Osborne v WorkSafe New Zealand

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

23 NOVEMBER 2017

MEDIA RELEASE – FOR IMMEDIATE PUBLICATION

ANNA ELIZABETH OSBORNE AND SONYA LYNNE ROCKHOUSE v WORKSAFE NEW ZEALAND AND THE DISTRICT COURT AT WELLINGTON

(SC 23/2017)     [2017] NZSC 175

PRESS SUMMARY

This summary is provided to assist in the understanding of the Court’s judgment.  It does not comprise part of the reasons for that judgment.  The full judgment with reasons is the only authoritative document.  The full text of the judgment and reasons can be found at Judicial Decisions of Public Interest arrangement that a prosecution will not be brought or maintained on the condition that a sum of money is paid is unlawful because it is contrary to the public interest.  The question in issue on the appeal was whether WorkSafe New Zealand acted to give effect to an unlawful agreement of this nature when it offered no evidence on charges against Peter William Whittall for breaches of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992.  In the High Court and Court of Appeal it was held that the decision to offer no evidence to the charges was not unlawful.  The Supreme Court has unanimously allowed the appeal from the decision of the Court of Appeal.  It has found that the decision to offer no evidence was made under an unlawful agreement to stifle prosecution.  It has granted a declaration to that effect.

The case arises out of the Pike River mining disaster of 19 November 2010 in which 29 men died and two others were injured.  The disaster was later described by WorkSafe as “the employment related disaster of a generation”. 

The Government appointed a Royal Commission to investigate the causes of the explosions at the mine.  The police and the Department of Labour (now WorkSafe) undertook their own investigations to determine whether there had been any criminal offending or breaches of the legislation governing health and safety in employment.  The police investigation was concluded without charges being laid.  The police concluded that there was “insufficient evidence to prove a causal link between the actions of any individual and the specific events which led to the explosion” (as was required for a charge of manslaughter), and that, although there was “enough evidence to support a charge of criminal nuisance”, a prosecution for criminal nuisance would not be in the public interest “given the ongoing prosecutions led by [WorkSafe] under the Health and Safety in Employment Act”.    

Prosecutions by WorkSafe under the Health and Safety in Employment Act were brought against Pike River Coal Ltd and VLI Drilling Ltd, a contractor engaged by Pike River Coal.  At the same time, WorkSafe also laid 12 charges against Mr Whittall, a director and the chief executive officer of Pike River Coal.  The charges against Mr Whittall were laid both on the basis that he had “directed, authorised, assented to, acquiesced in or participated in” the breaches of the Act by Pike River Coal and on the basis of his own alleged breaches of duty as an employee.  The charges…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Osborne v WorkSafe New Zealand and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZSC 175
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of New Zealand heard an appeal by Anna Elizabeth Osborne and Sonya Lynne Rockhouse against WorkSafe New Zealand and the District Court at Wellington. The appellants were seeking a declaration that WorkSafe's decision to offer no evidence in the prosecution of Peter William Whittall for breaches of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992 was unlawful. This decision was taken in the context of the Pike River mining disaster where 29 miners died. The appellants, who lost family members in the disaster, argued that the arrangement to offer no evidence was made under an unlawful agreement to stifle prosecution. WorkSafe had accepted that such an agreement was unlawful but maintained that its decision not to proceed with the prosecution was justified by various considerations, including the conditional offer to pay reparations.

The legal issues before the court included whether WorkSafe's decision to offer no evidence constituted an unlawful agreement to stifle prosecution, and if the decision was made based on other lawful considerations. The High Court and Court of Appeal had previously found that the decision was lawful, holding that WorkSafe was entitled to consider the conditional offer to make payments to the victims. The Supreme Court, however, held that the arrangement to offer no evidence in exchange for the payment constituted an unlawful agreement to stifle prosecution. The Court held that it was irrelevant that WorkSafe considered other factors in reaching the decision, as the payment was in exchange for the withdrawal of the prosecution and was unlawful.

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and found that WorkSafe's decision to offer no evidence was made under an unlawful agreement to stifle prosecution. It granted a declaration to that effect. The Court noted that no other relief was appropriate, given the passage of time. This decision highlights the importance of ensuring that prosecutorial decisions are made in accordance with the law and in the public interest, and not under unlawful agreements.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Osborne v WorkSafe New Zealand concerns the aftermath of the Pike River mining disaster on 19 November 2010, where 29 men died and two were injured. Following the disaster, a Royal Commission was appointed to investigate its causes, and the police and the Department of Labour (now WorkSafe) conducted investigations to determine any criminal offences or breaches of health and safety legislation. The police investigation concluded without charges, while WorkSafe laid charges against Pike River Coal Ltd and VLI Drilling Ltd under the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992, as well as against Peter William Whittall, a director and chief executive officer of Pike River Coal. VLI Drilling pleaded guilty and was fined, while Pike River Coal was convicted on nine charges in April 2013, fined $760,000, and ordered to pay $3.41 million in reparations, which were never paid due to the company being wound up. Discussions for a plea arrangement for Mr Whittall began in mid-2013, where his counsel proposed a payment of reparations instead of a guilty plea. The proposal was accepted by WorkSafe, leading to the decision in November 2013 to discontinue the prosecution against Mr Whittall, considering the payment and other factors not to be in the public interest. The charges against Mr Whittall were dismissed, and the payment was used to meet Pike River Coal's reparation obligation. Anna Osborne and Sonya Rockhouse, who lost family members in the disaster, sought judicial review of WorkSafe's decision, arguing it was taken under an unlawful bargain to stifle prosecution.

The case initially proceeded to the High Court, where the appellants, Anna Osborne and Sonya Rockhouse, sought judicial review of WorkSafe's decision to offer no evidence and the subsequent dismissal of charges against Peter William Whittall. The High Court dismissed their appeal, a decision that was upheld by the Court of Appeal. Dissatisfied with the outcome, the appellants were granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, focusing on whether the Court of Appeal was correct in dismissing their appeal. The Supreme Court unanimously allowed the appeal, finding the arrangement to offer no evidence was indeed an unlawful agreement to stifle prosecution.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the decision by WorkSafe New Zealand to offer no evidence on charges against Peter William Whittall for breaches of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992 was made under an unlawful agreement to stifle prosecution.
2. If the Supreme Court should grant a declaration that WorkSafe's decision to discontinue the prosecution was unlawful, considering the passage of time and the circumstances of the case.

Held
1. The Supreme Court found that the decision by WorkSafe New Zealand to offer no evidence on charges against Peter William Whittall for breaches of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992 was made under an unlawful agreement to stifle prosecution. The appeal was allowed and a declaration to that effect was granted.
2. Considering the passage of time and the circumstances of the case, the Supreme Court held that it was not appropriate to grant a declaration that WorkSafe's decision to discontinue the prosecution was unlawful.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court began by noting that the arrangement between WorkSafe and Mr Whittall's counsel was that Mr Whittall would arrange for the payment of the reparations imposed on Pike River Coal, conditional on the prosecution against him being discontinued. The court considered whether this arrangement constituted an unlawful agreement to stifle prosecution. It was held that the arrangement was indeed unlawful as it involved an agreement to discontinue a prosecution in exchange for payment, which is contrary to the public interest.

The Supreme Court emphasised that it was irrelevant that WorkSafe considered other factors in reaching the decision to offer no evidence. The court stressed that the payment was in exchange for the withdrawal of the prosecution and was therefore unlawful. This principle aligns with the understanding that any arrangement that allows a prosecution to be stifled in exchange for payment is inherently unlawful.

The Supreme Court also considered the passage of time and the circumstances of the case when deciding whether to grant a declaration that WorkSafe's decision to discontinue the prosecution was unlawful. The court concluded that, given the passage of time and the fact that no other relief was appropriate, it was not appropriate to grant such a declaration. The court's decision underscores the importance of considering the timing and context of legal actions, particularly when deciding on the appropriateness of certain remedies.