P v R HC Wanganui CRI 2010-483-11

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WANGANUI REGISTRY

CRI 2010-483-11

BETWEEN  K  P Appellant

ANDQUEEN Respondent

Hearing:         30 March 2010

Counsel:         M Bullock for Appellant

L C Rowe for Respondent

Judgment:      16 April 2010

JUDGMENT OF MILLER J

[1]      P  was  16  years  of  age  when  she  appeared  for  sentence  on  charges  of aggravated robbery, robbery and possession of cannabis.  She admitted the charges in the Youth Court and was transferred to the District Court for sentence.  There she received two and a half years imprisonment on the aggravated robbery charge and was convicted and discharged on the other two.

[2]      After the hearing I dismissed the appeal and gave leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.  These are my reasons.

[3]      The appeal confronts, not for the first time, the relationship between tariff sentencing decisions, in this case R v Mako,[1]  and youth justice principles when a youth happens to be sentenced in an adult Court.  Judge Becroft followed a decision

of mine, R v Patea-Glendinning, to the effect that youth justice principles do not

K   P   V R HC WANG CRI 2010-483-11 16 April 2010

apply directly;  rather, youth is treated as a mitigating factor.[2]   He took that approach reluctantly, holding:[3]

If  I  could  have  gone  lower,  I would  have  done.    Home  detention  was recommended in the probation report.   If I did not feel constrained by the tariff approach, if I did not feel forced to proceed today on the basis that youth justice principles do not apply as a matter of law, I would have made a reduction for youth of at least 40 percent, which when coupled with the 33 percent deduction for an early guilty plea, would have bought you under two years, and home detention would have applied.  I would have granted it.  But I regret that I cannot do so.     The end sentence is two and a half years imprisonment.

[2] R v Patea-Glendinning (2006) 22 CRNZ 959.

[3] At [57].

[4]      I adopt the Judge’s discussion of the facts, which are not in dispute.  There were two separate incidents.  The first in time was the robbery, which occurred at the Woburn railway station on 7 February 2009, when P was 15:[4]

[4] At [11]-[13].

You and your friends had been drinking and were throwing and smashing empty bottles around the railway station. There were others waiting at the station to catch the train.  Some within that group came and confronted you and your friends about what you were doing.   You were joined by your brother and his friends and while they were assaulting some in the group who had confronted you, you grabbed another in that group from behind and placed that person, a woman, in a headlock.   She was an 18-year-old Australian tourist.

You punched her in the face with a closed fist three times and knocked her to the ground.   You grabbed her shoulder bag, walked off…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read P v R HC Wanganui CRI 2010-483-11 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 1021
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand at Wanganui, the appellant, K P, challenged the sentence imposed by the District Court for charges of aggravated robbery, robbery, and possession of cannabis. The District Court sentenced P to two and a half years in prison for aggravated robbery and discharged her on the other two charges. P appealed against the severity of the sentence, arguing that it did not adequately consider her youth as a mitigating factor. P admitted to the charges in the Youth Court and was transferred to the District Court for sentencing.

The central legal issue in this appeal was the relationship between tariff sentencing decisions and youth justice principles when a youth is sentenced in an adult court. The appellant argued that the Youth Court's sentencing principles should apply, which allow for more tailored sentencing to facilitate rehabilitation and reintegration into society. The respondent contended that tariff sentencing principles, specifically those established in R v Mako, should govern the case, treating youth primarily as a mitigating factor rather than a principle that directly influences sentencing.

The court determined that while youth justice principles do not directly apply to sentencing in an adult court, age must be considered as a mitigating factor. The sentencing judge had acknowledged the appellant's developmental lag and immaturity but had limited the discount for youth to 25%, citing long-standing sentencing practice and the appellant's bleak prospects for rehabilitation. The court found that the judge's approach, while reflecting sentencing practice, did not err in law. The judge's decision to limit the discount for youth, given the appellant's circumstances, was deemed appropriate under the Sentencing Act 2002 and the precedent set in R v Mako.

The appeal was dismissed, and the sentence was upheld as not manifestly excessive. The court recognised the significant impact of the offenses on the victims but concluded that the sentence imposed was proportionate and consistent with the sentencing guidelines for aggravated robbery.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established