Mycroft v Ministry of Social Development

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY

CRI-2014-463-45 [2015] NZHC 2520

BETWEEN

MICHELLE LISA MYCROFT

Appellant

AND

THE MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT

Respondent

Hearing: 13 October 2015

Counsel:

D Hall for Appellant
C H Macklin for Respondent

Judgment:

14 October 2015

JUDGMENT OF BREWER J

This judgment was delivered by me on 14 October 2015 at 10:00 am pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:           Douglas Hall (Rotorua) for Appellant

Gordon Pilditch (Rotorua) for Respondent

MYCROFT v THE MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT [2015] NZHC 2520 [14 October 2015]

Introduction

[1]      Judge CJ McGuire sentenced Ms Mycroft to 100 hours’ of community work in the District Court at Rotorua on 18 July 2014.  Ms Mycroft had pleaded guilty to three charges of wilfully omitting to tell an officer concerned with the administration of the Social Security Act of her current income for the purpose of misleading an officer concerned with the administration of the Act, thus resulting in her receiving

benefits under the Act.1   Over a period of just over three years, Ms Mycroft acquired

fraudulently $13,304.61.  Ms Mycroft wanted to be discharged without conviction.

She now appeals against Judge McGuire’s refusal to do so.

Background

[2]      There is quite a lot of detail in the background to Ms Mycroft’s offending.  It is relevant to the assessment, to which I will come, of the gravity of the offending.  I will, therefore, now set out the background detail as recorded by Judge McGuire in his sentencing notes:

[2]       This  offending occurred  over  a  period  from July 2009  to  March

2012.  Over that period of time, save for the time between October 2010 and

January 2011, Ms Mycroft received a sickness benefit where, it would seem, something like three weeks in 2012 when she was not on a benefit as well. The amount involved here is $13,304.61.   Ms Mycroft is currently paying that sum off.

[3]       The  facts  summary  in  this  case  discloses  that  on  or  about

20 July 2009, she applied for a sickness benefit, in which case she was ask to specify where she had been working in the last 52 weeks.   She correctly stated  she  had  been  working  for  Ascend Quality  Care.    However,  she incorrectly stated that her last day of work was 9 July 2009 and that she only intended to return to work once her treatment had been completed.   She signed the client obligation section of the form indicating that, amongst other things, the information provided was true and correct, and that she would advise the Ministry of Social Development of any material changes to her circumstances.    Based  on  that  information,  she  was  granted  a  sickness benefit, which was backdated to 17 July.  In fact, she continued to work for Ascend Quality Care until 26 March of the following year.

[4]       Once the benefit was granted, letters generated every three months. Amongst other things, it told the defendant that if she returned to work, she must inform the Ministry of Social Development.

[5]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mycroft v Ministry of Social Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 2520
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Michelle Lisa Mycroft appealed against Judge McGuire's refusal to grant her a discharge without conviction for obtaining social security benefits fraudulently. Ms Mycroft was sentenced to 100 hours of community work. She had pleaded guilty to three charges of wilfully omitting to inform an officer of her current income, resulting in her receiving benefits under the Social Security Act. Ms Mycroft's appeal was heard on the basis of a rehearing. The appeal hinged on the correctness of Judge McGuire's decision not to grant a discharge without conviction under section 106 of the Sentencing Act 2002. The appeal also questioned whether the direct and indirect consequences of a conviction would be out of all proportion to the gravity of the offence.

Judge McGuire had found that Ms Mycroft's offending was of moderate gravity. Counsel agreed on this point and the Court concurred. The direct and indirect consequences of a conviction were identified as likely difficulties in obtaining work in Ms Mycroft's chosen field (nursing). Judge McGuire concluded that the direct and indirect consequences of Ms Mycroft's offending were not out of all proportion to the gravity of the offending. The Court found that Ms Mycroft's offending was premeditated and persistent. It persisted over a period of over three years, during which she obtained by fraud just over $13,000. The Court accepted that there were extenuating circumstances, but found that the convictions would not be out of all proportion to the gravity of the offending.

The appeal was dismissed. The Court agreed with Judge McGuire's conclusion that the gravity of the offending was moderate and that the direct and indirect consequences of conviction were not out of all proportion to the gravity of the offending. The Court also found that Ms Mycroft's offending was premeditated and persistent, and that she had obtained by fraud just over $13,000 over a period of over three years. The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established