No 317 Limited v Canterbury Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2012-409-002607 [2015] NZHC 186

BETWEEN

NO 317 LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

CANTERBURY REGIONAL COUNCIL Defendant

Hearing:

11 February 2015

(with further submissions in the form of orders, 16 February
2015 and 17 February 2015 (twice))

Appearances:

CR Carruthers QC and P A Cowey for Plaintiff
M Colson and K J Dobbs for Defendant

Judgment:

17 February 2015

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

on discovery applications

Introduction

[1]      The trial of this proceeding is to commence on 9 March 2015.

[2]      After the close of pleadings (6 August 2014) the plaintiff filed the application for two sets of discovery orders which are the subject of this judgment.

[3]      This interlocutory hearing was convened at the first available point and this judgment will be necessarily brief to ensure that disruption to trial preparation is minimised.

Leave

[4]      The plaintiff requires leave to make the application because pleadings have closed.1  The defendant (ECAN) opposes the granting of leave.

1      High Court Rules, r 7.7(1).

NO 317 LIMITED v CANTERBURY REGIONAL COUNCIL [2015] NZHC 186 [17 February 2015]

[5]      I heard submissions both on the leave issue and on the substance of the applications at the one hearing.   Having heard a half-day argument, I am satisfied that justice required that the Court consider the substance of both applications and not allow them to be defeated at the leave threshold.

[6]      ECAN, in opposition, raises concerns as to the time and cost which would be involved for ECAN if further discovery were ordered.  ECAN personnel would be involved at a time when the parties are preparing for hearing.  There was, however, no evidence that the trial date itself would be jeopardised.  The possible impact on ECAN’s preparation can be taken into account, upon the basis of proportionality, in the specific detail of any additional discovery ordered.

[7]      I therefore grant leave to the plaintiff, No 317 Limited (“No 317”), to make the interlocutory applications which are the subject of this judgment.

Additional discovery

The application itself

[8]      In No 317’s application, dated 3 November 2014, additional discovery was sought as “Order 2” encompassing three categories of documents.2    The first two categories identified in the application were not pursued at the hearing and I dismiss the application in that regard.

[9]      The remaining application was in terms for an order that ECAN provide further and better discovery of:

The RTT database and monitoring database for the period January to May

2008, including details of RedBus and Leopard.

The litigation context

[10]     No 317 once ran bus services.   Some of the services were run pursuant to contracts administered by ECAN as the Regional Council of the Canterbury region.

2      The original interlocutory application, dated 10 September 2014, sought “further and better discovery” of five categories of documents.  These were condensed to three categories after the conference on 23 September 2014.

In  June 2010,  No 317  entered  into  two  additional  bus  service agreements  with

ECAN.   The services under those agreements…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read No 317 Limited v Canterbury Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 186
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

No 317 Limited brought an action against Canterbury Regional Council (ECAN) for what it claims are damages in the amount of $6,000,000. No 317 claims that ECAN unlawfully threatened in November 2010 to terminate contracts unless No 317’s business was sold to a third party. No 317 then sold its business to GoBus Holdings Ltd. The case came before Associate Judge Osborne who heard the application for two sets of discovery orders that are the subject of the judgment. The plaintiff required leave to make the application because pleadings had closed. The defendant opposed the granting of leave on the basis of time and cost. However, the judge was satisfied that the court consider the substance of both applications and not allow them to be defeated at the leave threshold. Therefore, leave was granted to the plaintiff to make the interlocutory applications which are the subject of the judgment.

The plaintiff applied for an order that ECAN provide further and better discovery of: the RTT database and monitoring database for the period January to May 2008, including details of RedBus and Leopard. The judge considered that there was demonstrable relevance to the documentation sought by No 317 and that the subject matter of information requested by No 317 (relating to 2008) was relevant. The way in which ECAN apparently intended to develop its case must be taken to involve a recognition of relevance. An order was made for discovery of the classes of information which the evidence indicated should be accessible albeit with some difficulty and expense for the defendant.

ECAN made discovery of an email chain of October 2010 but with redactions of content containing legal advice. ECAN also claimed legal professional privilege in relation to a separate memorandum of legal advice. The plaintiff sought an order setting aside redactions in the emails and requiring production of the legal advice memorandum. The judge found that issue estoppel applied to the legal advice memorandum and dismissed the application to the extent it related to the legally privileged documents. There was no order as to costs or disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established