Muollo v Hunt HC Wellington CP No 252/00

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
WELLINGTON REGISTRY CP No 252/00

BETWEEN RAFFAELE MUOLLO of Wellington, Company Director AND JOSEPHINE MUOLLO his wife
Plaintiffs

AND PETER MICHAEL HUNT of Wellington, Company Director
Defendant

Date of Hearing: 2 August 2001

Counsel: J Porter for Plaintiffs
J S Kos and J L Beatson for Defendant

Judgment Date: 12 September 2001

JUDGMENT OF MASTER J C A THOMSON

Solicitors:
Sievwrights, Wellington for Plaintiffs
Russell McVeagh, Wellington for Defendant

Application

[1] This is an application by the plaintiffs for summary judgment. The plaintiffs seek an order for specific performance, and interest for late settlement.

Background Facts

[2] The defendant contracted with the plaintiff to purchase the plaintiffs’ hotel, known as Hotel Raffaele, for $11m, with the intention of developing the property into a retirement village. The agreement was dated 13 August 1999. The defendant in terms of the agreement was not purchasing the hotel as a going concern, those clauses in the printed agreement having been deleted. The agreement was conditional on the defendant conducting a feasibility study and obtaining finance. The defendant made the agreement unconditional on 15 September 1999.

[3] For reasons I discuss further, settlement was never effected. On 3 May 2000 the plaintiff issued a settlement notice requiring settlement within 12 days, to which the defendant replied by letter outlining his difficulties in obtaining finance. On 21 June 2000 the parties, after negotiations, signed a variation of the agreement. The purchase price was reduced. Clause 10 of the variation agreement provided:

“10. If the purchaser does not comply with the terms of this variation (time being strictly of the essence) then the variation shall be void and of no effect between the parties and the terms of the original agreement and settlement notice will apply, save that the vendor shall be entitled to retain the deposit of $1,275,000.00 on account of the purchase price under the original agreement.”

[4] The defendant again failed to settle, so the original agreement for sale and purchase was reactivated. In the end the defendant purported to cancel the agreement pursuant to s 7 of the Contractual Remedies Act 1979. However he did not do so until 16 February 2001 and only after the plaintiffs had issued summary judgment proceedings. The plaintiffs now seek summary judgment against the defendant for failing to settle pursuant to the original agreement for sale and purchase.

Defendant’s Argument

[5] The defendant raises a number of defences, firstly, a defence based on false pre-contractual representations made by the plaintiffs that induced him to enter the contract, and which substantially altered the benefit and burden of the contract, thus justifying cancellation.

[6] The defendant claims that the plaintiffs represented that the profitability of the hotel exceeded $1m per annum, and that this representation was an integral part of the pre-contractual negotiations. He says only when he finally received financial information from the plaintiff, and which he claims had been withheld (despite repeated requests for it by the defendant) did it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Muollo v Hunt HC Wellington CP No 252/00 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NZHC 849
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand, Wellington Registry, dealt with a case involving an application for summary judgment by the plaintiffs, Raffaele and Josephine Muollo, against the defendant, Peter Michael Hunt. The Muollos sought specific performance of a contract for the sale of their hotel, Hotel Raffaele, and interest for late settlement. The defendant, who was a company director, had contracted to purchase the hotel for $11 million with the intention of developing it into a retirement village. The agreement was conditional upon the defendant conducting a feasibility study and obtaining finance. Despite making the agreement unconditional, the defendant failed to settle, leading the plaintiffs to issue a settlement notice and subsequently seek summary judgment.

The central legal issues in this case were whether the defendant's misrepresentation claims constituted a defence to the plaintiffs' claim for specific performance and whether the defendant's actions amounted to an affirmation of the contract, preventing cancellation. The defendant argued that the plaintiffs' pre-contractual representations about the hotel's profitability and other factors induced him to enter into the contract and that these misrepresentations justified the cancellation of the agreement under the Contractual Remedies Act 1979. The plaintiffs contended that the misrepresentation defence was raised too late and that the defendant's conduct affirmed the contract, precluding cancellation.

The court found that there were significant factual disputes, particularly concerning the nature and impact of the alleged misrepresentations, which precluded the granting of summary judgment. The court noted that if the misrepresentations were substantiated, they could potentially satisfy the requirements for cancellation under the Act, thus barring summary judgment. The court also observed that the defendant's actions, such as lodging a caveat and attempting to secure finance, could be explained by the plaintiffs' failure to disclose historical financial data promptly. Therefore, the court concluded that the plaintiffs had not demonstrated that the defendant had no arguable defence to the claim for specific performance. Summary judgment was refused, and costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.