Phillimore Imperial Limited v St John's College Trust Board

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2016-404-003288 [2017] NZHC 2854

BETWEEN

PHILLIMORE IMPERIAL LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

ST JOHNʼS COLLEGE TRUST BOARD Defendant

Hearing: 20 November 2017

Appearances:

J K Stewart/HFK Munkowits for the Plaintiff
I McEntagart/C Bryant for the Defendant

Judgment:

21 November 2017

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE CHRISTIANSEN

This judgment was delivered by me on

21.11.17 at 3:30pm, pursuant to

Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

PHILLIMORE IMPERIAL LIMITED v ST JOHNʼS COLLEGE TRUST BOARD [2017] NZHC 2854 [21

November 2017]

[1]      Both  the  plaintiff  and  the  defendant  have  filed  applications  for  further discovery. Each application is opposed by the other.

Background

[2]      The proceeding concerns the interpretation of a lease contract between the defendant (St John’s) and the plaintiff (Phillimore), namely clause 20 of the lease between St John’s as lessor and Lion Nathan Property Limited (Lion Nathan) as lessee and in particular what the words “major redevelopment of the buildings erected on the said land” mean, and whether by reference to those words, Phillimore has or has not completed a “major redevelopment” on the leasehold land.

[3]      The leasehold land is at 44 Queen Street, Auckland (the land).  The buildings on the land are called the Imperial Building and the Boathouse.

[4]      If there has been a major redevelopment in the terms contemplated by the lease then rent reviews will occur every seven years.  If not, then rent reviews remain at 21 years.

[5]      The lease was executed between St John’s as lessor and Lion Nathan as lessee on 23 November 1993 for a renewed 21-year term.  Since then the lessee’s interest in that land has been transferred:

(a)      From Lion Nathan to Imperial Buildings Limited on 7 March 2003. (b)        From Imperial Buildings Limited to I B Trust on 12 August 2003. (c)         From I B Trust to AMP on 24 August 2007.

(d)      From AMP to Phillimore on 11 September 2009.

[6]      Over 2010 – 2011 Phillimore undertook a restoration project that involved refurbishing buildings on the land and on the adjacent land at 48 – 56 Queen Street over which Phillimore has registered freehold title. The restoration works undertaken

to the buildings on the leasehold land formed only part of the overall restoration project.

[7]     On 1 September 2012, the lease came up for renewal and the parties corresponded regarding a renewal lease but could not agree as Phillimore says its works did not constitute a “major redevelopment” as that term is used in clause 20 of the lease.  St John’s argues to the contrary.

[8]      Phillimore has initiated declaratory judgment proceedings to resolve these matters which are, in essence, about whether rental reviews should occur every 21 years (as Phillimore contends) or every seven years (as St John’s contends).

[9]      Factual issues for consideration upon this proceeding include:

(a)      What were the buildings like pre-development? (b)      What were they like following redevelopment? (c)      The cost of redevelopment.

(d)How the buildings have changed in terms of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phillimore Imperial Limited v St John's College Trust Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 2854
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard a case involving Phillimore Imperial Limited and St John’s College Trust Board, focusing on the interpretation of a lease contract between the parties, particularly clause 20 concerning the definition of "major redevelopment of the buildings erected on the said land." The court needed to determine whether Phillimore had completed a "major redevelopment" as per the lease, which would affect the frequency of rent reviews. The lease, originally between St John’s and Lion Nathan Property Limited, has since transferred through several entities, culminating in Phillimore as the current lessee. Phillimore undertook restoration works on the leasehold land, leading to a dispute over whether these works constituted a "major redevelopment."

The court had to decide whether St John’s College Trust Board's requests for further discovery were justified and whether Phillimore’s requests were valid. St John’s sought extensive information regarding the scope, cost, and changes in functionality and value of the redevelopment works. Phillimore, on the other hand, sought correspondence between St John’s and previous lessees to understand the commercial context of the lease negotiations.

The court granted St John’s request for further discovery to a significant extent, ordering Phillimore to disclose various documents related to the redevelopment works, their costs, and the changes in the buildings post-redevelopment. The court rejected Phillimore’s application for discovery of St John’s correspondence, finding no sufficient grounds to support it. The court also awarded costs to St John’s for both applications, scheduling a further case management conference to review compliance with discovery obligations and consider trial scheduling.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established