Paki v Maori Land Court

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

CIV-2014-454-31 [2015] NZHC 2535

UNDER the Judicature Amendment Act 1972

IN THE MATTER

of a decision of the Māori Land Court dated 26 November 2012 and actions of the other defendants between that date and

4 August 2013

BETWEEN

COLIN POTANGOTANGO HANITA PAKI

Plaintiff

AND

MAORI LAND COURT First Defendant

JONATHAN PROCTOR AND OTHERS Second Defendants

HOROWHENUA DISTRICT COUNCIL Third Defendant

HORIZONS REGIONAL COUNCIL Fourth Defendant

THE LAKE HOROWHENUA DOMAIN BOARD

Fifth Defendant

DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF CONSERVATION

Sixth defendant

Hearing:

23 March 2015

(Final post-trial materials received 17 June 2015)

Counsel:

G D S Taylor for Plaintiff
No appearance for First and Second Defendants
D G Randal and L M Bazalo for Third and Fifth Defendants
S Johnston for Fourth Defendant
K Muller and H Baille for Sixth Defendant

Judgment:

14 October 2015

PAKI v MAORI LAND COURT [2015] NZHC 2535 [14 October 2015]

JUDGMENT OF CLIFFORD J

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction ............................................................................................................. [1] Context ..................................................................................................................... [9] Participation at the hearing ................................................................................. [41] Did the Māori Land Court have power to declare terms for the Lake Horowhenua Trust as it purported to do in the 2012 Decision? ....................... [51] If the Māori Land Court did have that power, is its decision doing so void for error in law? .......................................................................................................... [92] Was the Domain Board properly constituted when it decided to enter into the Accord? .................................................................................................................. [95] Costs ..................................................................................................................... [106]

Introduction

[1]      The plaintiff, Colin Paki, is a member of the Muaupoko iwi of Horowhenua.

[2]      The bed of Lake Horowhenua, together with what is now known as the dewatered area1  (a further one-chain strip of land around the original margin of the Lake and the bed of the Hokio Stream and certain adjoining lands) are owned by the second defendants in trust (the Lake Horowhenua Trust) for members of Muaupoko who have beneficial interests in land within the Horowhenua XI block.

[3]      Mr Paki is one such member of Muaupoko.

[4]      Lake Horowhenua is a much degraded, shallow, coastal lake.   It was not always so.   In August 2013 the second to sixth defendants entered into an accord providing for the restoration of Lake Horowhenua as “taonga that holds pride of place in the Horowhenua community” (the Accord).

[5]      In these proceedings Mr Paki challenges the Accord by reference to what he terms six reviewable actions.  In effect he says that:

(a)      the trustees of the Lake Horowhenua Trust, the second defendants, acted unlawfully in agreeing to the Accord, because the Lake Horowhenua Trust is currently unlawfully constituted by reason of the unlawfulness of the Māori2  Land Court’s decision on 26 November

2012 (the 2012 Decision)3; and

(b)the  Domain  Board,  the  fifth  defendant,  acted  unlawfully  when  it decided to enter into the Accord, because it did not act in accordance with   provisions   relating  to   the   role   of   the   representatives   of Muaupoko.

[6]      By agreement, the parties have asked the Court to consider, as provided by subpart 4 of Part 10 of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paki v Maori Land Court and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 2535
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves Colin Paki, a member of the Muaupoko iwi of Horowhenua, challenging the restoration agreement (Accord) for Lake Horowhenua, signed in August 2013 by the trustees of the Lake Horowhenua Trust (second defendants), the Lake Horowhenua Domain Board (fifth defendant), the Horowhenua District Council (third defendant), the Horizons Regional Council (fourth defendant), and the Director-General of Conservation (sixth defendant). The plaintiff argues that the trustees of the Lake Horowhenua Trust acted unlawfully and that the Domain Board was not properly constituted when it decided to enter into the Accord. The High Court was asked to consider three preliminary questions: whether the Māori Land Court had the power to declare terms for the Lake Horowhenua Trust, whether that decision was void for error in law, and whether the Domain Board was properly constituted when it decided to enter into the Accord. The Court found that the Māori Land Court had the jurisdiction to declare terms for the Lake Horowhenua Trust, that there was no error in law in the Court's decision, and that the Domain Board was properly constituted when it made its decision to enter into the Accord. The Court's decision was based on the special jurisdiction of the Māori Land Court over trusts of Māori land, the provisions of the Reserves and Other Lands Disposal Act 1956, and the terms of the Reserves Act 1977 that apply to meetings of domain boards.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established