Oraka Technologies Limited v Napier Tool & Die Co Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

SC 154/2016

[2017] NZSC 79

BETWEEN

ORAKA TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED

First Applicant

ORAKA GRADERS LIMITED
Second Applicant

MICHAEL WILLIAM SCHWARZ
Third Applicant

AND

NAPIER TOOL & DIE CO LIMITED

First Respondent

GEOSTEL VISION LIMITED
Second Respondent

PAUL DAYNES AND GORDON ROBERTSON

Third Respondents

Court: Elias CJ, William Young and Arnold JJ

Counsel:

B P Henry for Applicants

M J Gavin for First Respondent
K T Glover for Second and Third Respondents

Judgment:

26 May 2017


JUDGMENT OF THE COURT (AS TO COSTS)


The applicants are jointly and severally liable to pay costs of $750 to the first respondent and $750 to the second and third respondents, that is, $1,500 in total.


REASONS

[1]    Mr Michael Schwarz invented an asparagus grading machine with a unique cup grader. He assigned the copyright formally to Oraka Technologies Ltd (Technologies), a company of which he and his wife were the sole shareholders and

ORAKA TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED v NAPIER TOOL & DIE CO LIMITED [2017] NZSC 79 [26 May 2017]

directors. Through their involvement with Mr Schwarz in the development of the Oraka grader, Napier Tool & Die Co Ltd (Napier) and Messrs Daynes and Robertson were familiar with it. Messrs Daynes and Robertson set up their own company, Geostel Vision Ltd (Geostel), and started manufacturing a grading machine that competed with the Oraka grader. Their grader incorporated a cup assembly manufactured by Napier that was a substantial copy of the cup assembly used on the Oraka grader. This was held to be a copyright infringement, which continued for almost eight years.

[2]    Before the infringing behaviour began, there were two developments. First, Technologies ceased operating, and the manufacture and sale of the Oraka grader was undertaken by Oraka Technologies Holdings Ltd (Holdings). Then Holdings ceased operating and the manufacture and sale of the grader was taken over by Oraka Graders  Ltd  (Graders),  the  sole  shareholders   and   directors   of   which   were Mr Schwarz’s two adult children.

[3]    In a 2013 appeal, the Court of Appeal concluded that the ownership of the copyright had remained with Technologies throughout and that Napier, Geostel and Messrs Daynes and Robertson (the infringers) had breached its copyright.1  The Court entered judgment accordingly, and remitted the matter back to the High Court for the determination of damages. The damages hearing took place before Hinton J.2 Of the infringers, only Napier participated in that hearing. It did not  contest quantum. Its argument was that the losses which Technologies sought to recover were not its losses but losses incurred by Graders, which had no standing to sue as it was not the owner of the copyright nor did it have an exclusive licence from Technologies to use the copyrighted assembly. Hinton J rejected that argument and entered judgment for Technologies in the amount of $4.1 million against all three infringers. The infringers then filed appeals against that decision.

[4]    The Court of Appeal upheld the infringers’ appeals, setting aside the judgment for $4.1 million.3

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oraka Technologies Limited v Napier Tool & Die Co Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZSC 79
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court was asked to determine the appropriate costs to award in relation to an abandoned application for leave to appeal. The applicants, Oraka Technologies Limited, Oraka Graders Limited, and Mr Michael Schwarz, sought leave to appeal the Court of Appeal’s decision to set aside a $4.1 million judgment for copyright infringement against the respondents, Napier Tool & Die Co Limited, Geostel Vision Limited, and Messrs Daynes and Robertson. The applicants filed their application on 19 December 2016 but abandoned it on 20 February 2017, just six working days before the respondents’ written submissions were due. The respondents applied for indemnity costs on the abandonment of the application for leave to appeal.

The central legal issue was whether the Supreme Court could award indemnity costs against the applicants for the abandonment of their application for leave to appeal, and if so, the appropriate amount. The respondents argued that the abandonment was "fundamentally flawed" and resulted in wasted costs, justifying indemnity costs. The applicants countered that there was a basis in the authorities for their appeal and that they abandoned the application due to concerns about Napier’s asset stripping. The Court had to determine whether the abandonment warranted indemnity costs and, if so, the appropriate amount.

The Court held that the abandonment of an appeal does not affect its power to award costs, and this principle should apply to abandonments of leave applications as well. The Court noted that the abandonment did not distinguish this case from many others and did not justify an award of indemnity costs. Instead, the Court typically awards costs of $2,500 to the respondent on an unsuccessful application for leave that is opposed and dealt with on the papers. Given that the respondents started to prepare submissions before the abandonment, the Court considered a modest award of costs was justified. Consequently, the Court awarded costs of $750 to the first respondent and $750 to the second and third respondents, totaling $1,500.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Michael Schwarz invented an asparagus grading machine with a unique cup grader and assigned the copyright to Oraka Technologies Limited (Technologies). Napier Tool & Die Co Ltd (Napier) and Messrs Daynes and Robertson were familiar with the Oraka grader through their involvement in its development. They set up Geostel Vision Ltd (Geostel) and started manufacturing a competing grading machine. This machine incorporated a cup assembly manufactured by Napier, which was a substantial copy of the cup assembly on the Oraka grader, leading to copyright infringement. The infringing activity continued for almost eight years. Technologies ceased operating, and the manufacture and sale of the Oraka grader was taken over by Oraka Technologies Holdings Ltd, and subsequently by Oraka Graders Ltd, the sole shareholders and directors of which were Mr Schwarz’s two adult children. In a 2013 appeal, the Court of Appeal concluded that Technologies remained the owner of the copyright and that Napier, Geostel, and Messrs Daynes and Robertson had breached its copyright. The matter was remitted back to the High Court for the determination of damages. Napier participated in the damages hearing but did not contest quantum. Hinton J rejected Napier’s argument that the losses sought by Technologies were not its losses and entered judgment for Technologies in the amount of $4.1 million against all three infringers. The infringers appealed this decision, and the Court of Appeal set aside the judgment for $4.1 million and remitted the matter back to the High Court to retry the issue of quantum based on a notional licence fee.

Technologies, Oraka Graders Ltd, and Mr Schwarz sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against the Court of Appeal’s decision to set aside the judgment for $4.1 million. They filed their application and submissions as a single document. Six working days before the respondents’ written submissions were due, the applicants filed a notice of abandonment. Counsel for the respondents then filed applications for costs on the abandonment, seeking indemnity costs and, in the alternative, costs in the amount the Court usually awards on an unsuccessful leave application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the abandonment of an appeal application sufficient grounds for an award of costs?
2. Are the applicants jointly and severally liable for the costs of the respondents?
3. Should the costs be awarded on an indemnity basis or at the usual rate for an unsuccessful leave application?

Held
1. The abandonment of an appeal application does not prevent the Court from awarding costs. The Court found that the abandonment of the leave application did not affect its power to make a costs award.
2. The applicants are jointly and severally liable for the costs of the respondents. The Court ordered that the applicants, Oraka Technologies Limited, Oraka Graders Limited, and Michael William Schwarz, are jointly and severally liable for the costs.
3. The Court awarded costs at the usual rate for an unsuccessful leave application, which is $2,500, as opposed to the indemnity basis sought by the respondents. The Court awarded $750 to the first respondent and $750 to the second and third respondents, totaling $1,500.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court of New Zealand considered the issue of awarding costs following the abandonment of an appeal application. The Court acknowledged that the abandonment of an appeal application does not affect its inherent jurisdiction to award costs. The Court found that the abandonment of the leave application did not negate its power to make a costs award. The Court noted that while abandonment typically does not result in indemnity costs, the usual award for an unsuccessful leave application is $2,500. However, the Court considered the circumstances where respondents had begun to prepare submissions before the notice of discontinuance was filed. As a result, the Court awarded $750 to the first respondent and $750 to the second and third respondents, totaling $1,500. The Court did not find any exceptional circumstances justifying an indemnity award of costs. The ratio decidendi of this case is that while the abandonment of a leave application does not preclude a costs award, it does not automatically warrant indemnity costs unless there are exceptional circumstances. The Court followed its usual practice of awarding costs at the standard rate for unsuccessful leave applications, adjusted based on the respondents' preparation efforts.