Osborne v Worksafe New Zealand

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2014-485-11211 [2015] NZHC 264

UNDER the Judicature Amendment Act 1972

IN THE MATTER OF

an application for judicial review of decisions under s 185 and s 188 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 and s 68 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957

BETWEEN

ANNA ELIZABETH OSBORNE First Applicant

SONYA LYNNE ROCKHOUSE Second Applicant

AND

WORKSAFE NEW ZEALAND First Respondent

DISTRICT COURT AT WELLINGTON Second Respondent

Hearing: 11 February 2015

Counsel:

P Cranney and S N Meikle for applicants
J Holden and A Boadita-Cormican for respondents

Judgment:

24 February 2015

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[1]      This proceeding is brought by the widow and mother respectively of two of the 29 men killed in the disaster at the Pike River coal mine near Greymouth on

19 November 2010.   They seek judicial review of the decision made by the first respondent (Worksafe) to not offer evidence in relation to informations laid against Mr Peter Whittall under the Worksafe New Zealand Act 2013.  Mr Whittall was an employee and officer of Pike River Coal Limited, the operator of the Pike River coal

mine.

OSBORNE v WORKSAFE NEW ZEALAND [2015] NZHC 264 [24 February 2015]

[2]      Worksafe has provided discovery of documents relevant to the circumstances in which the decision not to offer evidence was made.  That decision was part of an arrangement that included a commitment procured by Mr Whittall for the company’s insurers to make a payment into Court of $3.41 million in reparation to the families of the men who died.   Worksafe has waived privilege in the sequence of correspondence entered into between Mr Brent Stanaway, the Crown Solicitor in Christchurch who was prosecuting the informations for Worksafe, and Mr Stuart Grieve QC, counsel briefed to defend Mr Whittall. Worksafe’s waiver of privilege in the exchanges of correspondence occurred after Mr Grieve invited Worksafe to treat privilege as waived in the exchanges, to clarify apparent public misconceptions as to the terms on which the proposals for settlement had been advanced and dealt with.

[3]      However, Worksafe has declined to waive privilege in relation to file notes made by Mr Stanaway.   The file notes recorded matters discussed  in  telephone discussions and meetings that he had with Mr Grieve about these prosecutions.  The applicants dispute the entitlement of Worksafe to withhold the file notes from inspection.  This judgment deals with the issue of whether Worksafe is entitled to assert some form of privilege, or to claim confidentiality in respect of the file notes so as to justify withholding them from inspection.

[4]      The present application also raised the discoverability and admissibility of the content of the District Court file, as well as the correspondence that had been exchanged on a without prejudice basis between Messrs Stanaway and Grieve.  The parties have agreed a process for the listing of the content of the District Court file, and no orders are required in that regard.

[5]      As to the context in which Mr Stanaway came to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Osborne v Worksafe New Zealand and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 264
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Anna Elizabeth Osborne and Sonya Lynne Rockhouse, sought judicial review of decisions made by Worksafe New Zealand not to offer evidence in relation to informations laid against Mr Peter Whittall under the Worksafe New Zealand Act 2013. Mr Whittall was an employee and officer of Pike River Coal Limited, the operator of the Pike River coal mine, where a disaster resulted in the deaths of 29 men on 19 November 2010. The applicants disputed Worksafe's entitlement to withhold file notes from inspection, which were made by Mr Brent Stanaway, the Crown Solicitor prosecuting the informations for Worksafe, and which contained information from discussions with Mr Stuart Grieve, QC, counsel briefed to defend Mr Whittall. The applicants argued that the file notes should be disclosed as they may have contained information that could have influenced the decision, but which was not reflected in the correspondence. The court was required to decide whether Worksafe was entitled to assert some form of privilege or claim confidentiality in respect of the file notes, thereby justifying their withholding from inspection.

The court found that the file notes were not irrelevant and that Worksafe could not rely on litigation privilege as codified in s 56 of the Evidence Act 2006. The court found that the rationale for the privilege codified in s 56 was to protect a litigant from any obligation to disclose preparatory materials to opposing parties in the proceeding to which the preparatory materials relate. The court also found that there was a strong public policy ground for upholding the confidentiality of conversations that practising at the criminal bar consistently treated as confidential and inadmissible when conducted on a "counsel to counsel" basis in attempts to resolve criminal charges. However, the court was not satisfied that protection of the confidentiality of such conversations could properly be achieved by interpreting s 56 as applying to the present circumstances. The court ultimately decided that the application for disclosure of Mr Stanaway's file notes was dismissed.

The court's reasoning was based on the strong public policy grounds for upholding the confidentiality of conversations that those practising at the criminal bar consistently treat as confidential and inadmissible when conducted on a "counsel to counsel" basis in attempts to resolve criminal charges. The court found that to cast doubt on the confidentiality of that practice would have a chilling effect, lessening its utility. The court also considered that it was inappropriate at this stage to overrule a claim to retain confidentiality in the notes of counsel to counsel discussions, on the basis that the argument must inevitably succeed. The court found that it was premature to rule against Worksafe that the negotiations conducted in this case fell outside the scope of principled plea bargaining, so as to deprive the file notes of the protection of confidentiality that would cover them, in case it was ultimately held that the discussions did come within the scope of principled plea bargaining.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established