New Zealand Loyal v Electoral Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2023-485-604

[2023] NZHC 2827

BETWEEN

NEW ZEALAND LOYAL

Applicant

AND

ELECTORAL COMMISSION

First Respondent

AND

ATTORNEY-GENERAL

Second Respondent

Hearing: 6 October 2023

Counsel:

M Hague for Applicant

D J Perkins and S Cvitanovich for Respondents

Judgment:

9 October 2023


JUDGMENT OF ISAC J

[Application for judicial review]


NEW ZEALAND LOYAL v ELECTORAL COMMISSION [2023] NZHC 2827 [9 October 2023]

Introduction

[1]    In five days’ time the 2023 general election will take place, determining the composition of the House of Representatives for the next three-year term. The applicant, New Zealand Loyal, is a registered political party contesting the election. In this urgent proceeding it seeks judicial review of what it says is a decision of the Electoral Commission to refuse to accept an amended party list. New Zealand Loyal seeks an urgent mandatory order requiring the Electoral Commission to accept and publish “updated election information” which, in effect, would increase the number of its list candidates from the three accepted by the Commission to 36. Given advance voting has already begun, the applicant says that with each passing day its position in the election is prejudiced without publication of the amended list. Should the party win an electorate seat, or exceed the five per cent threshold, the existing party list would likely see some seats in Parliament New Zealand Loyal would otherwise have filled allocated to a different party.

[2]    The Electoral Commission is an independent statutory body charged with conducting elections impartially, efficiently and effectively in accordance with the Electoral Act 1993. It opposes the application for review. It says that the Electoral Act contains an unqualified requirement in s 127(3)(a) for a party list to be submitted before noon on 14 September 2023. After that deadline, a political party may only withdraw its party list, but it may not submit a new one. Amending the party’s list at this point would involve a breach of clear statutory requirements that apply to all political parties. It argues that it has no power to accept amendments to a party list after the deadline and, for the same reason, the Court has no power to grant the relief New Zealand Loyal seeks.

[3]    These proceedings were filed on 5 October 2023 and served on the respondents that day on a Pickwick basis. As the duty judge I held a teleconference with counsel to determine the appropriate way forward. Counsel for the Commission, Mr Perkins, suggested that given the need for urgency, the Court should determine a preliminary question of law said to underpin the applicant’s first ground of review, as it relates to the mandatory order. Mr Hague, counsel for New Zealand Loyal, agreed with the sense

of that approach, as did I. There was some refinement to the question, but the parties agreed on the following formulation:1

If the facts pleaded by New Zealand Loyal are assumed to be true, can the Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read New Zealand Loyal v Electoral Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 2827
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

New Zealand Loyal, a registered political party, sought judicial review of a decision by the Electoral Commission, the independent statutory body charged with conducting elections, to refuse to accept an amended party list. The applicant’s three grounds of review related to what it says was the “decision” of the Electoral Commission to refuse to accept party list information submitted after the statutory deadline. The applicant sought an urgent mandatory order requiring the Electoral Commission to accept and publish “updated election information” which, in effect, would increase the number of its list candidates from the three accepted by the Commission to 36. Given advance voting had already begun, the applicant said that with each passing day its position in the election was prejudiced without publication of the amended list. The Electoral Commission opposed the application for review. It said that the Electoral Act contained an unqualified requirement for a party list to be submitted before noon on 14 September 2023. After that deadline, a political party may only withdraw its party list, but it may not submit a new one. Amending the party’s list at this point would involve a breach of clear statutory requirements that apply to all political parties. It argued that it had no power to accept amendments to a party list after the deadline and, for the same reason, the Court had no power to grant the relief New Zealand Loyal sought. The Court held that the “decision” identified in the statement of claim—the Commission’s refusal to accept party list information after the noon 14 September deadline—was not the exercise of a power of decision amenable to judicial review. Rather than lawfully requiring the Commission to exercise a power in the applicant’s favour, the mandatory order in substance sought to suspend or modify important statutory requirements Parliament has seen fit to impose. The Court could not grant the mandatory order sought as a matter of law. This was not to say that the applicant was without a remedy. If it was ultimately able to establish the facts it pleaded in support of the first ground of review, it might still be open for the court to make declarations of illegality. However, it did clearly follow that the principal relief that had been sought could not be granted as a matter of law. The second and third grounds of review also failed. The second ground of review raised two questions of law. The first asked whether s 146H(1) of the Electoral Act required the Electoral Commission to accept a party list (or revised “party list information”) submitted after noon on Thursday 14 September, but before noon on Friday 15 September. Alternatively, it asked whether s 128C required the Electoral Commission to accept the withdrawal and resubmission of a party list after noon on Thursday 14 September, but before noon on Friday 15 September. The Court concluded that the second ground of review could not succeed as a matter of law, and the applicant was not entitled to the relief it sought in reliance of that ground. The third ground of review rested on s 12(b) of the New Zealand Bill of Rights 1990. It was said that the Commission’s decision not to permit additional party list ranking information (or perhaps more accurately, a refusal to accept a revised party list) after noon on 14 September limited New Zealand Loyal’s candidates’ right of participation in the general election as a party list candidate contrary to s 12(b). The Court was not persuaded that this ground of review raised an arguable question of law. The third ground of review was dismissed. For the foregoing reasons: (a) The answer to the preliminary question was “no”, and the application for a mandatory order—whether interim or final—was dismissed. (b) To the extent the first ground of review sought declaratory relief, the application for judicial review was adjourned to a date after the results of the election were known. This would provide New Zealand Loyal with an opportunity to consider whether the issues it raises on the first ground of review still require a determination by the court. (c) The second and third grounds of review raise questions of law which were answered against the applicant and they were also dismissed.