Ortmann v District Court at North Shore

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2015-404-564 [2015] NZHC 901

UNDER

BETWEEN

Judicature Amendment Act 1972

MATHIAS ORTMANN First Plaintiff

BRAM VAN DER KOLK Second Plaintiff

KIM DOTCOM Third Plaintiff

FINN BATATO Fourth Plaintiff

AND

THE DISTRICT COURT AT NORTH SHORE

First Defendant

THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA Second Defendant

Hearing: 21 and 22 April 2015

Counsel:

G M Illingworth QC, G J Foley and A L Hyde for first and second plaintiffs

R Mansfield and S Cogan for third plaintiff
F Batato in person
J C Gordon QC, M Ruffin and F Sinclair for second defendant

Judgment:

1 May 2015

JUDGMENT OF KATZ J

This judgment was delivered by me on 1 May 2015 at 3:00pm Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Solicitors:               Keegan Alexander, Auckland

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Anderson Creagh Lai Ltd, Auckland

Crown Law Office, Wellington

Counsel:                 J C Gordon QC, Auckland

G M Illingworth QC, Auckland

M Ruffin, Auckland

R Mansfield, Auckland

G J Foley, Auckland

ORTMANN, VAN DER KOLK, DOTCOM, BATATO v THE DISTRICT COURT AT NORTH SHORE [2015] NZHC 901 [1 May 2015]

Table of Contents

Introduction ..........................................................................................................[1]

Is an extradition hearing in June 2015 consistent with the requirements

of natural justice?.................................................................................................[7]

What does natural justice require in this case?  [7]

Have the plaintiffs been given reasonable notice of the case against them?   [10]

Will the plaintiffs have a reasonable opportunity to prepare and present

their case if the extradition hearing takes place in June 2015?  [19] Mr Dotcom’s position  [22] Mr Batato’s position  [36] Messrs Ortmann and van der Kolk’s position  [46]

The alleged errors of law ...................................................................................[54]

The issues  [54]

Did the Judge err by requiring the plaintiffs to support their applications

for oral evidence orders with briefs of proposed evidence and exhibits?       [59]

Did the Judge err by failing to require that any oral evidence order

applications be determined prior to the extradition hearing?  [73]

Did the Judge err by allowing the United States to adduce evidence in

reply?  [79]

Did the Judge err in allowing the United States to file supplementary

ROCs?  [83]

Did the Judge err by allowing the United States to adduce evidence regarding the plaintiffs’ abuse of process application by way of a

supplemental ROC?  [92]

Are the challenged decisions amenable to judicial review?..........................[106] Summary and conclusion ................................................................................ [111] Result ................................................................................................................. [119]

Introduction

[1]      Mathias  Ortmann,  Bram  van  der  Kolk,  Kim  Dotcom  and  Finn Batato, (together, “the plaintiffs”) currently reside in New Zealand.   The United States of America seeks their extradition to face charges of criminal copyright infringement, wire fraud, money laundering and racketeering.  The charges relate to the plaintiffs’ involvement in the Megaupload group of companies.

[2]      Since the plaintiffs arrest in January 2012 there has been extensive related litigation which has impacted (directly or indirectly) on the timing of the extradition hearing.  This has included judicial review proceedings brought by the United States regarding the extent of disclosure it is required to provide (finally determined on

21 March 2014)1…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ortmann v District Court at North Shore and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 901
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mathias Ortmann, Bram van der Kolk, Kim Dotcom, and Finn Batato (the plaintiffs) are residents of New Zealand who face extradition to the United States on charges including copyright infringement, wire fraud, money laundering, and racketeering. The United States of America (the United States) seeks their extradition in connection with their involvement in the Megaupload group of companies. The plaintiffs challenged the timing of the scheduled extradition hearing and sought to judicially review the decision of the District Court at Auckland to decline their application for an adjournment of that hearing. The plaintiffs argued that they had not been given reasonable notice of the case against them, and that they and their legal advisers would be unable to prepare for the hearing due to recent changes in legal representation and insufficient funding. They also argued that the District Court Judge had made a number of errors of law by making timetable directions that were inconsistent with the statutory regime governing the extradition process. The Court held that the plaintiffs had been given proper notice of the case against them, and that the District Court Judge had not made any of the errors of law alleged. The Court did, however, hold that the interests of natural justice required the extradition hearing date to be adjourned. The Court held that Mr Dotcom would not have a reasonable opportunity to prepare and present his case by the scheduled date, and that Mr Batato would be unable to adequately represent himself at the extradition hearing due to the recent withdrawal of his legal advisers and the refusal of his application for legal aid. The Court also held that the preparation of Messrs Ortmann and van der Kolk for the extradition hearing had been impacted by Mr Dotcom’s funding issues, given the collaborative approach taken by the plaintiffs to date. The Court held that the extradition hearing date should be set at a time that would allow the plaintiffs to prepare for the hearing with whatever level of legal support they are able to secure. The Court granted the plaintiffs’ application for judicial review of the District Court decision dated 20 March 2015, in part. The decision not to adjourn the extradition hearing date of 2 June 2015 was quashed. The matter was remitted to the District Court to set a new extradition hearing date, not earlier than 1 September 2015, and to make associated timetable orders. Costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established