PAE (New Zealand) Ltd v Brosnahan

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA616/2008
[2009] NZCA 105

BETWEENPAE (NEW ZEALAND) LIMITED


Appellant

ANDMARK DAVID BROSNAHAN


First Respondent

ANDMICHAEL RALPH CARTER


Second Respondent

ANDWAYNE ALBANY PATTINSON


Third Respondent

Hearing:17 March 2009

Court:O'Regan, Arnold and Ellen France JJ

Counsel:P O'Neil for Appellant (Respondent in the present application)


J D Every-Palmer for Respondents (Applicants in the present application)

Judgment:1 April 2009 at 11.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AWe grant to the respondents an extension of time to file a memorandum setting out the grounds upon which the respondents intend to support the judgment appealed against.

B        We make no award of costs.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by O’Regan J)

[1]       PAE (New Zealand) Limited (PAE) purchased shares in Central Property Services Limited (CPS), of which Messrs Brosnahan, Carter and Pattinson were directors and shareholders (we will call them “the directors”).  PAE alleged that the financial and accounting information supplied to PAE during negotiations was inaccurate.  PAE sought damages of approximately $960,000 for the overstatement of CPS’s assets.  The directors counter-claimed for payment of $350,000 under the sale and purchase agreement.

[2]       In the High Court, the directors were for the most part successful: PAE (New Zealand) Ltd v Brosnahan HC WN CIV-2005-485-843 10 September 2008.  PAE’s causes of action based on fraudulent misrepresentation, innocent or negligent misrepresentation, and misleading and deceptive conduct failed, although it did establish a breach of warranty and was awarded approximately $202,000.  The directors’ counterclaim was successful.

[3]       In her judgment, Mallon J made a number of adverse findings as to the behaviour of one of the directors, Mr Carter, after the sale.  At [249] of the judgment, for example, she concluded that the evidence pointed “strongly to the deliberate concealing of information” by Mr Carter.  In a subsequent costs judgment issued on 7 November 2008, the Judge relied on this conduct (at [17]) in reaching the conclusion that costs should lie where they fell.

[4]       On 6 October 2008, PAE appealed against the substantive judgment.  The directors now seek an extension of time to file a memorandum supporting the judgment on other grounds, namely that:

(a)       Mr Carter’s post-sale conduct was not improper;

(b)       the Judge incorrectly assessed the value of CPS; and

(c)the Judge incorrectly held each director jointly liable for all of the misrepresentations made by his fellow directors.

[5]       This application was filed on 18 December, approximately eight weeks out of time (the time for filing under r 33 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005 having expired on 20 October). 

[6]       Counsel for the directors, Mr Every-Palmer, submitted that the application to file the memorandum supporting the judgment on other grounds was filed as soon as practicable in the circumstances.  In particular, he said that it was only when the costs judgment was issued that it became apparent, due to the weight the Judge gave to Mr Carter’s conduct, that the directors’ interests could possibly diverge.  It was only after this potential conflict was resolved, during…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PAE (New Zealand) Ltd v Brosnahan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZCA 105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

PAE (New Zealand) Limited filed an appeal against the High Court decision that was unfavourable to them in a dispute with Messrs Brosnahan, Carter, and Pattinson over the sale of shares in Central Property Services Limited (CPS). The directors had counterclaimed for payment of $350,000 under the sale and purchase agreement. The directors had filed a memorandum in support of the judgment, but it was filed eight weeks late. The directors sought an extension of time to file a memorandum setting out the grounds upon which they intended to support the judgment on other grounds.

The directors argued that the memorandum was filed as soon as practicable in the circumstances, and it was only after the costs judgment was issued that it became apparent that the substantive judgment was supportable on the further grounds listed above. The directors contended that it was in the interests of justice for the Court to grant their application. PAE opposed any extension of time and submitted that the proposed grounds were without merit. PAE said that if the application were granted, this would widen the scope of the appeal, which would be detrimental to them.

The Court of Appeal found it surprising that counsel were unable to agree to an extension of time in these circumstances. The Court did not see the directors' memorandum as a substantial expansion of the scope of the appeal. Even if it does lead to additional hearing time, that could, in appropriate circumstances, be relevant when the Court determined costs. Nor did the Court believe the grounds specified at [4] above can be fairly characterised at this stage as being without merit. Of course, whether they are ultimately found to have merit will be for the Court which hears the appeal to determine. The Court granted the extension of time sought by the directors. The Court made no award of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established