Official Assignee v 22 O'Shannessey Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2022-404-000829

[2022] NZHC 3217

UNDER Part 32 of the High Court Rules

IN THE MATTER OF

The bankruptcy of Andrew Michael Fonagy

BETWEEN

THE OFFICIAL ASSIGNEE

Applicant

AND

22 O’SHANNESSEY LIMITED

First Respondent

AND

WHARERIMU TRUSTEE LIMITED

Second Respondent

AND

MARAM PROPERTY TRADING LIMITED

Third Respondent

Hearing: (On the papers)

Counsel:

Paul Murray for the Applicant

Robert Hucker and Mark Swan for the First Respondent No appearance for the Second Respondent

Jai Moss for the Third Respondent

Judgment:

2 December 2022


JUDGMENT OF MOORE J

[Costs]


This judgment was delivered by me on 2 December 2022 at 2:00 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/ Deputy Registrar Date:

THE OFFICIAL ASSIGNEE v 22 O’SHANNESSEY LIMITED & ORS [2022] NZHC 3217 [2 December 2022]

Introduction

[1]    The substantive dispute in these proceedings relates to transactions undertaken by an Andrew Fonagy prior to his adjudication as bankrupt, which the Official Assignee (“the Assignee”) claims were designed to defeat his creditors. The impugned transactions involve related parties. These included 22 O’Shannessey Ltd (“O’Shannessey”) and a family trust called the Wharerimu Trust (“the Trust”), of which the trustee was Wharerimu Trustee Ltd (“WTL”).

[2]    The Assignee was originally represented by Meredith Connell (“MC”). MC had previously represented a former corporate trustee of the Trust, called Ora Trustees Ltd (“Ora Trustees”).

[3]    WTL took issue with MC representing the Assignee in subsequent proceedings. It applied for orders that MC be prohibited from acting for the Assignee. MC did not accept that it was not entitled to act, but subsequently withdrew as counsel to avoid distracting from the substantive dispute.

[4]    WTL now seeks costs on its application. WTL’s position is that MC’s decision to withdraw means it was, in effect, the successful party.

[5]    MC’s position is that costs should lie where they fall. It says that WTL’s application lacked merit and it acted reasonably and pragmatically to resolve the issue.

Should costs lie where they fall?

[6]    The thrust of WTL’s argument is that MC’s withdrawal as counsel constitutes success on its application. Mr Hucker, for WTL, submitted that this is reflective of the merits of the application. He submitted that there is a perception of injustice arising from MC acting for Ora Trustees and then subsequently acting against WTL, the new trustee of the Trust. It follows, in his submission, that the merits of the application are clear. He submitted that as a consequence, WTL is entitled to costs.

[7]    Mr Hucker’s submissions have strong support in the default rule that costs follow the event. While costs are at the discretion of the Court,1 the general rule is that the party who fails with respect to a proceeding or an interlocutory application should pay costs to the party who succeeds.2 A common sense approach is taken to the issue of which party in a proceeding has succeeded whether in whole or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Official Assignee v 22 O'Shannessey Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 3217
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Official Assignee applied for an order to cancel transactions that Andrew Michael Fonagy undertook prior to his bankruptcy, which the Assignee claims were designed to defeat his creditors. These transactions involved related parties, including 22 O’Shannessey Ltd and the Wharerimu Trust. Wharerimu Trustee Ltd, the trustee of the Trust, applied for orders that Meredith Connell, who was originally representing the Assignee, be prohibited from acting for the Assignee. Connell withdrew as counsel to avoid distracting from the substantive dispute. Wharerimu Trustee Ltd now seeks costs on its application.

The Court had to determine whether Wharerimu Trustee Ltd was entitled to costs on its application. Wharerimu Trustee Ltd argued that Connell's withdrawal as counsel meant that it was, in effect, the successful party. Connell argued that costs should lie where they fall and that Wharerimu Trustee Ltd's application lacked merit. The Court found that while Wharerimu Trustee Ltd achieved the outcome sought by its application, it had failed to reasonably explore resolution of this issue informally before filing its application. The Court found that Connell acted reasonably to settle the matter after Wharerimu Trustee Ltd's application was filed, and that Wharerimu Trustee Ltd's conduct resulted in Connell bearing unnecessary time and expense in responding to an unforeseeable application. The Court found that a reduction in costs was appropriate, so as to prevent Connell bearing Wharerimu Trustee Ltd's costs altogether.

The Court ordered that costs lie where they fall.