Peet v Bourne HC Hamilton CIV 2006-419-1272

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

CIV 2006-419-1272

IN THE MATTER OF     Section 145A Land Transfer Act 1952

AND

IN THE MATTER OF     an application to sustain a caveat

BETWEEN  DAVID ANDREW PEET AND JACQUALYN MARINI PEET Applicants

ANDGILMORE ROBERT BOURNE AND LOIS NANCY BOURNE

Respondents

Hearing:         1 February 2007

Counsel:         D O’Neill for applicants

M Black for respondents

Judgment:      2 February 2007 at 17:55

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE FAIRE [on application that caveat not lapse]

Solicitors:           Clark & Gay, PO Box 5, Waihi for applicants

Allen Needham & Co, PO Box 12, Morrinsville for respondents

PEET & ANOR  V BOURNE & ANOR HC HAM CIV 2006-419-1272  2 February 2007

The application

[1]      The applicants apply for an order that

Caveat No 6706398.1 being lodged by the applicants against the land owned by the respondents, being 9.5 hectares more or less being Lot 3 of a subdivision of Lot 2 Deposited Plan 311340 comprised in head Certificate of Title 44753 (South Auckland Registry) Certificate of Title 44753

shall not lapse.

[2]      The application is made pursuant to s 145A of the Land Transfer Act 1952. The application was made following the issue of a notice pursuant to s 145A on behalf of the Registrar-General of Lands.  No issue is taken as to the timeliness of the application.  To protect the position pending the hearing of this fixture an interim order that the caveat not lapse was made on 2 October 2006.

[3]      The grounds set forth in the application allege simply that the applicant has a caveatable interest.

The caveat

[4]      The caveat claims an estate or interest derived from the registered proprietor expressed in the following way:

Pursuant to an agreement for sale and purchase dated 5 October 2004 in respect of 9.5ha hatched black more or less being part of the land contained in the above certificate of title as defined on the attached plan and made between the registered proprietors Gilmore Robert Bourne and Lois Nancy Bourne and the abovenamed caveators.

The grounds advanced in opposition

[5]      In an amended notice of opposition dated 30 January and which was further amended without opposition by Mr O’Neill at the hearing of this application, the following eight grounds were pleaded in opposition.

1.The applicants  do not  have  a  caveatable interest.   The  sale  and purchase agreement dated the 5th  of October 2004 (the first agreement) never became unconditional and there has never been a completed and enforceable agreement between the applicants and respondents.

2.Further, the first agreement was cancelled and came to an end in or about December 2005.   Confirmation of that position was also acknowledged and accepted by the applicants in:

a.Subsequent    correspondence    between    their    respective solicitors from December 2005 and into July 2006:

b.By the applicants and respondents addressing a “second agreement” which was never completed or signed by the parties and is therefore unenforceable.

3.In  respect  of  the  second  agreement  the  applicants  also  required various amendments and changes to the proposed second agreement which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Peet v Bourne HC Hamilton CIV 2006-419-1272 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZHC 1575
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Peet v Bourne involves an application by the applicants, David Andrew Peet and Jacqualyn Marini Peet, to sustain a caveat against the land owned by the respondents, Gilmore Robert Bourne and Lois Nancy Bourne. The applicants seek an order that the caveat, lodged against the land owned by the respondents, shall not lapse. The application is made pursuant to section 145A of the Land Transfer Act 1952. The primary legal issue in this case is whether the applicants have a caveatable interest in the land, which would justify the continuation of the caveat against the respondents' title.

The applicants claim that they have a caveatable interest derived from an agreement for sale and purchase dated 5 October 2004. The respondents, however, argue that the agreement was never completed or enforceable, as it was cancelled in December 2005. The respondents also contend that the applicants waived their rights under the agreement through their conduct and correspondence with the respondents' solicitors.

The Court considered the applicable principles for applications that caveats not lapse, including the onus on the caveator to establish an arguable case for the interest claimed and the Court's jurisdiction to impose conditions in appropriate cases. The Court found that the applicants had not yet taken specific performance proceedings, despite their intention to do so. The Court also found that the applicants had not taken any specific action pursuant to the contract's clause 8.7, which would have avoided the contract.

The Court granted the application to sustain the caveat, subject to the condition that the applicants file and serve specific performance proceedings by 16 February 2007. The Court also set a case management conference for 3 April 2007 to address various matters related to the specific performance proceedings. The Court reserved the question of costs, to be determined at a later stage depending on the outcome of the specific performance proceedings.

In conclusion, the Court granted the applicants' application to sustain the caveat, subject to the condition that they promptly initiate specific performance proceedings. The Court also set a case management conference to address various matters related to the specific performance proceedings. The question of costs was reserved for a later stage, depending on the outcome of the specific performance proceedings.