Perpetual Trust Ltd v Financial Markets Authority no.3

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2012-404-2851 [2012] NZHC 2307

BETWEEN  PERPETUAL TRUST LTD Plaintiff

ANDFINANCIAL MARKETS AUTHORITY Defendant

Hearing:         27 August 2012

Counsel:         J R Billington QC and S E Fitzgerald for Perpetual Trust Ltd

H B Rennie QC, A M Callinan and G K Holm-Hansen for Financial
Markets Authority

Judgment:      7 September 2012

JUDGMENT (NO. 3) OF HEATH J

This judgment was delivered by me on 7 September 2012 at 2.30pm pursuant to Rule

11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:
Russell McVeagh, PO Box 8, Auckland

Simpson Grierson, Private Bag 92518, Auckland Financial Markets Authority, PO Box 1179, Wellington Counsel:

J R Billington QC, PO Box4338, Shortland Street, Auckland

H Rennie QC, PO Box 10242, Wellington

PERPETUAL TRUST LTD V FINANCIAL MARKETS AUTHORITY HC AK CIV 2012-404-2851 [7

September 2012]

Introduction

[1]      On 25 April 2012, the Financial Markets Authority (the Authority) issued a notice under s 25 of the Financial Markets Authority Act 20111 (the Act) in which it required a number of individual and corporate entities associated with Perpetual Trust Ltd (Perpetual) to produce and supply documents to it, in both paper-based and imaged form.2   Authorised representatives of the Authority attended at the offices of Perpetual in Auckland and Christchurch on 26 April 2012, to serve the notices.

[2]      At that time, the Authority was concerned that Perpetual had entered into transactions, as trustee for the Perpetual Cash Management Fund (the Cash Fund) and the Perpetual Mortgage Fund (the Mortgage Fund), that might have been in breach of the relevant Trust Deed, Deed of Participation and disclosure requirements for the relevant prospectus and investment statements.   In particular, the Authority

harboured concern about an advance made to Torchlight Fund No 1 LP (Torchlight).3

[3]      Mr George Kerr, directly or indirectly, is the beneficial owner of 76.5% of the

shares  in  Perpetual’s  parent  company,  Pyne  Gould  Corporation  Ltd  (PGC),  and

100% of Torchlight.  Because of Mr Kerr’s involvement, another representative of the Authority travelled to Sydney to provide copies to Mr Kerr and Mr Naylor, an investment advisor to Torchlight.

[4]      Perpetual seeks judicial review of the Authority’s decision to issue the s 25 notice.  It does so on the grounds that the notice did not comply with the statutory requirements  set  out  in  s 25.    Perpetual  contends that  it  was  not  “necessary or desirable” to issue the notice and no time “within which” compliance was to be

effected was given.   In consequence, it submits that s 58(2) of the Act4  applied to

require the Authority to destroy or return information or documents it had obtained. While  Perpetual  advanced  other  arguments  based  on  the  proposition  that  the

extraction  of  documents  amounted  to  an  unlawful  and  unreasonable  search  and

1      Financial Markets Authority Act 2011, s 25 is set out at para [21] below.

2      The notice, in material respects, is set out at para [17] below.

3      The circumstances in which this loan came to be made are discussed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perpetual Trust Ltd v Financial Markets Authority no.3 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Perpetual Trust Ltd v Financial Markets Authority no.3, the High Court of New Zealand was asked to determine the lawfulness of a section 25 notice issued by the Financial Markets Authority (FMA) to Perpetual Trust Ltd. The notice required Perpetual to produce documents and supply information, which Perpetual contended was unlawful due to the lack of a specified time frame for compliance. The court held that the notice was indeed unlawful as it did not specify a time within which the information and documents were to be supplied or produced. However, the court exercised its discretion under section 58(3) of the Financial Markets Authority Act 2011 to allow the FMA to retain the documents for use in ongoing investigations and any potential civil or criminal proceedings. The original documents or extracts from documents obtained from persons under a section 25 notice were to be returned to the person previously having possession or control over them, as per section 58(2)(b) of the Act.

The case involved the Financial Markets Authority issuing a section 25 notice to Perpetual Trust Ltd, requesting the production of documents and information related to the Perpetual Cash Management Fund and the Perpetual Mortgage Fund. Perpetual Trust Ltd sought judicial review of the notice, arguing that it was unlawful due to the lack of a specified time frame for compliance. The court agreed with Perpetual Trust Ltd, finding that the notice was unlawful as it did not specify a time within which the information and documents were to be supplied or produced. The court also noted that the nature and extent of the information and documents required by the Authority in its section 25 notice was such that no reasonable recipient could have supplied it "immediately."

However, the court exercised its discretion under section 58(3) of the Financial Markets Authority Act 2011 to allow the FMA to retain the documents for use in ongoing investigations and any potential civil or criminal proceedings. The court found that there was no unfairness in the way in which the information and documents were obtained, and that the circumstances made it necessary and desirable for the Authority to embark upon the collection of relevant evidence. The court also found that there was no need for a sanction to be imposed on the Authority for its breach, as bad faith was not alleged, and this was the first time a question of this type had arisen under section 25.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established