Orendowicz v R HC Tauranga CRI 2011-470-13

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

CRI 2011-470-13

BETWEEN  PETER JOHN ORENDOWICZ Appellant

ANDTHE QUEEN Respondent

Hearing:         16 September 2011

Appearances: B Nabney for appellant

J J Rhodes for respondent

Judgment:      26 September 2011

JUDGMENT OF ALLAN J

In accordance with r 11.5 I direct that the Registrar endorse this judgment with the delivery time of 11.30 am on Monday 26 September 2011

Solicitors:

B Nabney, Tauranga,  bill@tgachambers.co.nz

Crown Solicitor Tauranga

PETER JOHN ORENDOWICZ V R HC TAU CRI 2011-470-13 26 September 2011

[1]      Mr Orendowicz appeals against his conviction on charges of possession of cannabis for supply and of possession of equipment for the cultivation of cannabis. The police case was based entirely upon evidence obtained following execution of a search warrant in respect of Mr Orendowicz’s house.   Mr Nabney argues that the warrant ought not to have been issued because the evidence advanced in support of it did not reach the threshold prescribed by s 198 of the Summary Proceedings Act

1957.

[2]      In a second ground of appeal he argues that the evidence did not support a conviction for possession of equipment for the cultivation of cannabis.

Background

[3]      On 4 March 2010, Detective Sgt Verry of the New Zealand Police applied for a search warrant pursuant to s 198 of the Summary Proceedings Act, and s 18(1) of the Misuse of Drugs Act 1975.   The application was accompanied by affidavits sworn on 4 November 2008 by Detective Senior Sgt Hansen, and Detective Sgt Mackie.  The search warrant was issued by the Registrar of the District Court on the date of the application, 4 March 2010, and a search pursuant to the warrant was undertaken at the appellant’s home by police officers on 16 March 2010.

[4]      During the search,  the  police located  some  422  grams  of  cannabis  head material, 373 grams of poor quality leaf material, literature on the use and cultivation of cannabis, a harvest bag, a light shade, an electronic timer and a light bulb.

[5]      The appellant gave evidence at his trial.  He admitted growing cannabis on a prior occasion, some ten years ago, and that the cannabis located on this occasion was his, but claimed that it was for his personal use rather than for sale or supply.

[6]      Mr Nabney challenged the validity of the search warrant in the District Court. On 29 September 2010, the admissibility of the warrant was the subject of a separate preliminary argument before Judge Geoghegan.  The search warrant application was produced.  The application disclosed that the police had been conducting a nation-

wide covert operation investigating the activities of retail stores selling indoor growing equipment, hydroponic equipment, associated nutrients and materials in circumstances that suggested that these items would be used for the cultivation of cannabis. A significant portion of this operation was devoted to an investigation of a chain of retail shops known as “Switched on Gardener”.   The Tauranga shop had been under surveillance by the police for a period prior…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Orendowicz v R HC Tauranga CRI 2011-470-13 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved Peter John Orendowicz, who appealed his conviction for possession of cannabis for supply and possession of equipment for cultivating cannabis. The police case relied entirely on evidence obtained via a search warrant executed at Orendowicz's house. The appeal centred on two main issues: the validity of the search warrant and the sufficiency of the evidence to support the conviction for possession of equipment for cultivating cannabis.

The court had to decide whether the warrant was validly issued under section 198 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957. The warrant was based on evidence from a nationwide covert operation investigating the sale of indoor growing equipment and materials for cultivating cannabis. The police had been surveilling a retail store known as Switched on Gardener and had observed Orendowicz purchasing items from the store. The application for the warrant also cited Orendowicz's previous conviction for cultivating cannabis. The District Court had upheld the warrant's validity, but the appeal court found that the evidence did not meet the threshold required by the Act. The court noted that the evidence was outdated, did not specify what Orendowicz purchased, and did not sufficiently link him to cannabis cultivation at his home.

The court also examined whether the evidence supported a conviction for possession of equipment for cultivating cannabis. However, the court concluded that the evidence was insufficient to establish this charge. Given the deficient evidence supporting the warrant and the subsequent charges, the appeal court held that the warrant was unlawfully issued, rendering the search unreasonable under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.

Applying section 30 of the Evidence Act 2006, the court found that the improperly obtained evidence should be excluded. The court balanced the seriousness of the privacy invasion against the probative value of the evidence and concluded that excluding the evidence was proportionate to the impropriety. Consequently, the court allowed the appeal, set aside the District Court's decision to admit the evidence, quashed Orendowicz's conviction, and acquitted him on both charges.