Paki v Ministry of Social Development

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

CRI 2012-470-36 [2012] NZHC 2803

BETWEEN  HEMI TE AREA TE KAPO PAKI Appellant

ANDMINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT Respondent

Hearing:         24 October 2012

Counsel:         J M Smylie for Appellant

H G Sheridan for Respondent

Judgment:      24 October 2012

JUDGMENT OF KEANE J

Solicitors

Crown Solicitor, Tauranga

Counsel

J L Smylie, Tauranga: jim@smylie.co.nz

HEMI TE AREA TE KAPO PAKI V MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT HC TAU CRI 2012-470-36 [24

October 2012]

[1]      On 11 September 2012 Hemi Paki was sentenced to imprisonment for one year, eight months, for 18 offences involving welfare benefit fraud between 2 August

1999 - 14 January 2011, some 12 years: five offences of using a forged document, four of dishonest use of a document, and the balance obtaining by deception.

[2]      According to the uncontested statement of facts on sentence, Mr Paki, a beneficiary since  1997,  had  received  throughout  an  accommodation  and  related supplements, to which he was not entitled, totalling $51,000.

[3]      In 18 instances, on applications and on reviews, he had held out that he needed these supplements to meet his rent, when that was not true. In five, the first in

1999, the last in 2010, he relied on forged tenancy agreements. In that last instance on a forged letter as well. In this, as the Judge said on sentence, he was systematic and deliberate.

[4]      On this appeal against sentence the Judge's decision to imprison Mr Paki is not in issue. The Judge would have imposed home detention if Mr Paki had been able to identify a suitable address. The Judge did grant Mr Paki leave to apply for home detention if during the course of his sentence he obtained one.

[5]      The question on this appeal is whether, as Mr Paki contends, the term of imprisonment the Judge imposed on him was manifestly excessive. The Judge, he contends, took too high a starting point, as the Judge said, between 24 - 30 months. It ought, he contends, not to have been any higher than 15 - 18 months. With a full 25 per cent discount for plea, he contends, his sentence ought not to have been more than 13 - 14 months imprisonment.

[6]      The Ministry contends, by contrast, that the sentence the Judge imposed was open in principle and proportion. The Judge's actual starting point, given the end sentence and a full discount for plea, must have been 26 - 27 months. Even if she had taken a  starting point of 18 - 24 months, the Ministry contends Mr Paki's previous convictions might have justified a modest uplift. The Judge did give a full 25 per cent discount for plea.

[7]      As this Court said in Hogan v Ministry of Social Development,[1]  there is no tariff for benefit fraud, just as there is none for other forms of fraud. The amount obtained is one factor. The period over which it is obtained another. What impelled the offender, whether it was need…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paki v Ministry of Social Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2803
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard an appeal brought by Hemi Te Area Te Kapo Paki against a sentence imposed by a lower court. The appellant, Paki, was sentenced to imprisonment for a total of one year and eight months for 18 offences related to welfare benefit fraud. The nature of the dispute involved the appellant arguing that the term of imprisonment imposed on him was manifestly excessive. The Ministry of Social Development argued that the sentence was open in principle and proportion.

The legal issues before the court were whether the term of imprisonment imposed on Paki was manifestly excessive and whether the Judge's starting point for the sentence was too high. The court considered the amount obtained through the fraud, the period over which it was obtained, the motive behind the fraud, and the appellant's previous convictions.

The court found that the sentence imposed was both specific to the case and sensibly within the range imposed in other generally similar cases. The court considered two cases that were similar to the present case, in which starting points of 15 months and two years were upheld on appeal. The court found that a starting point in the range of 18 months, even two years, could not be considered excessive. The court also considered the appellant's previous convictions, which were numerous but did not necessarily require an uplift in the starting point. The court found that the sentence imposed was right at the highest end of the range available to the Judge, consistent with proportion and principle. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed.

The court's reasoning and outcome demonstrate the importance of considering the specific circumstances of each case when imposing a sentence for welfare benefit fraud. The court found that the sentence imposed was not manifestly excessive and was consistent with proportion and principle. The appeal was dismissed, and the original sentence was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established