NZDSOS Inc v Minister for COVID-19 Response

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

NOTE: ORDER THAT NO SEARCH OF THE COURT FILE IS PERMISSIBLE WITHOUT THE PERMISSION OF A JUDGE AS PER THE TERMS SET OUT IN [2021] NZHC 3064 AT [83] REMAINS IN FORCE.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI MANA NUI

 SC 150/2021
 [2021] NZSC 163
BETWEEN

NZDSOS INCORPORATED
First Applicant

NZTSOS INCORPORATED
Second Applicant

AND

MINISTER FOR COVID‑19 RESPONSE
First Respondent

DIRECTOR‑GENERAL OF HEALTH
Second Respondent

ATTORNEY‑GENERAL
Third Respondent

Court:

O’Regan, Ellen France and Williams JJ

Counsel:

W C Pyke for First Applicant
S K Green for Second Applicant
D J Perkins and R M McMenamin for Respondents

Judgment:

24 November 2021

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to bring a direct appeal to this Court is dismissed.

BCosts are reserved.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

  1. The applicants, which are incorporated societies representing certain doctors and teachers respectively,[1] applied to the High Court for judicial review of orders made by the first respondent (the Minister) under s 11 of the COVID‑19 Public Health Response Act 2020 (the Act).  The COVID‑19 Public Health Response (Vaccinations) Order 2021 (the Order) has the effect of preventing persons in certain work sectors from working unless they are either vaccinated or exempt from vaccination.  The COVID‑19 Public Health Response (Vaccinations) Amendment Order (No 3) 2021 brought workers in the health and disability sector and certain affected education services within the scope of the Order, thus bringing members of the applicant societies within its ambit.

    [1]NZDSOS also represents other health professionals and NZTSOS also represents others in the education sector.

  2. The applicants’ challenge to the Order was mounted on two bases:

    (a)that the Order is not legally valid because the Act does not empower it to be made, if interpreted consistently with the right to refuse medical treatment under s 11 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (Bill of Rights) and the principle of legality; and

    (b)the Order is invalid because it is not a reasonable and justified limit on the right to refuse medical treatment under s 5 of the Bill of Rights.

  3. The application for judicial review, insofar as it related to the first ground set out above, was heard in the High Court alongside a similar challenge by four midwives.  The High Court dismissed the application for judicial review.[2] 

  4. The second ground of review has yet to be heard, but is set down for hearing in December.[3]

    [3]Counsel for the applicants advise that they may seek to defer consideration of the second ground of challenge pending the outcome of any appeal in relation to the first ground.

  5. A similar challenge to the Order that was heard slightly earlier than the present case was also dismissed by the High Court.[4]

  6. The applicants have applied for leave to appeal directly to this Court from the decision of the High Court, insofar…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NZDSOS Inc v Minister for COVID-19 Response and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZSC 163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, NZDSOS Inc and NZTSOS Inc, sought leave to directly appeal to the Supreme Court of New Zealand from the High Court’s dismissal of their application for judicial review of the COVID-19 Public Health Response (Vaccinations) Order 2021. The Order mandates vaccination for certain work sectors, including health and education. The applicants argued the Order was invalid because it conflicted with the right to refuse medical treatment and the principle of legality under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990. The respondents opposed the direct appeal, arguing that the applicants should first appeal to the Court of Appeal. The Supreme Court found that while the appeal raised an issue of general or public importance, there were no exceptional circumstances justifying a direct appeal to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court noted that the issues would benefit from being first considered by the Court of Appeal, and that the Supreme Court could benefit from the outcomes of other similar cases in the Court of Appeal before hearing this appeal. The Supreme Court dismissed the application for leave to directly appeal. Costs were reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

NZDSOS Inc and NZTSOS Inc, incorporated societies representing certain health professionals and teachers respectively, sought judicial review of orders made by the Minister for COVID-19 Response under the COVID-19 Public Health Response Act 2020. The COVID-19 Public Health Response (Vaccinations) Order 2021, and subsequent amendment, required workers in health and disability sectors, and certain education services, to be vaccinated or exempt from vaccination to continue working. The applicants challenged the legality of the Order on the grounds that it is not empowered by the Act and is not a reasonable and justified limit on the right to refuse medical treatment under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990. The High Court dismissed the application for judicial review, with the second ground of challenge pending.

The applicants applied to the High Court for judicial review of the vaccination orders made under the COVID-19 Public Health Response Act 2020. The High Court dismissed their application. The applicants then sought leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court of New Zealand from the High Court's decision, which was dismissed by the Supreme Court. The dismissal was based on the conclusion that there were no exceptional circumstances justifying a direct appeal to the Supreme Court without first appealing to the Court of Appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the COVID-19 Public Health Response (Vaccinations) Order 2021 have the legal authority under the COVID-19 Public Health Response Act 2020?
2. Is the COVID-19 Public Health Response (Vaccinations) Order 2021 a reasonable and justified limit on the right to refuse medical treatment under section 5 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990?

Held
1. The application for leave to bring a direct appeal to this Court is dismissed.
2. Costs are reserved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court of New Zealand considered an application for leave to appeal directly to the Court from the decision of the High Court regarding the COVID-19 Public Health Response (Vaccinations) Order 2021. The applicants, NZDSOS Incorporated and NZTSOS Incorporated, argued that the Order was not legally valid and that it was not a reasonable and justified limit on the right to refuse medical treatment under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990. The applicants sought to appeal directly to the Supreme Court, arguing that there were exceptional circumstances justifying such an appeal due to the urgency of resolving the validity of the Order. The respondents opposed the grant of leave for a direct appeal, arguing that the applicants should first appeal to the Court of Appeal.

The Supreme Court held that while the proposed appeal involved a matter of general or public importance, there were no exceptional circumstances justifying a direct appeal to the Supreme Court. The Court reasoned that it would be beneficial for the issues to be refined by the Court of Appeal, and that the Supreme Court would benefit from the outcome of other appeals on the issue of the validity of vaccine mandates that would likely come before the Court of Appeal. The Court also noted that the High Court Judge was inclined to let costs lie where they fell, and therefore, the Court reserved the issue of costs for future determination if the respondents intended to apply for them.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases involving matters of general or public importance, the Supreme Court will not grant leave for a direct appeal unless there are exceptional circumstances that justify such an appeal, and the Court prefers for issues to be refined by the Court of Appeal before reaching the Supreme Court. The Court did not depart from or follow any specific prior authority but instead relied on the statutory provisions of the Senior Courts Act 2016.