Ngāti Hurungaterangi v Ngāti Wahiao

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA415/2016
CA54/2017
[2017] NZCA 429

BETWEEN

NGĀTI HURUNGATERANGI, NGĀTI TAEOTU ME NGĀTI TE KAHU O NGĀTI WHAKAUE
Appellants

AND

NGĀTI WAHIAO
Respondent

Hearing:

14 and 15 June 2017

Court:

Harrison, Winkelmann and Gilbert JJ

Counsel:

D J Goddard QC, J P Kahukiwa and E M Gattey for Appellants
J E Hodder QC, F E Geiringer and J C Adams for Respondent

Judgment:

26 September 2017 at 3.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is allowed.

B        The interim award issued by the arbitral panel on 7 June 2013 and adopted as the final award on 14 November 2014 is set aside. 

C        The respondent is ordered to pay the appellants costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.  We certify for second counsel. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

Contents

Introduction  [1]
Background to the arbitration  [10]

(1)Native Land Court decisions  [10]

(a)Historical context  [10]

(b)Arikikapakapa  [13]

(c)Whakarewarewa  [17]

(2)Waitangi Tribunal report  [19]

(a)Determinations of title  [20]

(b)Crown purchases  [24]

(3)Response from hapū, the Crown and Parliament  [27]

(a)Legislative process  [28]

(b)Vesting Act  [31]

(c)Trust Deed  [33]

(d)Mana whenua  [37]

(4) Determination notices  [40]

(5)Arguments at the hearing  [45]

Award  [55]
Obligation to give reasons  [60]

(1)Statutory requirement  [60]

(2)Purpose of duty  [61]

(3)Nature of duty  [63]

(4)Requirements for this award[64]

Adequacy of the panel's reasons  [78]

(1)Paragraph 63  [83]

(2)Paragraph 64  [88]

(3)Paragraph 65  [95]

(4)Paragraph 66  [99]

(5)Paragraph 67  [101]

Conclusion  [104]
Result  [111]

Appendix  

Introduction

  1. In the late nineteenth century the Crown, enabled by seminal decisions of the former Native Land Court, acquired from Māori certain ancestral lands near Rotorua known as Whakarewarewa and Arikikapakapa.  In 2008, immediately following a critical report by the Waitangi Tribunal,[1] the Crown agreed to return the lands to Ngāti Hurungaterangi, Ngāti Taeotu me Ngāti Te Kahu o Ngāti Whakaue  (Ngāti Whakaue) and those hapū comprising Tuhourangi Ngāti Wahiao (Ngāti Wahiao).[2]  However, Ngāti Whakaue and Ngāti Wahiao were unable to agree on which of them was entitled to the lands.  Each claimed exclusive beneficial ownership, a concept known in English law but not to Māori before colonisation.  Te Ao Māori now provides a rough proxy to beneficial ownership through the tikanga concept of mana whenua — territorial authority over land — which assumes central importance in this case.[3]

    [1]Waitangi Tribunal He Maunga Rongo: Report on Central North Island Claims: Stage One (Wai 1200, 2008) [Report].

    [2]See the definitions of “Ngati Whakaue Interest” and “Tuhourangi Ngati Wahiao Interest” at [34] of this judgment.

    [3]Whether mana whenua should be used as such remains controversial.  The term has been described as “an unhelpful nineteenth-century innovation that does violence to cultural integrity”: Waitangi Tribunal Rekohu: A Report on Moriori and Ngati Mutunga Claims in the Chatham Islands (WAI 64, 2001) at 28.

  2. The lands consist of three reserves or blocks.  They are the Roto-a-Tamaheke Reserve, comprising 4.304 hectares; the Whakarewarewa…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ngāti Hurungaterangi v Ngāti Wahiao and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZCA 429
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Ngāti Hurungaterangi v Ngāti Wahiao, the dispute concerns the ownership and rights to certain land reserves. The Native Land Court was tasked with determining the ownership interests of Ngāti Wahiao and Ngāti Whakaue in Te Roto-a-Tamaheke Reserve, Whakarewarewa Thermal Springs Reserve, and Southern Arikikapakapa Reserve. The legal issues revolved around the interpretation of historical evidence, the impact of past land sales on the concept of mana whenua, and the applicability of statutory provisions preventing the re-evaluation of prior court decisions. The court had to weigh the immediacy and reliability of historical evidence against the statutory restrictions and the outcomes of past court decisions.

The court placed significant emphasis on the historical evidence presented, particularly from witnesses with immediate knowledge of the land transactions, finding it more credible than later testimonies. However, it refrained from reassessing the validity of prior court decisions due to statutory constraints and the potential implications of doing so. The court determined that the differing rates of land sales between Ngāti Wahiao and Ngāti Whakaue provided substantial support for Ngāti Wahiao’s claim to mana whenua. The court concluded that both iwi have ownership interests in the contested reserves and recommended that these interests be recognized as undivided equal shares.

The court’s reasoning led to the decision that Ngāti Wahiao and Ngāti Whakaue each hold equal undivided shares in the reserves. This decision aimed to balance historical injustices and current ownership claims, ensuring a fair distribution of land rights. The court’s final orders recognised the equal undivided shares of Ngāti Wahiao and Ngāti Whakaue in the reserves, thus resolving the dispute over land ownership.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is appropriate, because of its importance to Ngāti Whakaue’s appeal, that we set out in full the substantive balance of the award which immediately followed the panel’s statement of issues and is said to constitute its reasons:Conclusion62.We have carefully reviewed the extensive evidence we have heard in light of clause 15.4 and the helpful submissions of counsel (summarised at [26] to [55] above). 63.In doing so we have placed considerable weight on the evidence presented to the [Native Land Court] by witnesses whose knowledge of the matters to which they were deposing was much more immediate than could be expected of any witness giving evidence some 130 years later. That evidence does provide strong support for Ngāti Whakaue’s claim of occupation. 64.We have not however accorded similar weight to the decisions of the Court, for a number of reasons. First, we think that there is considerable substance to the submissions we heard as to why the conclusions of the Court should be accorded less weight than would be accorded Court decisions today. Secondly, as we read s 348 of Te Ture Whenua Māori Act 1993 it is not possible for the orders of the Court “to be called into question” in these proceedings “on any grounds whatever”. Although the legislative intention may or may not have been to cover situations such as the present, the section is at least arguably applicable and we would not want to transgress it by reassessing the correctness of the decisions. Thirdly, the sales which occurred subsequent to the 1893 decision make it necessary to consider afresh the question of mana whenua. 65.Developing that final point further, we consider that the consequence of the sale of land by a willing seller is that mana whenua moves from the seller to the buyer. As the evidence summarised at para [46] above establishes, a striking feature of the evidence is the speed and volume of sales by those of Ngāti Whakaue who were awarded land compared to the very low level of sales by Ngāti Wahiao. While financial hardship and less than scrupulous dealings by Crown agents may well have contributed to the Ngāti Whakaue sales, that only serves to emphasise the point that Ngāti Wahiao, facing at least as great hardship and the same agents, in almost all cases refused to sell. The differing approaches to selling may also be explained, in part, by Whakarewarewa being the base of the Ngāti Wahiao hapū, whereas that of the Ngāti Whakaue hapū was at Ohinemutu. We therefore regard the evidence of sales and lack of sales as providing strong support for Ngāti Wahiao’s claim to mana whenua. 66.In summary, we have concluded that the three Ngāti Wahiao hapū and the three Ngāti Whakaue hapū have both established an ownership interest in Te Roto-a-Tamaheke Reserve and the Whakarewarewa Thermal Springs Reserve. Similarly, the three Ngāti Wahiao hapū and the Pukeroa Oruawhata Trust have both established an ownership interest in the Southern Arikikapakapa Reserve. 67.We think that those interests should be recognised as undivided shares. In other words, each interest should share in all the reserve rather than different parts of a reserve being allocated to different interests. The question of whether the shares should be equal is a difficult one. If we had been asked to apportion all the Whakarewarewa Valley lands we would have inclined to the view that the Ngāti Wahiao interest should be somewhat greater than the Ngāti Whakaue interest. We are mindful however that Ngāti Wahiao continue to own most of the Whakarewarewa No 2 block which was awarded to them in 1893 whereas, following the Crown purchases, the Court in 1896 awarded to the Crown some 747 of the 871 acres in the Whakarewarewa No 1 block and 157 of the 215 acres in the Whakarewarewa No 2 block. We think therefore that justice will be done if ownership of the lands in the three reserves is apportioned equally between Ngāti Wahiao and Ngāti Whakaue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established