P v Police HC Nelson Cri-2007-442-8

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CRI-2007-442-000008

BETWEEN  P

Appellant

AND  NEW ZEALAND POLICE Respondent

Hearing:         4 October 2007

Counsel:        H W Riddoch for Appellant

H Boyd-Wilson for Respondent

Judgment:      4 October 2007

ORAL JUDGMENT OF WILD J

[1]      This is an appeal against refusal of name suppression pending trial.   The refusal was by Judge Zohrab in the District Court at Nelson on 24 July.

[2]      The appellant faces seven charges of indecent assault involving four separate female complainants over the 34 years between December 1951 and December 1985.

[3]      The appellant has pleaded not guilty to all the charges.  There presently is no date for a depositions hearing.   In fact Mr Riddoch advises me that there are no briefs of evidence yet.   It is for that reason that an application by the appellant to have the complainants present for cross-examination at the depositions hearing has been adjourned, at present to 17 October.

[4]      In advancing the appeal this morning Mr Riddoch placed it on a slightly narrower basis, seeking interim suppression at this stage only until the depositions hearing.

P V NEW ZEALAND POLICE HC NEL CRI-2007-442-000008  4 October 2007

[5]      The Judge’s power to  suppress publication of the  appellant’s  name  is  in s140(1) Criminal Justice Act 1985.   The leading guidance on the exercise of that power is to be found in the Court of Appeal’s decisions in R v Liddell [1995] 1

NZLR 538 at 546 and in Lewis v Wilson & Horton & Ors [2000] 3 NZLR 546 at [43]. In relation to suppression pre-trial there are also the Court of Appeal’s decision in Proctor v R [1997] 1 NZLR 295 at 298, and the judgment of Fisher J in this Court in M v Police (1991) 8 CRNZ 14 at 15-16.

[6]      Mr Riddoch also referred me to the judgment of Priestley J in GAP v Police HC ROT CRI-2006-463-68 23 August 2006, as a recent and thorough exposition of the considerations where the issue is suppression pre-trial.

[7]      The s140(1) power to prohibit publication of the name of a person accused or convicted of a criminal offence is a discretionary one.  The section provides that a Court “may” make an order prohibiting publication.  The familiar principles relating to an appeal from the exercise of a discretionary power therefore apply.  They are set out in May v May (1982) 1 NZFLR 165 (CA).  Although Priestley J in GAP v Police did not explicitly approach the appeal he was dealing with on those principles, he found an error of principle in the District Court Judge’s approach.  He considered the Judge had erroneously treated the principle of open justice as so irrebuttable as to be “fundamental”, rather than as a presumption which could be displaced, albeit with difficulty.   It was on that basis that he embarked on what  was essentially a re- exercise of the discretion, allowing the appeal and granting the appellant interim name suppression.

[8]      Here,  I  invited…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read P v Police HC Nelson Cri-2007-442-8 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZHC 1005
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in P v Police HC Nelson Cri-2007-442-8 was brought against the refusal of name suppression pending trial, which was decided by Judge Zohrab in the District Court at Nelson on 24 July. The appellant faces multiple charges of indecent assault involving four female complainants over a period of 34 years. The appellant has pleaded not guilty to all charges and there is currently no date set for a depositions hearing. The appellant's counsel, Mr Riddoch, narrowed the basis of the appeal to seek interim suppression of the appellant's name until the depositions hearing.

The legal issue before the court was whether the Judge’s refusal to suppress the appellant’s name pending trial was justified. The court considered the principles set out in previous cases such as R v Liddell, Lewis v Wilson & Horton & Ors, Proctor v R, and M v Police. The court also referred to the judgment in GAP v Police, which provided guidance on the considerations for suppression pre-trial. The court found that the Judge’s discretion under section 140(1) of the Criminal Justice Act 1985 was exercised correctly, and that there was no error of principle or oversight of relevant factors. The court considered factors such as the presumption of innocence, the historic nature of the alleged offences, and the appellant's health, but found these did not warrant a departure from the Judge's decision.

The court upheld the Judge's decision, noting that the main factors in favour of publication were the presumption that court proceedings should be open and the potential for publication to assist police inquiries and lead to further complainants coming forward. The court dismissed the appeal, concluding that the appellant’s name may now be published.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established