This case has been anonymized
IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CRI-2009-404-000262
P
Appellant
v
NEW ZEALAND POLICE
Respondent
Hearing: 3 February 2010
Appearances: F Hogan for Appellant
S Duncan for Respondent
Judgment: 5 February 2010 at 2:00 pm
RESERVED JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J
This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 5 February 2010 at 2:00 pm
pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
Registrar / Deputy Registrar
Date...................................
Solicitors: Meredith Connell, P O Box 2213, Auckland
Fax: (09) 336-7629 – S Duncan
Counsel: F P Hogan, Dyke Road, R D 1, Papakura
Fax: (09) 292-7424
P V NZ POLICE HC AK CRI-2009-404-000262 5 February 2010
[1] Following a defended hearing before Wade DCJ in the District Court at Manukau Mr P was convicted on a charge of driving a motor vehicle while the proportion of alcohol in his blood exceeded 100 milligrams of alcohol per 100 millilitres of blood,. It was Mr P ’s second such conviction and he was sentenced to perform 120 hours of community work in addition to a period of disqualification of 12 months. Mr P appeals the community work sentence on the ground that it is manifestly excessive and that a fine was the appropriate sentence.
[2] The Judge’s rationale for imposing the sentence of community work was that a fine would not have the necessary deterrent effect:
[3] You have plainly not learnt your lesson about the dangers of drink driving and I take the view that in those circumstances a fine is not appropriate because you can simply pull out your chequebook, write out a cheque for the fine and forget all about it. I think it needs to be brought home to you that this is a serious offence and for that reason you will be sentenced to perform 120 hours of community work.
[3] Under s 13(1)(a) Sentencing Act 2002 where the Court may impose a fine in addition to or instead of any other sentence it must nevertheless regard a fine as the appropriate sentence unless satisfied that the purpose or purposes for which sentence is being imposed cannot be achieved by imposing a fine. There was no reference to s 13 in the Judge’s sentencing notes but Ms Duncan submitted that it is apparent from that the Judge did take into account the considerations under s 13(1)(a) namely Mr P ’s financial circumstances, and determined that a fine was not appropriate. She submitted that this conclusion was available.
[4] Mr Hogan, for Mr P , produced evidence of Mr P ’s chronic health condition and his employment commitments to show that a community work sentence is inappropriate. This evidence was not before the sentencing Judge. It shows that Mr P has fulltime work commitments as chief executive officer of the Wakatu Incorporation, a Mäori trust. These work commitments and associated social responsibilities involve regular travel and occupy virtually his entire time. Further, Mr P suffers from a fused vertebrae which makes standing…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read P v Police HC Ak Cri-2009-404-262 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NZHC 380
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the sentence of 120 hours of community work was appropriate given Mr P's second conviction for drink driving. The court had to consider whether the sentencing judge adequately applied the criteria set out in the Sentencing Act 2002, particularly whether a fine was the appropriate sentence unless specific conditions were met. The District Court judge had imposed the community work sentence based on the belief that a fine would not sufficiently deter Mr P from reoffending. However, Mr P's counsel argued that a fine would be more appropriate considering Mr P's significant employment commitments as the chief executive officer of a Māori trust and his chronic health condition, which were not taken into account by the sentencing judge.
The court found that the sentencing judge did not adequately consider Mr P's specific circumstances, such as his employment commitments and health condition, which were presented for the first time during the appeal. The court noted that a fine, combined with disqualification, was typically imposed in similar cases of second drink-driving offences. The court concluded that the nature of Mr P's employment and health issues warranted a different sentence, and thus, a fine of $2,000 was deemed more appropriate. The court quashed the community work sentence and imposed a fine instead, while maintaining the disqualification period.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi