Oxygen Air Limited v LG Electronics Australia Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2015-404-2184

[2018] NZHC 3350

BETWEEN

OXYGEN AIR LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

LG ELECTRONICS AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Counsel:

M Black for the Plaintiff

A Holmes on behalf of A Steel for subpoenaed witness

Judgment:

17 December 2018


JUDGMENT OF GORDON J

[As to costs]


This judgment was delivered by me

on 17 December 2018 at 3.00 pm, pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

Solicitors:           Craig, Griffin & Lord, Auckland Counsel:      M Black, Auckland

A Steel, Auckland

A Holmes, Auckland

OXYGEN AIR LTD v LG ELECTRONICS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD [2018] NZHC 3350 [17 December 2018]

Introduction

[1]                This is an application for costs which follows from my decision setting aside a subpoena duces tecum served on a witness, Geoffrey Lim, on behalf of the plaintiff,

Oxygen Air Limited (Oxygen).1

[2]                Mr Lim and Oxygen were unable to agree on costs and each has filed a separate memorandum.

[3]                Mr Lim applies for costs and disbursements as set out in Annexure A to this judgment. As is apparent from the Annexure, Mr Lim also seeks increased costs.

[4]                Oxygen agrees that some of the items are appropriately claimed. It opposes others along with the claim for increased costs.

Background

[5]                Oxygen formerly distributed and installed LG Electronics Australia Pty Ltd (LG) air-conditioning and heat pump systems in New Zealand.

[6]                Oxygen brought proceedings against LG claiming that LG breached its supply and distribution agreement with Oxygen in a number of ways, one of which was that it supplied products to other distributors in breach of the exclusivity clause in the agreement. Oxygen also alleges a breach of a further agreement with LG by which it says LG granted Oxygen distribution rights to LG solar panel products. Finally, Oxygen alleges that LG engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct in breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986.

[7]                Mr Lim is a director of I Fix 4U Services Limited which was formerly known as I Fix 4U Limited. Mr Lim’s position is that I Fix 4U was, and remains, a general service agent for LG.


1      Oxygen Air Ltd v LG Electronics Australia Pty Ltd [2018] NZHC 2912.

[8]                Oxygen’s  claims against  LG  were for hearing on 29 October 2018.   On     8 October 2018, Oxygen served a subpoena duces tecum on Mr Lim. Both LG and Mr Lim separately applied to set aside that subpoena.2

[9]                The applications were opposed by Oxygen.  It also sought a direction under   r 9.10 of the High Court Rules that each of the three witnesses gives oral evidence at the trial.

[10]            The applications were called on 29 October 2018, which was to have been the first day of the trial. On that day, the trial was adjourned. The applications therefore proceeded on a pre-trial basis later in the week, on 1 November 2018.

[11]            I granted the application on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oxygen Air Limited v LG Electronics Australia Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 3350
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerns an application for costs which follows from a decision to set aside a subpoena duces tecum served on a witness, Geoffrey Lim, on behalf of the plaintiff, Oxygen Air Limited (Oxygen). Mr Lim and Oxygen were unable to agree on costs, and each has filed a separate memorandum. Mr Lim applies for costs and disbursements as set out in Annexure A to this judgment. Oxygen agrees that some of the items are appropriately claimed. It opposes others along with the claim for increased costs.

Oxygen brought proceedings against LG Electronics Australia Pty Ltd (LG) claiming that LG breached its supply and distribution agreement with Oxygen in a number of ways, one of which was that it supplied products to other distributors in breach of the exclusivity clause in the agreement. Oxygen also alleges a breach of a further agreement with LG by which it says LG granted Oxygen distribution rights to LG solar panel products. Finally, Oxygen alleges that LG engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct in breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986. Mr Lim is a director of I Fix 4U Services Limited which was formerly known as I Fix 4U Limited. Mr Lim’s position is that I Fix 4U was, and remains, a general service agent for LG. Oxygen’s claims against LG were for hearing on 29 October 2018. On 8 October 2018, Oxygen served a subpoena duces tecum on Mr Lim. Both LG and Mr Lim separately applied to set aside that subpoena. The applications were opposed by Oxygen. It also sought a direction under r 9.10 of the High Court Rules that each of the three witnesses gives oral evidence at the trial. The applications were called on 29 October 2018, which was to have been the first day of the trial. On that day, the trial was adjourned. The applications therefore proceeded on a pre-trial basis later in the week, on 1 November 2018. The Court granted the application on behalf of Mr Lim to set aside his witness subpoena. It also granted the application by LG, to the extent it related to Mr Lim’s witness subpoena. The Court refused the application by Oxygen for a direction that Mr Lim give oral evidence at trial.

Costs are at the discretion of the Court. The general principle is that the party who fails with respect to a proceeding should pay costs to the successful party. But the overriding consideration when exercising the discretion to award costs is that any award ought to do justice between the parties. The Court will work through each of the items in Annexure A that is opposed. The Court will then address the claim for increased costs. The Court found that there were inadequate efforts to brief Mr Lim before the subpoena was issued. In relation to the subpoena itself, there were two categories of documents sought. The subpoena was issued in the following terms: You are ordered to bring with you and produce at the same time and place any records and any information held relating to the period from January 2010 to 14 August 2015 of the following: 2.1 LG’s invoices and summaries of the same to I Fix 4U Limited for the purchase of LG air-conditioning units from LG NZ Limited. 2.2 All LG warranty and installation records, including parts purchased from LG for air-conditioning units. During the course of the hearing, Oxygen changed its position in relation to the two categories of documents. The Court was advised that Oxygen no longer required Mr Lim to produce any documents falling under the description in 2.2 of the subpoena. In relation to 2.1, Oxygen’s position was that it should be amended to read: Summaries of LG’s invoices to I Fix 4U Limited for the purchase of LG air-conditioning units from LG NZ Limited. In other words, Oxygen no longer sought copies of the actual invoices. The Court held that the subpoena as it related to the production of documents was an abuse of process and should be set aside as it went behind discovery orders and the position adopted by Oxygen in relation to third party discovery. Second, it would require Mr Lim to create (or at least obtain) a document which he does not have, covering five and a half years of transactions. A further reason in support was that such a summary already existed and was in the hands of Oxygen through the process of discovery. The Court bears in mind the statement by Kós J referred to in [37] above that inherent demerit does not itself cast the proceedings into r 14.6(3) (increased costs) consideration. However, the Court accepts Mr Holmes’ submission that Mr Lim acted reasonably in relation to the subpoena. The Court considers that those factors do provide the basis for increased costs, but the 33 per cent uplift sought is too high. In the Court’s view, an uplift of 20 per cent is sufficient.

The Court therefore awards costs on a category 2, band B basis in the sum of $4,014.00 and disbursements in the sum of $550.00, totalling $4,564.00, against Oxygen in favour of Mr Lim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established