Myoak Holdings Limited v Millstone Grazing Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2016-441-000104 [2017] NZHC 891

UNDER

the Companies Act 1993 and Part 19 of the

High Court Rules

BETWEEN

MYOAK HOLDINGS LIMITED Applicant

AND

MILLSTONE GRAZING LIMITED Respondent

Hearing: 4 May 2017 (Determined on the papers)

Counsel:

P W G Ahern for Applicant
J D Haig for Respondent

Judgment:

5 May 2017

COSTS JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

[1]      On  29  July  2016  the  applicant,  Myoak  Holdings  Limited  (Myoak)  was ordered to pay costs to Millstone Grazing Limited (Millstone) in the sum of $10,258 plus disbursements in the sum of $1,280.  This followed a judgment by the Court sustaining a caveat Millstone had lodged over a property owned by Myoak.

[2]      Millstone  did  not  pay the  costs  as  ordered.    It  appealed  the  substantive judgment to the Court of Appeal.   It did not apply for a stay of the High Court judgment.

[3]      Millstone issued a demand against Myoak under s 289 of the Companies Act

1993  on  16 August  2016  claiming payment  of the costs  ordered  by the Court. Myoak brought this application to set aside the statutory demand, a few days later.

The application was scheduled to be heard by the Court on 18 November 2016.

MYOAK HOLDINGS LTD v MILLSTONE GRAZING LTD [2017] NZHC 891 [5 May 2017]

[4]      The day before the scheduled hearing counsel for Myoak and Millstone filed a joint memorandum advising the Court that the case had been resolved, and an order was sought that the application to set aside the notice be dismissed by consent. Millstone was paid the sum owing under the Court order, evidently on the basis that it gave an undertaking that the amount paid would be repaid should Myoak’s appeal to the Court of Appeal be successful. An order was made accordingly, but costs were reserved.

[5]      Millstone  applies  for costs.    It  says  that  an  appeal  against  a substantive judgment and a costs award does not operate as a stay or justify an appellant not meeting a costs order.  It says that it was justified in issuing the notice and it seeks costs on a 2B basis with a further 0.2 of a day on scale costs for the preparation of the submissions made in relation to costs.

[6]      Myoak says that the use of the statutory demand process was improper and that there were no grounds on which the statutory demand should be set aside under s 290 of the Companies Act.  It says that the parties both agreed that the hearing of the application to set aside should not proceed, and the Court should approach the question of costs on the basis that each party compromised in order to achieve an outcome.  The parties remain engaged in substantial litigation and evaluation of the compromise reached is a subjective issue requiring assessment of the merits.

Discussion

[7]      Rule 14.2(a) provides that a party which fails in respect of a proceeding should pay costs to the party which succeeds.  Rule 15.23…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Myoak Holdings Limited v Millstone Grazing Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 891
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Myoak Holdings Limited v Millstone Grazing Limited, the court was asked to determine the costs associated with an application to set aside a statutory demand issued by Millstone against Myoak. Myoak had previously been ordered to pay costs to Millstone following a judgment that sustained a caveat lodged by Millstone over a property owned by Myoak. Millstone issued a statutory demand under the Companies Act 1993 for Myoak to pay the costs, which Myoak sought to set aside. The case was resolved before the hearing of the application to set aside, with Millstone receiving payment of the sum owing under the Court order, on the basis that it would repay the amount if Myoak's appeal to the Court of Appeal was successful. Millstone applied for costs, arguing that it was justified in issuing the statutory demand and seeking costs on a 2B basis with a further 0.2 of a day on scale costs for the preparation of the submissions made in relation to costs. Myoak argued that the use of the statutory demand process was improper and that there were no grounds on which the statutory demand should be set aside under s 290 of the Companies Act. The court found that Millstone was entitled to costs against Myoak on the application to set aside, and on its memorandum in relation to costs. The court ordered Myoak to pay Millstone costs on a 2B basis on the application to set aside the statutory demand together with costs for 0.2 days in relation to Millstone’s memorandum in relation to costs. Myoak was also ordered to pay any disbursements which may be fixed by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established