Perpetual Trust Ltd v Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2010-404-7597 [2012] NZHC 223

BETWEEN  PERPETUAL TRUST LIMITED First Plaintiff

ANDAMP CAPITAL PROPERTY PORTFOLIO LIMITED

Second Plaintiff

ANDMAINZEAL PROPERTY AND CONSTRUCTION LIMITED First Defendant

ANDNUPLEX INDUSTRIES LIMITED Second Defendant

ANDPROJECT ROOFING LIMITED Third Defendant

CONTINUED OVERLEAF Hearing:  23 November 2011

Appearances: Mr Price, Ms Stewart and Mr Lockhead for plaintiffs

Ms Knight for first defendant

Fourth defendant (excused from attendance) Fifth Defendant (excused from attendance)

J A Thompson for fifth defendant
P J K Spring for sixth defendant

Mr D K Wilson appears for eighth defendant (but is excused attendance)

Mr A Barker for tenth defendant Mr O'Neill for eleventh defendant Mr P Hunt for twelfth defendant

Mr Smith and Ms Beight for fourteenth and seventeenth defendants

Ms Webster for fifteenth defendant

Judgment:      23 February 2012

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE DOOGUE

This judgment was delivered by me on

23.02.12 at 10 a.m., pursuant to

Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

PERPETUAL TRUST LIMITED & Anor V MAINZEAL PROPERTY AND CONSTRUCTION LIMITED & Ors HC AK CIV-2010-404-7597 [23 February 2012]

ANDMPM WATERPROOFING SERVICES LIMITED

Fourth Defendant

ANDDOMINION CONSTRUCTORS (1973) LIMITED

Fifth Defendant

ANDVILLAGE FARMS LIMITED Sixth Defendant

ANDMCALPINE HUSSMANN LIMITED Seventh Defendant

ANDY NOT PLASTERERS LIMITED Eighth Defendant

ANDROBERT GORE LIMITED Ninth Defendant

ANDDOWNER WORKS EDI LIMITED Tenth Defendant

ANDDEAN STEEL LIMITED Eleventh Defendant

ANDCONTRACT COATINGS LIMITED Twelfth Defendant

ANDD. L. GOOD PLUMBERS LIMITED Thirteenth Defendant

ANDSTUDORP LIMITED Fourteenth Defendant

ANDPEDDLE THORP AITKEN LIMITED Fifteenth Defendant

ANDCONTRADO LIMITED Sixteenth Defendant

ANDJAMES HARDIE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Seventeenth Defendant

Solicitors:

MinterEllisonRuddWatts, P O Box 3798, Auckland –

Stephen.price@minterellison.co.nz/  Janine.stewart@minterellison.co.nz for plaintiff

Simpson Grierson, Private Bag 92518, Wellesley Street, Auckland – jo- anne.knight@simpsongrierson.com Graeme.christie@simpsongrierson.com for first defendant

Glaister Ennor, P O Box 63, Auckland  - tim.rea@glaisterennor.co.nz for second defendant

Brookfields, P O Box 240, Auckland – neutze@brookfields.co.nz /

corlett@brookfields.co.nz for third defendant

Short & Partners, Auckland – j.macdonald@short.co.nz for fourth defendant

Robertsons, P O Box 2068, Auckland –jthompson@robertsonslaw.co.nz  for fifth defendant

Keegan Alexander, Auckland – pspring@keegan.co.nz for sixth defendant

Schnauer & Co, Attn: Mr D Schnauer  - dschnauer@schnauer.com for seventh defendant

Mr D Wilson, P O Box 5133,Auckland – dkw.barrister@xtra.co.nz for eighth defendant

Wilson Harle, Auckland – kate.morrison@wilsonharle.com /

gary.hughes@wilsonharle.co.nz
(Counsel: A Barker, Auckland -  ab@shortlandchambers.co.nz for tenth defendant)

Lee Salmon Long, P O Box 2026, Shortland Street, Auckland –paul.o’neil@lsl.co.nz
/ julian.long@lsl.co.nz for eleventh defendant

McElroys, P O Box 835, Auckland  – by email:  peter.hunt@mcelroys.co.nz / Andrew.colgan@mcelroys.co.nz for twelfth defendant

Morgan Coakle, P O Box 114, Auckland – bwebster@morgancoakle.co.nz for fifteenth defendant

Lowndes Jordan, P O 5966 Auckland – mkb@lojo.co.nz for fourteenth and seventeenth defendants

(Counsel:  W Smith – warwicksmith@xtra.co.nz) Kennedys, Auckland – m.dennett@kennedys-law.co.nz

[1]      The plaintiffs seek leave to discontinue against the sixth, eighth to thirteenth, and fifteenth defendants.  In the course of the hearing, Mr Warwick Smith, for the fourteenth and seventeenth defendants (James Hardie New Zealand Ltd and its subsidiary, Studorp Ltd) (“James Hardie”), said that his clients had no objection to the   plaintiffs   discontinuing   against   the   eleventh…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perpetual Trust Ltd v Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 223
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Perpetual Trust Ltd and Amp Capital Property Portfolio Ltd brought proceedings against Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd and others in relation to defective building work. The plaintiffs sought leave to discontinue against several of the defendants. James Hardie New Zealand Ltd and its subsidiary, Studorp Ltd, opposed discontinuance by the plaintiffs against certain defendants. The Court had to decide whether to grant leave for the plaintiffs to discontinue against those defendants, and if so, whether to impose any conditions on the discontinuance. The Court considered whether the defendants would be prejudiced by the discontinuance, particularly in relation to the defendants' cross-claims for contribution. The Court held that a plaintiff is not required to be guided by considerations of what would be in the interests of a defendant in the proceedings. Even if discontinuance would cause prejudice to the defendants in prosecuting their cross-claims, that would not be a sufficient reason to refuse to allow the plaintiff to discontinue. The Court concluded that the plaintiffs were entitled to discontinue against the nominated defendants, and granted leave for discontinuance without any conditions.