| For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link |
| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND |
| CA415/2016 CA54/2017 [2017] NZCA 429 |
| BETWEEN | NGĀTI HURUNGATERANGI, NGĀTI TAEOTU ME NGĀTI TE KAHU O NGĀTI WHAKAUE |
| AND | NGĀTI WAHIAO |
| Hearing: | 14 and 15 June 2017 |
Court: | Harrison, Winkelmann and Gilbert JJ |
Counsel: | D J Goddard QC, J P Kahukiwa and E M Gattey for Appellants |
Judgment: | 26 September 2017 at 3.30 pm |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
A The appeal is allowed.
B The interim award issued by the arbitral panel on 7 June 2013 and adopted as the final award on 14 November 2014 is set aside.
C The respondent is ordered to pay the appellants costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements. We certify for second counsel.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
Contents
Introduction [1]
Background to the arbitration [10]
(1)Native Land Court decisions [10]
(a)Historical context [10]
(b)Arikikapakapa [13]
(c)Whakarewarewa [17]
(2)Waitangi Tribunal report [19]
(a)Determinations of title [20]
(b)Crown purchases [24]
(3)Response from hapū, the Crown and Parliament [27]
(a)Legislative process [28]
(b)Vesting Act [31]
(c)Trust Deed [33]
(d)Mana whenua [37]
(4) Determination notices [40]
(5)Arguments at the hearing [45]
Award [55]
Obligation to give reasons [60]
(1)Statutory requirement [60]
(2)Purpose of duty [61]
(3)Nature of duty [63]
(4)Requirements for this award[64]
Adequacy of the panel's reasons [78]
(1)Paragraph 63 [83]
(2)Paragraph 64 [88]
(3)Paragraph 65 [95]
(4)Paragraph 66 [99]
(5)Paragraph 67 [101]
Conclusion [104]
Result [111]
Appendix
Introduction
In the late nineteenth century the Crown, enabled by seminal decisions of the former Native Land Court, acquired from Māori certain ancestral lands near Rotorua known as Whakarewarewa and Arikikapakapa. In 2008, immediately following a critical report by the Waitangi Tribunal,[1] the Crown agreed to return the lands to Ngāti Hurungaterangi, Ngāti Taeotu me Ngāti Te Kahu o Ngāti Whakaue (Ngāti Whakaue) and those hapū comprising Tuhourangi Ngāti Wahiao (Ngāti Wahiao).[2] However, Ngāti Whakaue and Ngāti Wahiao were unable to agree on which of them was entitled to the lands. Each claimed exclusive beneficial ownership, a concept known in English law but not to Māori before colonisation. Te Ao Māori now provides a rough proxy to beneficial ownership through the tikanga concept of mana whenua — territorial authority over land — which assumes central importance in this case.[3]
[1]Waitangi Tribunal He Maunga Rongo: Report on Central North Island Claims: Stage One (Wai 1200, 2008) [Report].
[2]See the definitions of “Ngati Whakaue Interest” and “Tuhourangi Ngati Wahiao Interest” at [34] of this judgment.
[3]Whether mana whenua should be used as such remains controversial. The term has been described as “an unhelpful nineteenth-century innovation that does violence to cultural integrity”: Waitangi Tribunal Rekohu: A Report on Moriori and Ngati Mutunga Claims in the Chatham Islands (WAI 64, 2001) at 28.
The lands consist of three reserves or blocks. They are the Roto-a-Tamaheke Reserve, comprising 4.304 hectares; the Whakarewarewa…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ngāti Hurungaterangi v Ngāti Wahiao and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NZCA 429
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court placed significant emphasis on the historical evidence presented, particularly from witnesses with immediate knowledge of the land transactions, finding it more credible than later testimonies. However, it refrained from reassessing the validity of prior court decisions due to statutory constraints and the potential implications of doing so. The court determined that the differing rates of land sales between Ngāti Wahiao and Ngāti Whakaue provided substantial support for Ngāti Wahiao’s claim to mana whenua. The court concluded that both iwi have ownership interests in the contested reserves and recommended that these interests be recognized as undivided equal shares.
The court’s reasoning led to the decision that Ngāti Wahiao and Ngāti Whakaue each hold equal undivided shares in the reserves. This decision aimed to balance historical injustices and current ownership claims, ensuring a fair distribution of land rights. The court’s final orders recognised the equal undivided shares of Ngāti Wahiao and Ngāti Whakaue in the reserves, thus resolving the dispute over land ownership.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi