Ngati Patumoana

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2017-485-253 CIV-2017-485-262 CIV-2017-485-377 CIV-2017-485-299

CIV-2017-485-292 [2024] NZHC 1435

IN THE MATTER of applications for protected customary rights under the Marine and Coastal Area (Takutai Moana) Act 2011 (the Act)

TE RINGAHUIA TE HATA for and on behalf of NGĀTI PATUMOANA

(CIV-2017-485-253)
First Applicant

NGĀI TAMAHAUA (CIV-2017-485-262) and TE HAPŪ TĪTOKO O NGĀI TAMA (CIV-2017-485-377)

Second Applicant

NGĀTI IRA O WAIŌWEKA (CIV-2017-485-299)

Third Applicant

AND

NGĀTI RUATAKENGA (CIV-2017-485-292)

Fourth Applicant

Hearing: 1 May 2024

Counsel:

M Smith and T H Bennion for First Applicant for CIV-2017-485- 253

C M Panoho-Navaja and J Alexander for CIV-2017-485-262 and CIV-2017-485-377

A T Sykes, S W Fletcher and M S Te Hira for CIV-2017-485-299 G Melvin and S L Gwynn for Attorney-General

T Greensmith-West for Whakatane District Council (Written submissions only)

R M Boyte for Bay of Plenty Regional Council (Written submissions only)

M Hill for Crown Regional Holdings Ltd

NGĀTI PATUMOANA and ORS (CIV-2017-485-292) [2024] NZHC 1435 [31 May 2024]

(Written submissions only)

Judgment:

31 May 2024


JUDGMENT OF CHURCHMAN J


Background

[1]                 In its judgment of 18 October 2023, the Court of Appeal allowed certain appeals from the High Court decision in Re Edwards (Whakatōhea)1 (the judgment under appeal). Rehearings were directed in respect of number of the matters that had been the subject of appeals.

[2]This decision deals with five such matters:

(a)Protected Customary Rights (PCR) Order for Ngāti Patumoana;

(b)Amended application for PCR and Customary Marine Title (CMT) order for Ngāi Tamahaua hapū;

(c)Third amended application for PCR orders for Ngāti Ira o Waiōweka;

(d)The extent to which any form of seaweed could be the subject of a recognition order; and

(e)Miscellaneous matters raised by local authorities.

Ngāti Patumoana

[3]                 In the judgment under appeal, Ngāti Patumoana had sought recognition orders for PCRs under the Marine and Coastal Area Act 2011 (MACA Act). Other than in respect of whitebaiting, the application was declined for lack of evidence.


1      Re Edwards [2021] NZHC 1025, [2022] 2 NZLR 772.

[4]                 In respect of whitebaiting the application was declined on the basis that the beds of navigable rivers were not part of the Common Marine and Coastal Area (CMCA).

[5]                 Because the Court of Appeal held that the beds of navigable rivers are part of the CMCA, Ngāti Patumoana were entitled to a PCR in respect of whitebaiting in the Waiōweka River.

[6]                 Ngāti Patumoana had originally applied for a PCR in respect of taking kaimoana and seabirds. The Court of Appeal noted that there was no challenge to the finding in the judgment under appeal that there was no evidence of non-regulated species of kaimoana and seabirds being taken.2 The result of this was that a PCR order was not available in relation to this part of the application.

[7]                 In the judgment under appeal Ngāti Patumoana’s application for a PCR in respect of the taking of aquatic plants had been dismissed.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ngati Patumoana and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 1435
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves five applications for protected customary rights (PCR) under the Marine and Coastal Area (Takutai Moana) Act 2011. The first application is from Ngāti Patumoana, who seek recognition of PCRs for various activities, including whitebaiting, the gathering of aquatic plants, navigation, and the exercise of kaitiakitanga. The Court of Appeal had previously allowed the appeal for PCRs related to whitebaiting, aquatic plants, navigation, and the exercise of kaitiakitanga but not for the gathering of aquatic plants. The second application is from Ngāi Tamahaua and Te Hapū Titoko o Ngāi Tama, who seek recognition of customary marine title (CMT) and PCRs. The Court of Appeal had directed a rehearing for CMT but not for PCRs. The third application is from Ngāti Ira o Waiōweka, who seek recognition of CMT and PCRs. The Court of Appeal had directed a rehearing for CMT but not for PCRs. The fourth application concerns the extent to which any form of seaweed could be the subject of a PCR. The fifth application raises miscellaneous matters raised by local authorities.

The court had to decide whether Ngāti Patumoana were entitled to a PCR for whitebaiting in the Waiōweka River, as the Court of Appeal had held that the beds of navigable rivers were part of the Common Marine and Coastal Area. The court had to determine whether Ngāti Patumoana’s draft PCR order accurately reflected the Court of Appeal’s findings. The court also had to assess the amended applications from Ngāi Tamahaua and Te Hapū Titoko o Ngāi Tama and Ngāti Ira o Waiōweka to ensure they conformed to the Court of Appeal’s directions. Furthermore, the court had to address the issue of whether any form of seaweed could be the subject of a PCR and consider the concerns raised by local authorities regarding the contents of recognition orders.

The court found that Ngāti Patumoana were entitled to a PCR for whitebaiting in the Waiōweka River, as the Court of Appeal had allowed the appeal for this activity. The court noted that Ngāti Patumoana’s draft PCR order needed modifications, particularly regarding the types of aquatic plants that could be gathered. The court identified issues with the amended applications from Ngāi Tamahaua and Te Hapū Titoko o Ngāi Tama and Ngāti Ira o Waiōweka, including inconsistencies with the Court of Appeal’s findings and inaccuracies in the maps. The court also decided not to make a finding on the issue of seaweed regulation, as it was not appropriate in these proceedings. Finally, the court addressed the local authorities’ concerns by clarifying that recognition orders do not need to refer to specific provisions of the Marine and Coastal Area Act if the Act already provides the necessary guidance. The court concluded that any final determination on the availability of CMT or PCR for areas affected by the Ōpōtiki Harbour redevelopment would have to wait until the final harbour redevelopment project plans were available.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.