Paros Property Trust Limited v Faith

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURTOF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2014-404-001906 [2015] NZHC 649

BETWEEN

PAROS PROPERTY TRUST LIMITED

Applicant

AND

PAUL MICHAEL FAITH Respondent

Hearing: 31 March and 1 April 2015

Counsel:

D R Bigio and A J Steel for Applicant
E G Grove for Respondent

Judgment:

1 April 2015

ORAL JUDGMENT OF FOGARTY J

Counsel:       D R Bigio, Auckland

A J Steel, Auckland

E J Grove, Auckland

Solicitors:    Brown Partners, Auckland

Stewart and Associates, Alexandra

PAROS PROPERTY TRUST LIMITED v PAUL MICHAEL FAITH [2015] NZHC 649 [1 April 2015]

[1]      This Court is sitting this morning after an adjournment of one day. Yesterday, I sat with counsel, but in the absence of Mr Faith, the respondent, the purpose being to consider further relief sought by the applicant upon the failure of the respondent to adhere to the conditions of the Court’s judgment on 13 November 2014.1

[2]      By  that  judgment,  the  Court  granted  relief  to  Mr  Faith  against  the cancellation of his lease for non-payment of rent and provided him the option of electing to arbitrate the rent.  The second judgment of 10 December 2014 enabled Mr Faith to pay rent at his valuer’s new rental value, but if arbitration was not elected, the lessor’s rental rate would apply from 25 January 2014.  The lessee to pay the difference between the old rent (of the preceding rental period) and the new, pro

tem, lessee’s rent, ten working days after invoices are issued2.

[3]      There was significant difference between the rent calculated assessed by his

expert valuer at $16,350 per year, and the rent assessed by the landlord’s valuer at

$34,450 per year.

[4]      The  position  as  at  yesterday  was  that  Mr  Faith  has  not  progressed  the arbitration.  He has made no payment of backdated rental, other than one payment made of $870 on 29 December 2014.   Consequently, the lessor has applied for cancellation  of  the  lease,  pursuant  to  s  251(1)  of  the  Property  Law Act  which provides:

251 Powers of court in making order for possession

1On an application to a court for an order for possession of the land comprised in a lease, the court may make the order and cancel the lease.

[5]      His  counsel,  Mr  Grove,  advised  me  yesterday  that  Mr  Faith’s  preferred

position  was  to  bring  a  further  court  proceeding  in  which  he  would  sue  Paros

Property Trust Ltd (“Paros”) on an issue that he raised in the trial before me, namely

1      Paros Property Trust Ltd v Paul Michael Faith ]2014] NZHC 2826.

2      Paros Property Trust Ltd v Faith [2014] NZHC 3155.

that Paros had shopped around for valuations and there had been an earlier valuation by Prendos.

[6]      I issued a minute yesterday recording what I had said orally in Court, that Mr Faith may be at risk of being faced with a plea of issue estoppel per rem judicatum, relying on the decision of Henderson v Henderson.3

[7]      I adjourned the hearing against the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paros Property Trust Limited v Faith and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 649
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Paros Property Trust Limited, as the lessor, filed a case against Paul Michael Faith, the lessee, seeking the cancellation of his lease and possession of the property located at 12 Commodore Drive, Lynfield, Auckland. The dispute originated from the failure of Mr. Faith to adhere to the conditions of the Court's previous judgment, which granted relief to Mr. Faith against the cancellation of his lease for non-payment of rent and provided him the option of electing to arbitrate the rent. The significant difference between the rent calculated by Mr. Faith's expert valuer and the landlord's valuer led to the lessor applying for the cancellation of the lease. The court was required to decide whether the non-compliance of Mr. Faith with the court's previous orders would lead to the cancellation of the lease, and if so, what orders should be made to enforce the cancellation and possession of the property.

The court found that Mr. Faith had not progressed the arbitration or complied with the conditions of relief, thus exposing himself to an application for the cancellation of the lease. The court reasoned that Mr. Faith had had a trial in the High Court where he had the opportunity to dispute the actions taken by the landlord, but he did not take the right of appeal against the decision. The court held that it was beyond its jurisdiction to reopen the issues that were canvassed at the trial or could have been canvassed at the trial and set aside the judgment. The court granted the orders sought by Paros Property Trust Limited, including the cancellation of the lease, the delivery of possession of the property to the lessor, and the payment of outstanding rent by the lessee. The court further ordered Mr. Faith to pay costs to the lessor.

The court made the following orders: (a) The orders granting relief against cancellation in favour of Paul Michael Faith, and made by this Court on 13 November 2014 and 10 December 2014, and Paros Property Ltd against Faith [2014] NZCH 26 are rescinded; (b) The lease between Paros Property Ltd and Paul Michael Faith in respect of the property known as 12 Commodore Drive, Lynfield, Auckland, is cancelled as of the making of this order; (c) Paros Property Trust Ltd has possession of the property, and Paul Michael Faith is to deliver up possession of the property peaceably to Paros Property Trust Ltd and its agents no later than 9 April 2015, and all things necessary to give effect to Paros Property Trust Ltd's possession; and (d) Reserving leave for Paros Property Trust to apply to the Court by way of memorandum for any further orders regarding possession.