Neill v Neill Island Farms Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TAURANGA MOANA ROHE

CIV 2024-470-000016

[2024] NZHC 2518

UNDER the Residential Tenancies Act 1986

BETWEEN

JEANNE ISABELLA NEILL

Appellant

AND

NEILL ISLAND FARMS LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing: 2 September 2024

Appearances:

A Little for the Appellant

P Anderson for the Respondent

Judgment:

4 September 2024


JUDGMENT OF TAHANA J


This judgment was delivered by me on 4 September 2024 at 12 noon Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

…………………………

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Gibson Sheat Lawyers, Wellington Cooney Lees Morgan

NEILL v NEILL ISLAND FARMS LIMITED [2024] NZHC 2518 [4 September 2024]

Introduction

[1]                 This  is  an  appeal  from  the  decision  of  Judge  I  D  R  Cameron  dated   28 November 2023.1 The Judge dismissed an appeal from a decision of the Tenancy Tribunal (the Tribunal) dated 21 July 2023. The Tribunal had granted Neill Island Farms Ltd (the Company) possession of a property at Omokoroa, Tauranga (the Property), formerly occupied by Jeanne Neill (Jeanne). I refer to first names to avoid any confusion given the shared family name.

[2]                 The key issue on appeal is whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to grant the possession order. That issue turns on whether Jeanne was occupying the Property under a tenancy or pursuant to a licence to occupy. If the occupancy was under a tenancy, then the question is whether she is a family member of the Company (as landlord or owner) such that the Residential Tenancies Act 1986 (RTA) does not apply.2

[3]Before considering these issues, I set out the relevant background.

Background

[4]                 The Company was incorporated in 1979 and is the owner of an avocado orchard on Matakana Island. The Company purchased the Property in 1981.

[5]                 The J & T family trust (the Family Trust) was settled on 23 July 2001 with Jeanne’s parents, Tui and John, as trustees. The primary beneficiaries are Tui, John and their children. The trustees of the Family Trust own 99 per cent of the shares in the Company. The estate of John owns 0.5 per cent and Tui (deceased) owns the other

0.5 per cent. Tui’s shareholding has not yet been transferred to her estate.

[6]                 The Property was used as the family home of John and Tui. John passed away and Tui continued to reside at the Property alone.


1      Neill v Neill Island Farms Ltd [2023] NZDC 25982.

2      Residential Tenancies Act, s 5(1)(n).

[7]                 In 2016, Tui had knee surgery and Jeanne returned from Sydney to support her for that operation. Tui suffered complications from her surgery and moved to a rest home in 2016.

[8]                 Jeanne’s siblings, Iain and Fiona, became directors of the Company in June 2018. Tui remained a director until sometime in 2019.

[9]                 On 17 December 2018 the Company wrote to Jeanne informing her that she may stay at the Property during her visits to Omokoroa from Australia. That letter expressly stated that “this is not a fixed term…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Neill v Neill Island Farms Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 2518
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal arises from the dismissal of a challenge by Jeanne Neill against a decision of the Tenancy Tribunal, which in turn had upheld a decision by Neill Island Farms Limited (the Company) to evict Jeanne from a property at Omokoroa, Tauranga. The appeal concerns the question of whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to grant the possession order, which hinges on whether Jeanne was occupying the Property under a tenancy or pursuant to a licence to occupy. If the latter, the question arises whether she was a family member of the Company such that the Residential Tenancies Act 1986 (RTA) does not apply. The court was required to determine whether the Judge's finding that the Tribunal was correct to find that s 5(1)(n) of the RTA did not apply and that the Tribunal had jurisdiction to make a possession order was erroneous in point of law.

The court found that the Judge did not err in determining that Jeanne's occupation of the Property was not under a tenancy but under a licence to occupy. The court considered that the evidence before the Tribunal and Judge did not establish that Jeanne’s right to occupy the Property was in consideration for her providing care for her mother. The court found that the December 2018 letter from the Company to Jeanne was contrary to the submission that Tui agreed that Jeanne could occupy the property until it was sold, and that there was no reference to such an arrangement in the letter. The court also found that the Family Court consent memorandum did not refer to Jeanne’s occupation of the Property and that the Judge was entitled to rely on the Company's correspondence in determining the nature of the occupancy arrangements. The court concluded that it was open to the Tribunal and the District Court to reject Jeanne's argument that s 5(1)(n) applied. The court was satisfied that the Judge did not err in finding that s 5(1)(n) did not apply.

The court also agreed with the Judge's finding that any licence to occupy had been revoked by the Company as the owner of the Property. At the time of the Tribunal's decision, Jeanne did not have any ongoing right to occupy the Property. It follows that the Tribunal was required to make a possession order in favour of the Company under s 65 of the RTA. For the above reasons, the court found that the decision of the District Court Judge was not erroneous in point of law.

The appeal is dismissed. The court’s preliminary view is that the respondent is entitled to costs on a 2B basis. If the parties are unable to agree costs, the respondent is to file and serve a costs memorandum within 15 working days of the date of this judgment, and the appellant is to file and serve a memorandum in response within a further 10 working days. Unless the court hears further from counsel, costs will be determined on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established