Perry Corporation v Ithaca (Custodians) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA43/03

BETWEENPERRY CORPORATION


First Appellant

ANDRICHARD C PERRY


Second Appellant

ANDITHACA (CUSTODIANS) LIMITED


First Respondent

ANDGUINNESS PEAT GROUP PLC


Second Respondent

ANDRUBICON LIMITED


Third Respondent

Hearing:8 December 2003

Coram:Gault P
Blanchard J
Glazebrook J

Appearances:  A R Galbraith QC and C M Stevens for Appellants


R J Asher QC and M R Dean for Respondents

Judgment:8 December 2003

Reasons:16 December 2003

REASONS FOR THE JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
DELIVERED BY GAULT P

[1]       The second respondent (GPG) applied for conditional leave to appeal to the Privy Council from the judgment of this Court delivered on 4 November 2003.

[2]       In its judgment this Court held that a full analysis of the evidence did not disclose an arrangement by which Perry Corporation had the power to acquire a substantial shareholding in Rubicon Ltd so as to require disclosure under s5 of the Securities Markets Act 1988.

[3]       This was a different conclusion from that reached in the High Court where it had been held that there had been a failure to disclose and that, in consequence, Perry Corporation should forfeit 12 million shares in Rubicon and dispose of a further 24 million shares within 180 days.

[4]       The interest of GPG is as a substantial shareholder in Rubicon Ltd having built its shareholding in the belief that there was no other substantial security holder, only to learn that Perry Corporation had terminated equity swap arrangements and acquired its shares.  It was held in the High Court, and not challenged, that GPG suffered no quantifiable loss as a result of the claimed failure by Perry Corporation to disclose its interest.

[5]       The application for conditional leave was advanced on the alternative grounds provided in r2(a) and (b) of the 1910 Order in Council.  It was submitted that GPG was entitled to leave as of right under r2(a), but if that was not accepted, there should be discretionary leave under r2(b).

[6]       At the end of the hearing we ruled that this is not a case attracting leave as of right and that we were not persuaded that this is a case in which the question involved in the proposed appeal is one which by reason of its great general or public importance or otherwise, ought to be submitted to the Privy Council.  We now give our brief reasons, which are essentially those advanced by Mr Galbraith QC in his well researched and comprehensive submissions on behalf of Perry Corporation.

[7]       The question formulated by Mr Asher QC as that involved in the appeal and of general and public importance was whether in the circumstances in which Perry Corporation, on entering into the share swaps, sold to the counterparties shares in Rubicon Ltd to be held as a hedge, and it was inevitable that those shares would be available for purchase from the counterparties when the share swaps were terminated, there existed arrangements by which Perry Corporation had the power to acquire the shares.  That…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perry Corporation v Ithaca (Custodians) Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NZCA 284
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Perry Corporation v Ithaca (Custodians) Limited concerned the interpretation of securities disclosure requirements under the Securities Markets Act 1988. The second respondent, Guinness Peat Group (GPG), sought conditional leave to appeal to the Privy Council from the Court of Appeal's judgment, which found that Perry Corporation did not have the power to acquire a substantial shareholding in Rubicon Ltd, thereby negating the need for disclosure. The High Court had previously ruled that Perry Corporation should forfeit 12 million shares and dispose of an additional 24 million shares within 180 days due to a failure to disclose. GPG, a significant shareholder in Rubicon Ltd, argued that it was entitled to appeal as of right or, alternatively, under the Court's discretion, due to the potential impact on its investment.

The legal issues before the Court of Appeal involved determining whether the appeal met the criteria for conditional leave to appeal to the Privy Council. Specifically, the court had to decide whether the matter involved a claim or question to or respecting property or a civil right amounting to or exceeding NZ$5,000, as required by rule 2(a) of the 1910 Order in Council. Alternatively, the court had to assess whether the question involved was one of great general or public importance, warranting discretionary leave under rule 2(b). The primary focus was on whether the equity swap arrangements between Perry Corporation and the counterparties constituted an arrangement by which Perry Corporation had the power to acquire a substantial shareholding in Rubicon Ltd, thereby requiring disclosure.

The Court of Appeal concluded that the appeal did not meet the criteria for leave as of right. While GPG argued that the value of the disputed shares exceeded the required threshold, the court found that GPG's interest in the outcome was contingent upon the retention of its shares rather than directly linked to the regulatory compliance issue. The court further noted that the proposed appeal, which sought to establish a specific exception to the general rule that equity swaps do not create disclosable interests, did not present a matter of great general or public importance. The court held that such a narrow and fact-specific interpretation of the disclosure requirements would not constitute a commercially practical regime and did not align with approaches in comparable jurisdictions. Consequently, the application for conditional leave was refused, and costs were awarded in favour of Perry Corporation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.