O'Connor v Hoyle HC Hamilton CIV-2010-419-1129

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

CIV-2010-419-1129

IN THE MATTER OF     an appeal pursuant to the District Courts

Act 1947, s 72.

BETWEEN  PATRICK O'CONNOR Appellant

ANDLAWRENCE ARTHUR HOYLE First Respondent

ANDDONNA KAYE HOYLE Second Respondent

Hearing:         11 April 2011

Appearances: D Hayes for the Appellant

M Talbot for the Respondent

Judgment:      11 April 2011

ORAL JUDGMENT OF PRIESTLEY J

Counsel/Solicitors:

D Hayes, P O Box 9323, Waikato Mail Centre, Hamilton 3240. Fax: 07 8490634
Email: david@taxlaw.co.nz

Brook Law, P O Box 9600, Waikato Mail Centre, Hamilton 3240. Fax: 07 838 3381.

Email: brooklaw@wave.co.nz

M Talbot, P O Box 24232, Hamilton 3253. Fax: 07 856 36007. Email: Michael@talbotlaw.co.nz

O'CONNOR V HOYLE HC HAM CIV-2010-419-1129 11 April 2011

The appeal

[1]      In October 2009 the appellant sued the respondents in the Hamilton District

Court for $50,000, plus interest, and costs.

[2]      The plaintiff’s cause of action was simple.  He claimed he was entitled to the

$50,000 as a result of a short agreement between him and the respondents, signed on

24 September 2008.  That agreement entitled him to a $50,000 fee as a result of his “negotiating skills”.   In addition the fee was payable because the appellant had reduced considerably the purchase price of an easement which the respondents needed.

[3]      In the District Court the respondents claimed that they were entitled to a set off to the extent of $22,500.

[4]      The hearing was before Judge Maze in July last year.  Her Honour effectively found in favour of the respondents.   The result of her judgment was that the respondents were obliged to pay to the appellant $27,500, plus interest and costs effectively on a pro rata basis.[1]     The appellant challenges that judgment by this appeal.

Background

[1] Patrick O’Connor v Laurence Arthur Hoyle And Anor DC HAM CIV-2009-001630, 9 August 2010.

[5]      If ever there was a cautionary tale as to why lay people should not enter into relatively complicated transactions without the benefit of legal advice, this is it.

[6]      The  respondents  own  land  which  adjoined  the  property owned  by Catra Properties (“Catra”).  Although at the relevant time the respondents were under the impression that the appellant had an interest in Catra, that was not the case.  Rather one of Catra’s directors was the appellant’s son.   In any event, because of an impending subdivision, the respondents were anxious to obtain a legal easement

whereby they could benefit from reticulated electricity and water supplies running

into Catra’s property.  It was for this purpose that the appellant became something of

a go-between.

[7]      Although the first agreement between the parties was undated, it seems to be common ground that it was concluded in May 2008.   The subject matter of the agreement was the easement to which I have referred.   The relevant terms of this agreement for the purposes of this appeal (and indeed at the District Court hearing), were:

(a)       That the respondent, Mr Hoyle, would pay to Catra $200,000 plus

GST for the easement.

(b)Mr Hoyle was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Connor v Hoyle HC Hamilton CIV-2010-419-1129 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 419
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In O'Connor v Hoyle, the appellant, Patrick O'Connor, sought to recover a $50,000 fee from the respondents, Laurence Arthur Hoyle and Donna Kaye Hoyle, for negotiating a reduced price for an easement on their property. The respondents, however, claimed they were entitled to a set off of $22,500 as they had already paid this amount under a previous agreement. The appeal before the Court was to challenge the District Court's judgment that the respondents were liable to pay $27,500 to the appellant.

The primary legal issues were whether the respondents had already paid for their easement under the May 2008 agreement, and if so, whether the appellant's indemnity covered the respondents' loss when they were required to pay again for the easement. The Court had to interpret the agreements between the parties, particularly the indemnity clause, to determine if the respondents' set off was justified.

The Court found that the respondents had indeed paid the purchase price for the easement under the May 2008 agreement and that the appellant's indemnity clause was intended to cover any costs or losses incurred by the respondents due to the enforcement of that agreement. Given that the respondents had paid the same amount under the new September 2008 agreement, the Court concluded that the appellant's indemnity was applicable, and the respondents were entitled to a set off. The appeal was dismissed, and the respondents were awarded costs on an agreed scale.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established