| IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND |
| SC 46/2011 [2011] NZSC 102 |
| BETWEEN NEIL TONY HICKMAN AND ORS |
| AND TURN AND WAVE LIMITED |
| BETWEEN DAVID JOHN LESTER AND ORS |
| AND GREENSTONE BARCLAY TRUSTEES LIMITED |
| BETWEEN ANTHONY COLLINGWOOD AND ORS |
| AND ICON CENTRAL LIMITED |
| Court: Elias CJ, Tipping and William Young JJ |
| Counsel: S H Barter and R S Phillips for H and M Herrick |
| Judgment: 6 September 2011 |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
Leave to appeal is granted on the following questions:
(1)Did the marketing by Blue Chip companies and sales agents of the Blue Chip investment products amount to offers to the public of equity and/or debt securities for the purposes of s 37 of the Securities Act 1978?
(2)If so, is the exemption in s 5(1)(b) applicable?
(3)If the answers to questions (1) and (2) are favourable to the investors, does this impeach the ability of the developers to enforce the agreements for sale and purchase on the basis that they (a) constituted part of the relevant allotments and were thus void and of no effect under s 37(4) or, (b) were tainted by their association with those allotments and thus illegal?
REASONS
Leave is not presently granted on the proposed ground that the developers are precluded from taking the benefit of the agreements for sale and purchase on the basis that (a) the Blue Chip investment products were offered to the public in breach of the Securities Act 1978 and (b) those who did this were acting as agents of the developers. The agency arguments associated with this proposed ground of appeal may be material to the issues identified in question 3 above and can be developed in that context. But we do not, at least for the moment, see these arguments as giving rise to an independent basis upon which relief might arguably be available. If in the course of formulating submissions, counsel for the investors wishes to pursue the agency argument as an independent ground of appeal, the application for leave to appeal on this ground can be renewed.
It is also necessary to address the application by Mr and Mrs Herrick to amend the application for leave to appeal on the basis of their wish to pursue separate appeal points based on arguments of non est factum, mistake and fraud in equity.
Mr and Mrs Herrick had initially agreed to buy three apartments in a development known as the Verve which had not proceeded as quickly as planned. They executed documents which released them from the Verve transactions but committed them to the acquisition of three apartments in the Icon development.[1]
[1]See the outline of the factual background in the appendix…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Neil Tony Hickman v Turn and Wave Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NZSC 102
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the arguments regarding the exemption under the Securities Act 1978 and whether the marketing activities of the Blue Chip companies and sales agents amounted to offers to the public. The investors contended that the activities were in breach of the Securities Act and that the developers were acting as agents of these entities, which would make them complicit in the breach. However, the court found that these agency arguments were not sufficiently developed to form an independent basis for appeal at that stage. The court also addressed the Herricks' application to amend their grounds for appeal to include claims of non est factum, mistake, and fraud in equity, but found that these arguments were not adequately supported by the evidence presented at trial or in the Court of Appeal.
The reasoning of the court was that the proposed arguments concerning agency and the Herricks' additional grounds were not sufficiently developed or supported to warrant leave to appeal at that time. The court indicated that if the Herricks wished to pursue the agency argument independently, they could renew their application for leave to appeal. Similarly, the additional grounds proposed by the Herricks were not advanced in the previous proceedings and would prejudice the respondents if granted. Consequently, the court denied leave to appeal on the proposed grounds but did not close the door on revisiting them if adequately developed in future submissions.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi