IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY
CIV-2011-442-517 [2012] NZHC 370
BETWEEN PATRICK DEAN NORRIS Appellant
ANDJOHNSON PRICE HOLDINGS LIMITED Respondent
Hearing: 23 February 2012
Counsel: P D Norris (In person)
S Sansom and G P Malone for Respondent
Judgment: 8 March 2012
JUDGMENT OF MILLER J
[1] Mr Norris, having been appointed liquidator of Trafalgar Top Limited, decided soon after his appointment to offer the company’s panel beating business for sale as a going concern. To do that he needed the co-operation of its landlord, Johnson Price Holdings Limited.
[2] Rent not having been paid before Mr Norris was appointed liquidator on 18
December 2008, the landlord took steps to terminate the lease. Its director, Mr Glenny Johnson, advised Mr Norris that he saw no advantage in allowing the company to remain in the premises without paying rent, since he could re-let the premises himself.
[3] On 14 January 2009 Mr Norris accordingly emailed the landlord’s solicitor,
Mr Malone, advising that he had two interested buyers of the business and stating:
I can confirm that in the order of priority, the landlord will rank with the Liquidator for the current building rental for the months of January and February 2009, and from thereon a month to month basis. I trust this will
PATRICK DEAN NORRIS V JOHNSON PRICE HOLDINGS LIMITED HC NEL CIV-2011-442-517 [8 March
2012]
satisfy your client in the interim and allow us to progress for the benefit of all the creditors.
[4] Mr Malone responded, also by email:
Our client accepts the offer not to cancel the lease at the end of January on the basis that from January will be in the same priority as the Liquidator; for the avoidance of doubt we note that the rent date is the 6th of each month so if either party wishes to cancel that arrangement they would need to give notice on or before the 5th of the month in respect of the following month.
[5] Rent was not paid, and Mr Norris’s attempts to sell the business as a going
concern soon foundered. He gave notice indicating that he wished to vacate on 31
March. The evidence, however, is that not all of the tenant’s fixtures were removed by that time; indeed, they were not removed until a new tenant went into possession on 1 May 2009 under a new lease with the landlord.
[6] Mr Norris offered to pay rent for the months of February and March, and it is not in dispute that he was in funds to pay the rent at the time it fell due. However, he made his offer conditional upon acceptance in full and final satisfaction of his liability under the email agreement, and that was not acceptable to the landlord, who duly sued in the District Court, and won. In the meantime, Mr Norris says, he ran out of money and no longer has any funds available to pay the judgment debt. He explained that the liquidation…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Norris v Johnson Price Holdings Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NZHC 370
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary issues in the appeal were whether Norris had assumed a personal liability to the landlord, whether the District Court had jurisdiction over the landlord's action against the liquidator, what was meant by "rank with the liquidator" in the email agreement, what sum was payable under the email agreement, and whether Norris's ability to pay was to be quantified at the end of the liquidation or when the rent fell due for payment.
The High Court found that Norris had indeed assumed a personal liability to the landlord, as the obligation was incurred post-liquidation. The Court rejected Norris's argument that he was only liable as the company's agent. The Court also found that the District Court had jurisdiction over the landlord's action against the liquidator, as the action was brought in contract and not pursuant to the High Court's supervisory jurisdiction. The Court held that the landlord's priority under the email agreement was with the liquidator, but not relegated to the liquidator's remuneration only. The Court found that money paid to Norris's management company was considered liquidator's remuneration, and the landlord's priority should be satisfied before the payment of pre-liquidation wages. The Court held that the obligation under the email agreement extended to the month of January and terminated on 1 May 2009, when the new lease began. The appeal was dismissed, and the respondent was awarded costs in the High Court.