Navy League Canterbury (NZ) Incorporated v Bell-Thomson

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2013-409-001080 [2014] NZHC 2104

BETWEEN

NAVY LEAGUE CANTERBURY (NZ)

INCORPORATED Plaintiff

AND

SONIA BELL-THOMSON Defendant

Submissions: Filed 15 July 2014 and 11 August 2014

Judgment:

2 September 2014

JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J AS TO COSTS (Dealt with on the papers)

Background

[1]      At  the  heart  of  this  proceeding  was  a  dispute  between  Navy  League Canterbury (NZ) Inc (NLC) and Ms Sonia Bell-Thompson, driven in no small part by tensions between the president of NLC, Mr Simon Courtney and Ms Bell- Thompson.  It would be fair to say that the dispute centred around the rules of NLC and the impact of those rules on certain meetings of NLC.

[2]      On 31  May 2013 Chisholm J  released  a decision  granting interim  relief before the substantive hearing in this proceeding was to take place.1     Since that decision was released, however, no further steps were taken for over a year.   The decision however according to the NLC achieved the resignation of Ms Bell- Thompson from the Executive Committee and the return of material she held, both of which had been sought in the proceedings themselves.  This led Associate Judge

Osborne to release a minute on 3 June 2014 recording that the claims either needed

to be discontinued, or timetabling needed to be set in place to get the proceeding to a

1      Navy League Canterbury (NZ) Inc v Bell-Thompson [2013] NZHC 1275.

NAVY LEAGUE CANTERBURY (NZ) INC v BELL-THOMSON [2014] NZHC 2104 [2 September 2014]

hearing.  The parties elected the former option and a notice of discontinuance was duly filed.  The only outstanding issue was costs upon which issue the parties have now filed memoranda which have been referred to me.  It is the issue of costs I now address by agreement on the papers.

Documents filed

[3]      I have received and read in full the following documents:

(a)       NLC’s submissions in support of costs, filed 15 July 2014.

(b)Ms Bell-Thompson’s submissions in support of cross-application for costs, filed 12 August 2014.

(c)       Affidavit of Ms Bell-Thompson in support of cross-application, filed

12 August 2014.

(d)      NLC’s reply submissions in support of its application for costs, filed

27 August 2014.

(e)       Affidavit of Robyn Loversidge in support of NLC’s application for

costs, filed 27 August 2014.

For the sake of brevity I do not replicate significant tracts of those submissions or affidavits.  I am fully cognisant of all arguments raised which are incorporated into the decision that follows.

Discussion

[4]      The starting point is that where a plaintiff discontinues a proceeding it is prima facie liable to pay the costs of the defendant.2   However, this presumption may

be displaced if I find that it would not be just and equitable for the rule to apply.3

2      High Court Rules, r 15.23.

3      Rule 14.1; Kroma Colour Prints Ltd v Tridonicatco NZ Ltd [2008] NZCA 150, (2008) 18 PRNZ

973; FM Custodians Ltd v Pati [2012] NZHC 1902 at [10] – [12].

[5]      For…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Navy League Canterbury (NZ) Incorporated v Bell-Thomson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2104
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Christchurch Registry, the case of Navy League Canterbury (NZ) Incorporated v Bell-Thomson was heard and decided. The plaintiff, Navy League Canterbury (NZ) Incorporated, was engaged in a dispute with the defendant, Sonia Bell-Thomson, primarily due to tensions between the president of the Navy League, Mr. Simon Courtney, and Ms. Bell-Thomson. The central issue revolved around the rules of the Navy League and their implications for certain meetings. The dispute had been ongoing, with an interim relief granted by Chisholm J on May 31, 2013. However, after a year with no further action, the claims were discontinued, leaving only the issue of costs to be resolved.

The court was required to decide whether the plaintiff, who had discontinued the proceedings, should be liable for the defendant's costs under the High Court Rules. The legal issue hinged on whether the circumstances warranted a departure from the presumption that the discontinuing party should bear the costs of the other party. The court considered several factors, including the disruptive actions of Ms. Bell-Thomson, the necessity of the proceedings, and the compliance with interim relief orders. Additionally, the court evaluated whether mediation could have resolved the issues and whether there was wider dysfunction within the Navy League.

The court found that while the plaintiff had not succeeded in the proceedings, the circumstances warranted a departure from the usual rule of costs following the event. The court noted that Ms. Bell-Thomson had made certain without prejudice concessions, and there was evidence of wider dysfunction within the Navy League, which was not solely attributable to Ms. Bell-Thomson. Moreover, the plaintiff had not attempted to attend mediation despite Ms. Bell-Thomson's request. Given these considerations, the court exercised its discretion and held that costs should lie where they fell, declining to order costs against Ms. Bell-Thomson.

In conclusion, the court ordered that costs were to lie where they fell, reflecting the valid points raised by both parties. This decision highlighted the need to balance the presumptions of the High Court Rules with the specific circumstances of each case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established