IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
CIV-2015-485-1033 [2017] NZHC 1182
UNDER the Declaratory Judgments Act 1908 BETWEEN
PAUAMAC5 INCORPORATED Plaintiff
AND
DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF CONSERVATION
First Defendant
AND
SHARK DIVE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Second Defendant
AND
SHARK EXPERIENCE LIMITED Third Defendant
Hearing: 19 October 2016 Appearances:
B A Scott and O T H Neas for Plaintiff
J M Prebble and J Dick for First Defendant
S J Grey for Second and Third DefendantsJudgment:
2 June 2017
JUDGMENT OF CLARK J
I direct that the delivery time of this judgment is
10:00 am on 2 June 2017
PAUAMAC5 INCORPORATED v DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF CONSERVATION [2017] NZHC 1182 [2 June
2017]
Introduction
[1] Near Stewart Island people dive to fish for pāua. In recent years they have been joined by those who dive to see white pointer sharks (commonly called great white sharks). Commercial operators take customers to view, from inside cages, great white sharks enticed to the area by “attractants”. This is called cage diving.
[2] PauaMAC5 says that when the shark cage diving operations were authorised by the Director-General of Conservation under the Wildlife Act 1953 he should have considered the safety of other water users. The Director-General does not agree. The Director-General considers that the Department of Conservation (which I refer to as the Department or DOC) is under no statutory obligation to consider public safety when making decisions under the Wildlife Act. Rather, the concern under the Wildlife Act is with the welfare of wildlife, in this context, the great white sharks.
[3] Submissions and evidence in the case addressed various matters including modification of shark behaviour, whether shark cage diving puts other water users at risk, and whether the shark cage diving operations could constitute an offence under the Wildlife Act. I consider, however, the key issue is whether s 53(1) of the Wildlife Act, the provision under which the shark cage diving operations were authorised, contemplates the grant of authorities such as those granted to the second and third defendants. In other words: are the authorities lawful?
The Parties
[4] The plaintiff, PauaMAC5, represents quota holders who harvest pāua commercially in the waters surrounding Stewart Island including around the Titi Islands to the northwest of Stewart Island. PauaMAC5 first filed proceedings in December 2015. At that time it sought a declaration from the High Court that public safety, and in particular the safety of other water users, is a permissible if not a mandatory consideration: when
(a) when the Director-General authorises shark cage diving under s 53 of the Wildlife Act; and
(b) when imposing conditions on authorisations issued under s 53; and
(c) when considering the content of a Code of Practice for shark cage diving activities where compliance with the Code is a condition of an authorisation under s 53.
[5] The Department of Conservation and the Director-General of Conservation were the named defendants.
[6] The matter was set down for hearing in July 2016 and came before Collins J. At the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read PauaMAC5 Incorporated v Director-General of Conservation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NZHC 1182
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that the phrase "catch alive or kill" in section 53(1) of the Wildlife Act should be interpreted according to its ordinary meaning and does not include the broader definition of "hunt or kill" found in section 2 of the Act. Consequently, the Director-General did not have the authority to issue permits for shark cage diving operations that did not involve the intention to catch or kill sharks. The court also declined to make declarations regarding the consideration of public safety by the Director-General, as this issue was rendered moot by the court's interpretation of section 53(1).
The court made a declaration that section 53(1) of the Wildlife Act does not confer power on the Director-General of Conservation to authorise commercial shark cage diving operators to attract sharks to a vessel, platform or cage for the purposes of viewing or filming the sharks. The court declined to make any declarations regarding the consideration of public safety by the Director-General, as this issue was rendered moot by the court's interpretation of section 53(1). The court also declined to order costs for either party, inviting the parties to file focused memoranda if they wished to seek costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi