first is of the Pacific Plus Tower on Buscomb Avenue, Henderson (the Buscomb Development) and the second is of the Sero Tower on Great North Road, Henderson (the Sero Development).

[3]                 The Buscomb Development was led by Western with PPUL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Plus Construction Company Limited v JL Trustee Nominee Limit... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 1986
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Plus Construction Co Limited (PCCL) sought summary judgment against JL Trustee Nominee Limited (JL Trustee), Sun Hee Lee (Ms Lee) and Junho Lee (Mr Lee) for amounts owing under a loan agreement entered into with JL Trustee and guaranteed by Ms Lee and Mr Lee. The defendants opposed the application, raising four defences. First, the defendants alleged a joint venture arrangement existed between PCCL and JL Trustee and their subsidiaries and that PCCL breached the joint venture obligations, giving rise to a counterclaim. Second, PCCL interfered in the contractual relations between Western Properties Limited and Plus Pacific United Limited, and PCCL knowingly received funds paid by Plus Pacific United Limited in breach of its fiduciary duty. Third, the defendants submitted the Loan Agreement was oppressive. Fourth, the defendants argued that PCCL was prevented from enforcing its rights under the Loan Agreement until certain guarantees were discharged in writing. The Court held that the application for summary judgment should be dismissed because the defendants had raised arguable defences. First, the defendants had an arguable position that a joint venture arrangement existed between PCCL and JL Trustee and their subsidiaries. Second, the defendants had an arguable position that PCCL interfered in contractual relations and that PCCL knowingly received funds paid by Plus Pacific United Limited in breach of its fiduciary duty. Third, the Court could not reach a view as to whether the Loan Agreement was oppressive until it was clarified at trial whether the Loan Agreement formed part of a larger joint venture arrangement. Fourth, the defendants had an arguable position that PCCL was prevented from enforcing its rights under the Loan Agreement until certain guarantees were discharged in writing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established