Noyce v Parnell Property Investments Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2013-404-4965 [2015] NZHC 2926

BETWEEN

DIGBY JOHN NOYCE AS

LIQUIDATOR OF PARNELL PROPERTY INVESTMENTS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) AND AS LIQUIDATOR OF ST STEPHENS INVESTMENTS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

Plaintiff

AND

PARNELL PROPERTY INVESTMENTS LIMITED

First Defendant

ST STEPHENS INVESTMENTS LIMITED

Second Defendant

Continued …

Hearing: (on the papers)

Appearances:

H L Thompson and J R Rutherford for the Plaintiff
Z G Kennedy and N A Chamberlain for the Seventh Defendant
P G Alexander in Person

Judgment:

23 November 2015

JUDGMENT OF WOODHOUSE J (Costs)

This judgment was delivered by me on 23 November 2015 at 3:00 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules 1985.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

……………………………………

Solicitors / Counsel / Parties:

Mr H L Thompson, McMahon Butterworth Thompson, Solicitors, Auckland

Mr Z G Kennedy and Ms N A Chamberlain, Minter Ellison, Solicitors, Auckland

Mr P G Alexander

NOYCE v PARNELL PROPERTY INVESTMENTS LIMITED [2015] NZHC 2926 [23 November 2015]

Continued …

ANDPARNELL STORAGE & PARKING LIMITED

Third Defendant

SECOND GENERATION LIMITED Fourth Defendant

FIFER RESIDENTIAL LIMITED Fifth Defendant

COMPARK PROPERTIES LIMITED Sixth Defendant

BANK OF NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Seventh Defendant

PAUL GRAEME ALEXANDER Eighth Defendant

[1]      In my judgment of 27 August 2015 I held that the seventh defendant, BNZ, is entitled to costs against the fifth defendant (Fifer), the sixth defendant (Compark) and the eighth defendant (Mr Alexander).1    BNZ now seeks indemnity costs or, in the alternative, increased costs.  It also seeks an order that funds held by the plaintiff liquidator on behalf of Fifer, Compark and Mr Alexander be paid to BNZ in payment or reduction of the costs as fixed.   Mr Alexander, for himself and for Fifer and Compark, opposes the application for indemnity or increased costs.   He accepts, given the judgment, that BNZ is entitled to some costs which he submits should be

fixed on a 2B basis.

[2]      Rule  14.6(4)  of  the  High  Court  Rules  makes  provision  for  an  award  of indemnity costs.  BNZ relies in particular on paragraphs (a) and (f) of Rule 14.6(4). These provide that the Court may order a party to pay indemnity costs if:

(a)       the   party   has   acted   vexatiously,   frivolously,   improperly,   or unnecessarily in commencing, continuing, or defending a proceeding or a step in a proceeding; or

…

(f)       some other reason exists which justifies the Court making an order for indemnity costs despite the principle that the determination of costs should be predictable and expeditious.

[3]      The leading decision on paragraph (a) is the decision of the Court of Appeal in Bradbury v Westpac Banking Corporation.2    BNZ, in its memorandum on costs, summarised the principles from this decision as follows:

Bradbury  v  Westpac  Banking  Corporation  held  that  the  word “unnecessarily”  in  r  14.6(4)(a)  takes  its  meaning  and  flavour  from  the adverbs preceding it. Accordingly, for indemnity costs to be awarded it must be demonstrated that the defendant’s misconduct was “flagrantly” bad.  The Court of Appeal endorsed Sheppard J’s summary in Colgate-Palmolive…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Noyce v Parnell Property Investments Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 2926
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Noyce v Parnell Property Investments Limited, the plaintiff, Digby John Noyce, as liquidator of Parnell Property Investments Limited and St Stephens Investments Limited, sought indemnity costs from the Bank of New Zealand (BNZ) against certain defendants, including Parnell Property Investments Limited, Fifer Residential Limited, Compark Properties Limited, and Paul Graeme Alexander. BNZ had previously been awarded costs against these defendants, and now sought indemnity costs or, in the alternative, increased costs. The defendants opposed the application for indemnity or increased costs, accepting that BNZ was entitled to some costs but submitting that they should be fixed on a 2B basis. The court considered the legal issues, including whether the defendants had acted vexatiously, frivolously, improperly, or unnecessarily in commencing, continuing, or defending the proceeding, or whether there was some other reason that justified the award of indemnity costs. The court found that the defendants' conduct was flagrantly bad, including knowingly presenting forged documents to the court and basing their case on groundless contentions. The court also noted the defendants' rejection of two Calderbank offers from BNZ, which would have resulted in a significantly higher distribution amount for the defendants. The court concluded that BNZ was entitled to indemnity costs and ordered the liquidator to pay the funds held on behalf of the defendants to BNZ in reduction of BNZ's costs judgment, subject to the liquidator's entitlement to hold all funds pending disposal of the appeal by the defendants against the substantive judgment.
The court's reasoning was based on the defendants' flagrantly bad conduct, including knowingly presenting forged documents to the court, basing their case on groundless contentions, and rejecting two Calderbank offers from BNZ that would have resulted in a significantly higher distribution amount for the defendants. The court found that BNZ's response to the defendants' allegations was understandable, entirely justified, and did not involve unnecessary or inappropriate steps in the proceeding. The court also found that BNZ's costs were reasonable and that it was entitled to engage second counsel to assist in Court. The court concluded that the defendants' conduct warranted the award of indemnity costs and that BNZ was entitled to an order directing the liquidator to pay the funds held on behalf of the defendants to BNZ in reduction of BNZ's costs judgment, subject to the liquidator's entitlement to hold all funds pending disposal of the appeal by the defendants against the substantive judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established