Paul v Durie

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2016-485-744 [2017] NZHC 713

BETWEEN

CLETUS MAANU PAUL

Plaintiff

AND

SIR EDWARD TAIHAKUREI DURIE First Defendant

AND

THE NEW ZEALAND MĀORI COUNCIL

Second Defendant

Hearing: 10 April 2017

Counsel:

A N Isac for Plaintiff
F E Geiringer for First Defendant
G Davidson for Second Defendant

Judgment:

12 April 2017

JUDGMENT OF SIMON FRANCE J

[1]      The first defendant, Sir Edward Durie, applies to strike out judicial review proceedings filed by the plaintiff, Mr Paul.  The second defendant has not similarly applied, but if the first defendant succeeds that would be an inevitable consequence.

Judicial review proceedings

[2]      Mr Paul and Sir Edward were (or are) co-chairs of the New Zealand Māori Council (the Council).  The relationship between them broke down, and there have been disputes since.  On 16 April 2016 Sir Edward was elected sole chair at what purported to be a meeting of the Council.  Mr Paul says the meeting was improperly convened (because he as co-chair did not agree to it).  Consequently the vote at that

meeting is invalid. That is the first ground of review.

PAUL v DURIE [2017] NZHC 713 [12 April 2017]

[3]      A second issue is raised in the proceedings.   It concerns who acts for the Council as its legal representatives.   Presently it is the firm of Woodward Law Offices.    The  principal  of  the  firm,  Ms Donna  Hall,  is  married  to  Sir  Edward. Mr Paul claims this creates an unmanageable conflict.

[4]      There are three challenged decisions in relation to this issue.  At the meeting of 15 April 2016, a “litigation services committee” was appointed.   Its role is to make litigation decisions on behalf of the Council.   Mr Paul alleges the three appointees had connections to Woodward Law Offices that needed to be disclosed and were not. This is claimed to invalidate the committee’s appointment.

[5]      At that meeting, there was also a resolution passed confirming Woodward Law Offices as the Council’s legal representatives.  That decision is challenged on the basis that:

(a)       Sir Edward and Ms Hall (who is also a member of the Council) both participated in the discussions; and

(b)      their conflicts of interests were not disclosed.

[6]      Further, a declaration is sought that Sir Edward and Ms Hall cannot hold the roles of co-chair, Council members and solicitor simultaneously.

[7]      Finally, if these challenges succeed, a similar decision made at the preceding meeting  (6 September 2015)  is  challenged.     It  is  again  alleged  Ms Hall  and Sir Edward participated and voted on the motion.

Preliminary observation

[8]      The defence of the Council’s decisions, and indeed the legitimacy of the Council’s meetings, are being carried by the first defendant.  The Council is taking no active role.  That is in my view both unusual and unfortunate.  It is after all the Council’s processes under challenge.  It is a statutory body and the Court would be assisted by proper representation in the matter.  I invite the Council to reconsider its position.

Applicant’s submissions

[9]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paul v Durie and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 713
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Paul v Durie involves an application by the first defendant, Sir Edward Durie, to strike out judicial review proceedings filed by the plaintiff, Mr Paul. The second defendant, the New Zealand Māori Council, has not applied to strike out but would be affected if the first defendant's application succeeded. The judicial review proceedings challenge decisions made by the Council, including the election of Sir Edward as sole chair and the appointment of legal representation. Mr Paul contends that the meeting at which Sir Edward was elected sole chair was improperly convened and that the appointment of legal representatives is invalid due to conflicts of interest. The first defendant argues that the proceedings should be struck out as they serve no useful purpose, are not reviewable as internal management decisions, and risk delaying the proceedings due to disputed facts.

The court considered the threshold for striking out a claim, noting that a claim should only be dismissed if it is certain to fail. The court found that the proceedings had utility as they would determine the chair of the Council and could have consequential effects on decisions made at relevant meetings. The court was not satisfied that relief would inevitably be declined if the plaintiff succeeded in his claims, and the court saw nothing in the allegation that the proceeding should be struck out because Mr Paul had acted inconsistently with his claim. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was not untenable at an interlocutory stage, and that the Council's acceptance of an obligation to manage conflicts suggested the claim was justiciable.

The court found that the first defendant was on stronger ground regarding the application to strike out aspects of the statement of claim. The court found that certain paragraphs were irrelevant and should be removed, and that the plaintiff should delete or summarise contentious facts included for "information" or "by way of background." The court directed the plaintiff to file an amended statement of claim by a specified date and any further evidence by a later date. The court ordered costs to lie where they fall.

The final orders of the court were that the applications to strike out the entire proceeding, or alternatively the challenges to the Council's decisions concerning legal representation, were dismissed. The court struck out certain paragraphs of the statement of claim and directed the plaintiff to file an amended statement of claim and any further evidence by specified dates. Costs were ordered to lie where they fall.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established