Parkhurst Corporation Limited v Bisht

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2021-404-000948

[2021] NZHC 2888

BETWEEN

PARKHURST CORPORATION LIMITED

Appellant

AND

MADHAN SINGH BISHT

Respondent

Hearing: 10 August 2021

Appearances:

A Shinkarenko and T Zaseev for the Appellant S Raju for the Respondent

Judgment:

29 October 2021


JUDGMENT OF WALKER J


This judgment was delivered by me on 29 October 2021 at 10 am Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

PARKHURST v BISHT [2021] NZHC 2888 [29 October 2021]

Introduction

[1]                  This appeal concerns damages awarded for ‘loss of a chance’ following a landlord’s unlawful entry of commercial premises. The landlord-tenant relationship between the appellant, Parkhurst Corporation Limited (Parkhurst) and the  respondent Madhan Singh Bisht foundered in early 2017. Mr Bisht’s company, Imaxx Café & Bistro Ltd, was running a restaurant from the leased premises. Parkhurst had become frustrated by Mr Bisht’s consistently late and/or deficient payment of rent and outgoings. It made various demands for the sums due. On 14 February 2017, Parkhurst re-entered and took possession of the leased premises by changing the locks. It had not served a valid notice upon Mr Bisht prior to re-entering but contended that Mr Bisht had given up possession of the premises.1

[2]                  Mr Bisht issued proceedings in the District Court against Parkhurst for breach of the lease.2 He was largely successful although, for reasons which will emerge, not on his principal claim to damages. The Judge delivered an interim judgment in which she found the re-entry unlawful and liability for breach. She dismissed all the conventional claims for damages but allowed for supplementary submissions on damages for loss of a chance. Ultimately, Mr Bisht was awarded $66,360.93 plus interest and costs under that measure.

[3]                  Parkhurst accepts that the re-entry was unlawful but argues on appeal that the Judge erred in two main respects: first in her assessment of loss of a chance and secondly, by rejecting Parkhurst’s affirmative defence that Mr Bisht failed to mitigate his losses.

Background

[4]                  On 11 May 2015, Parkhurst and Mr Bisht signed a formal Deed of Lease (the lease) for premises at 167 Parkhurst Road, Parakai (the premises). The material terms were:

(a)The lease was to commence on 11 August 2015.


1      Relying on s 245(2) of the Property Law Act 2007.

2      See Bisht v Parkhurst Corp Ltd [2021] NZDC 7242 [District Court decision].

(b)It was for a term of 18 years with rights of renewal exercisable every two years: the first two year term was to end on 11 August 2017 and the final expiry date was 11 August 2033.

(c)The monthly rental was $2,383.33 plus GST ($2,740.83 including GST) payable on the 11th day of each month.

(d)Under clause 3.1, Mr Bisht was required to pay a fair proportion of outgoings as agreed or determined by arbitration.

(e)Mr Bisht received a 12 week “rent holiday”; the first monthly rental payment was due on 11 September 2015.

(f)There were two special…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Parkhurst Corporation Limited v Bisht and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZHC 2888
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns damages awarded for 'loss of a chance' following a landlord's unlawful entry of commercial premises. Parkhurst Corporation Limited (Parkhurst) had become frustrated by Mr Bisht's consistently late and/or deficient payment of rent and outgoings, and re-entered the premises by changing the locks without serving a valid notice. Mr Bisht issued proceedings in the District Court against Parkhurst for breach of the lease. Parkhurst accepts that the re-entry was unlawful but argues on appeal that the Judge erred in two main respects: first in her assessment of loss of a chance and secondly, by rejecting Parkhurst's affirmative defence that Mr Bisht failed to mitigate his losses.

The Court considered that loss of a chance is a well-recognised head of damage involving an inherently difficult evaluation. The Court held that loss of a chance in the quantification of damages is different from loss of a chance as a form of identifiable head of loss. The Court found that the losses claimed by Mr Bisht under this head were not properly characterised as loss of a chance damages. The Court held that there were evidential problems which beset the proceedings, including no independent valuation evidence, no evidence of an offer and no evidence of discussion about price. The Court also held that the financial records were not a logical nor a reliable starting point to assess loss of a chance damages. The Court concluded that there was no evidence upon which the Court could reliably anchor its assessment of the quantum of Mr Bisht's claim.

The Court held that it was not necessary to deal with the arguments about failure to mitigate losses but considered that it was a question of fact and degree in the total circumstances of each case. The Court also held that no argument was directed at the Judge's finding as to the sum owed by Mr Bisht to Parkhurst for outgoings and the sum owed by Parkhurst to Mr Bisht for the wrongful retention of chattels and was not prepared to disturb the Judge's finding in this regard.

The appeal was allowed against the award of damages for loss of a chance and the judgment of $66,360.93 awarded in the District Court was quashed. The Court substituted an award to Mr Bisht against Parkhurst in the sum of $11,360.93 and held that the appellant was entitled to 2B costs and disbursements in this Court. The Court remitted the question of costs to the District Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established