Petricevic v Bridgecorp Management Services Limited (in rec)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA371/2008
[2008] NZCA 286

BETWEENRODNEY MICHAEL PETRICEVIC


Appellant

ANDBRIDGECORP MANAGEMENT SERVICES LIMITED (IN RECEIVERSHIP)


Respondent

Hearing:4 August 2008

Court:William Young  P, O'Regan and Robertson JJ

Counsel:P J Dale and C M Brick for Appellant


M J Tingey and J C Caird for Respondent

Judgment:4 August 2008 

ORAL JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        We dismiss the application for a stay.

BThe respondent is awarded costs on a standard (band A) basis along with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by William Young P)

Introduction

[1]       On 5 June 2008, Bridgecorp Management Services Ltd (in receivership), or BMSL as we will call it, obtained summary judgment from Associate Judge Robinson against Mr Rodney Petricevic for $661,333.50.  The primary claim was for $576,100 paid by BMSL on behalf of Mr Petricevic on 4 September 2006.  The balance of the judgment sum is for interest and costs.  Mr Petricevic has appealed against that judgment.  By reason of that appeal, he obtained from Priestley J a stay of execution of the judgment on the condition that he pay $576,100 into court.  He did not comply with that condition and now seeks a stay from this Court under r 12 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.

[2]       This application has particular relevance as bankruptcy proceedings by BMSL are to be called against Mr Petricevic on 7 August.

[3]       If the appeal is to proceed, it could be heard on 20 August 2008 and we direct that it be set down for hearing on that date.

The background to the litigation

[4]       BMSL is part of the Bridgecorp group of companies.  Mr Petricevic was the chief executive officer of those companies.  The material before us does not explain in detail the way in which those companies operated but we infer that BMSL provided management services to the Bridgecorp group.  This group operated, inter alia, as a financier and raised considerable money from the public through the offering of debenture stock.  Most of the companies in the group (but not BMSL) were placed in receivership on 2 July 2007.  At that stage the amount owed to the debenture holders was in the order of $458m.  The receivers anticipate that the debenture holders will eventually recover somewhere between 13 and 44 cents in the dollar, resulting in a deficiency of between $256m and $397m.  BMSL was not placed in receivership until 18 December last year.

[5]       Mr Petricevic is involved in two other sets of legal proceedings associated with the collapse.  He is being prosecuted for alleged offences under the Securities Act 1978 and the Companies Act 1993.  He is also a defendant in civil proceedings in which BMSL seeks to recover $2,749,347 from him, representing what the receivers claim to have been excessive remuneration over the period 1 July 2004 – 30 June 2007.  According to the receivers, further claims are likely.

The summary judgment claim

[6]       As noted, the present claim is based…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Petricevic v Bridgecorp Management Services Limited (in rec) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZCA 286
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Rodney Michael Petricevic has appealed against a summary judgment obtained by Bridgecorp Management Services Ltd (in receivership) for $661,333.50. The primary claim was for $576,100 paid by Bridgecorp on behalf of Mr Petricevic on 4 September 2006. Mr Petricevic has applied for a stay of execution of the judgment pending the determination of his appeal. The Court of Appeal has dismissed the application for a stay. The Court considered the appeal against the summary judgment to be arguable but found that the set-offs claimed by Mr Petricevic were implausible and lacked plausibility. The Court also found that Mr Petricevic had not demonstrated sufficient urgency in prosecuting his appeal and had not provided adequate disclosure of his financial circumstances. The Court awarded costs on a standard (band A) basis along with usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bridgecorp Management Services Ltd (BMSL), a company in the Bridgecorp group, obtained summary judgment against Rodney Petricevic for $661,333.50. The claim was for $576,100 paid by BMSL on behalf of Petricevic to the Inland Revenue Department, along with interest and costs. Petricevic, the former CEO of the Bridgecorp group, was involved in the management of the group's companies. Most of the companies in the group were placed in receivership in July 2007, with BMSL being placed in receivership in December 2007. Petricevic was also involved in other legal proceedings, including criminal charges and civil proceedings where BMSL sought to recover excessive remuneration from him. The summary judgment was based on a payment made by BMSL for tax owed by Petricevic, with BMSL claiming it was an advance. Petricevic argued the payment was to be offset against sums due to him. The Court of Appeal was asked to decide an application for a stay of the judgment.

BMSL obtained summary judgment against Petricevic on 5 June 2008. Petricevic appealed against this judgment and obtained a stay of execution of the judgment from Priestley J on the condition that he pay $576,100 into court. Petricevic did not comply with this condition and now sought a stay from the Court of Appeal under r 12 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005. The Court of Appeal heard the application on 4 August 2008.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Associate Judge was wrong to enter summary judgment given the unresolved alleged set-offs.
2. Whether there was a misunderstanding as to the nature of the hearing on 29 May 2008, such that not all possible defences to the summary judgment claim were canvassed.
3. Whether the unresolved set-off claims precluded summary judgment or warranted a stay of the judgment.
4. Whether the appeal against summary judgment is genuinely arguable.
5. Whether the Court should impose conditions on the stay of execution of the judgment.

Held
1. The appeal against the summary judgment was not genuinely arguable on the basis of the unresolved set-off claims, but if arguable, it was technical and largely involved timing issues.
2. The Court found no misunderstanding as to the nature of the hearing on 29 May 2008, as both parties addressed the substantive summary judgment claim.
3. The unresolved set-off claims did not preclude summary judgment or warrant a stay of the judgment.
4. The appeal against summary judgment was found to be genuinely arguable, albeit with limited merit.
5. The Court dismissed the application for a stay of execution of the judgment, reserving leave to reapply if security for the full amount of the judgment and the costs of the proceedings was provided.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court addressed the appeal against the summary judgment entered by Associate Judge Robinson, focusing on whether the unresolved set-off claims could have precluded summary judgment or warranted a stay of the judgment. The Court noted that the Associate Judge did not adequately engage with the plausibility of Mr Petricevic's set-off claims, but the Court itself viewed these claims with considerable scepticism. The Court was critical of the limited disclosure and selective nature of Mr Petricevic's financial information, which did not demonstrate his inability to meet the judgment sum. The Court was also concerned with the timing of certain asset transfers and the suspicious nature of Mr Petricevic's claims regarding the ownership of assets. The Court found the appeal to be genuinely arguable but with limited merit, primarily involving technical and timing issues. Ultimately, the Court dismissed the application for a stay of execution of the judgment, reserving leave to reapply if security for the full amount of the judgment and the costs of the proceedings was provided.

The Court held that the appeal against summary judgment was genuinely arguable, but the merits were limited, primarily involving technical and timing issues. The Court dismissed the application for a stay of execution of the judgment, reserving leave to reapply if security for the full amount of the judgment and the costs of the proceedings was provided. The Court awarded costs on a standard (band A) basis along with usual disbursements. The Court's decision balanced the interests of both parties, ensuring that the appeal did not become nugatory and the interests of the judgment creditor were not eroded or imperilled. The Court's dismissal of the stay application reflected its concern over the suspicious conduct of Mr Petricevic and the potential for gaming behavior, which needed to be guarded against to protect creditors.