Paine v Carter Holt Harvey Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2018-404-001143

[2019] NZHC 2477

UNDER the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993, Fair Trading Act 1986 and High Court Rule 4.24

BETWEEN

DAVID ERIC PAINE and LYNDA CAROLINE BOWERS

First Plaintiffs

KEVIN BRYAN START and FLORENCE ELIZABETH START

Second Plaintiffs

.../Third and Fourth Plaintiffs cont over page

AND

CARTER HOLT HARVEY LIMITED

Defendant

AND

AUCKLAND COUNCIL & ORS

First to Twenty-Ninth Third Parties

Hearing: On the papers

Judgment:

1 October 2019


JUDGMENT OF DOWNS J


This judgment was delivered by me on Tuesday, 1 October 2019 at 11 am pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

Adina Thorn Ltd, Auckland. LeeSalmonLong, Auckland. Heaney & Partners, Auckland. AS Ross QC, Auckland.

JG Miles QC, Auckland.

PAINE v CARTER HOLT HARVEY LIMITED [2019] NZHC 2477 [1 October 2019]

DONALD BRAMWELL JACKSON and HEATHER MAY PROCTOR JACKSON, and DONALD

BRAMWELL JACKSON, HEATHER MAY PROCTOR JACKSON and HOLLAND BECKETT TRUSTEE
No.11 LIMITED as trustees of the Jackson Family Trust 2011

Third Plaintiffs

STEPHEN MATHEW DEVCICH, JESSIE DIANA DEVCICH and JOHNNY CHARLES AUGUST as

trustees of the Devcich Family Trust Fourth Plaintiffs

[1]    In July this year, I dismissed applications by Carter Holt Harvey Ltd1 to stay or dismiss the plaintiffs’ claim.2 Carter Holt argued the claim had been brought without the Court’s permission under r 4.24(a) of the High Court Rules 2016; the plaintiffs’ solicitor made misleading statements when promoting the claim; and funding arrangements were objectionable. I found the plaintiffs’ solicitor misled potential claimants in one media interview, but otherwise rejected Carter Holt’s arguments. Knowledge of that judgment is assumed.

[2]Carter Holt seeks permission to appeal. The plaintiffs contest permission.

[3]    The requirement for permission in this context acts as a “filtering mechanism” of  unmeritorious  appeals  that  would   otherwise   cause   unnecessary   delay.3   The Court of Appeal has said permission should be granted when:4

… the significance or implications of an arguable error of fact or law, either for the particular case or for the applicant or as a matter of precedent, warrants the further delay which the appeal process would involve.

[4]I decline permission for three, closely related reasons.

[5]    First, contrary to Carter Holt’s submission, the proposed appeal is not “credible”. Its case in relation to r 4.24(a) is inconsistent with the plain language of the rule. And, unsupported by authority. Its case in relation to the conduct of the plaintiffs’ solicitor seeks to impugn factual findings, and exhorts a remedy “hopelessly disproportionate” to any wrong, even assuming the conduct amounted to an abuse of process.5 Its case in relation to funding arrangements confronts the proposition these are unremarkable.

[6]    The recent decision of the Court of Appeal in Ross v Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd does not alter the mix.6 Ross is about r 4.24(b), not r 4.24(a). The plaintiffs’ claim is governed by the latter, not the former. The Court of Appeal’s


1      Carter Holt.

2      Paine v Carter…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paine v Carter Holt Harvey Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 2477
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Paine v Carter Holt Harvey Limited, the plaintiffs, including David Eric Paine and Lynda Caroline Bowers, sought to pursue a claim against the defendant, Carter Holt Harvey Limited, under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993, Fair Trading Act 1986, and High Court Rule 4.24. The plaintiffs were represented by Adina Thorn Ltd, Lee Salmon Long, and Heaney & Partners, while Carter Holt Harvey Limited was represented by AS Ross QC and JG Miles QC. Auckland Council and others were also involved as third parties in the case. The central issue before the court was whether the defendant, Carter Holt Harvey Limited, should be granted permission to appeal the earlier decision dismissing their applications to stay or dismiss the plaintiffs' claim. The plaintiffs contested the defendant's request for permission to appeal.

The court addressed several legal issues in its reasoning, including the credibility of the defendant's proposed appeal, the significance of the errors in fact or law that the defendant sought to address, and the potential delay and disruption that the appeal might cause. The court found that the defendant's proposed appeal was not credible as it relied on inconsistent and unsupported arguments. Additionally, the court noted that the defendant had not made an obvious effort to filter its proposed arguments and had made no visible attempt to marshal interlocutory issues efficiently. The plaintiffs argued that the defendant seemed determined to pursue every possible right of appeal, irrespective of its merits. The court also considered the recent decision of the Court of Appeal in Ross v Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd and concluded that it did not alter the mix of the arguments presented.

Based on its reasoning, the court declined to grant permission for the defendant to appeal. The court found that the proposed appeal would not warrant the further delay and disruption that the appeal process would involve. The court also considered the plaintiffs' entitlement to costs and instructed the parties to file memoranda if they disagreed on the issue. The court's decision effectively dismissed the defendant's application for permission to appeal and maintained the earlier ruling that denied the defendant's applications to stay or dismiss the plaintiffs' claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.