Multistop Limited v Innovate Civil and Construction Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2022-404-1549

[2023] NZHC 748

IN THE MATTER of an application for summary judgment

BETWEEN

MULTISTOP LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

INNOVATE CIVIL AND CONSTRUCTION LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 27 March 2023

Appearances:

A R Williams for Plaintiff

C F L Godinet for Defendant

Judgment:

5 April 2023


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE LESTER


This Judgment was delivered by me on 5 April 2023 pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date: ……………………………

MULTISTOP LIMITED v INNOVATE CIVIL AND CONSTRUCTION LIMITED [2023] NZHC 748

[5 April 2023]

[1]                 Multistop Limited (Multistop) provides plastering and stopping services in the construction sector. The director is Mr Leandro Da Silva and Mr Paul Maumau is an employee of Multistop.

[2]                 In 2020 and into 2021, Multistop worked on two major jobs; the first in Mangere  for  which  it  issued   three   invoices   between   9   August   2020   and 30 November 2020. The second job was at Te Atatu and that job commenced in September 2020 with Multistop finishing on that site in May 2021 after a number of its invoices were not paid.

[3]                 In respect of both projects, Multistop says its contract was with Innovate Civil and Construction Limited (ICC).

[4]                 On the Mangere job, Multistop says it is owed $224,655.49 plus GST and on the Te Atatu job it says it is owed $217,608.78 plus GST.

[5]                 At the relevant times, the directors of ICC were a Mr Jason  Campbell and     a Mr Barry  Hayes.  During  both  projects,  Mr Da  Silva   dealt   with   both   Messrs Campbell and Hayes.

[6]                 Multistop seeks summary judgment against ICC in respect of its unpaid invoices. The complicating factor in the context of a summary judgment application is that there is  no  written  contract  for  either  job.  The  sole  defence  raised  by Mr Campbell, the only deponent for ICC, is that Multistop did not contract with ICC on either of the two jobs, subject to the unpaid invoices. Mr Campbell says Multistop’s contracts were with another company, B&R Property Maintenance Ltd (B&R), of which Mr Hayes is the sole shareholder and director. The noteworthy feature of that claim is that it was raised for the first time by Mr Campbell in this proceeding.

Summary judgment principles

[7]                 It is well known that the summary judgment process is usually not suitable for the determination of issues of fact, however, if a plaintiff can show that a defendant’s allegations are utterly baseless, it may still succeed.1

[8]                 The onus lies on Multistop throughout to establish that ICC does not have     a defence to this claim.

[9]                 Plainly contrived factual conflicts will not stand in the way of summary judgment.2 The well-known passage from Attorney-General v Rakiura Holdings Ltd, provides guidance as to when an apparent or supposed conflict of evidence will not stand in the way of judgment.3

In a matter such as this it would…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Multistop Limited v Innovate Civil and Construction Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 748
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Multistop Limited, a company providing plastering and stopping services, brought a claim for summary judgment against Innovate Civil and Construction Limited (ICC) for the recovery of unpaid invoices totaling over $750,000 for two construction projects. ICC, represented by Mr. Jason Campbell, defended the claim on the basis that it did not contract with Multistop and that the contracts were instead with another company, B&R Property Maintenance Ltd. This defense was raised for the first time in response to the proceedings. The central issue for the Court was whether ICC had a defence to the claim, given the absence of written contracts and the late-stage assertion by ICC that it had merely acted as an intermediary.

The Court found that ICC's defense lacked credibility and was not substantiated by the evidence. Mr. Campbell's evidence did not clearly establish that he acted solely as an agent for B&R. Instead, the Court observed that the interactions between the parties, including the addressing of invoices to ICC, promises of payment made by ICC, and the absence of any protest from ICC when invoices were sent, indicated that ICC was the contracting party. The Court held that ICC's belated assertion that it acted merely as an intermediary was not credible and did not constitute a reasonably arguable defence. The Court was also sceptical of defences raised only after claims for payment had been made.

Accordingly, the Court granted summary judgment in favour of Multistop against ICC for the amounts claimed, plus interest as per the Money Claims Act 2016. Costs were awarded to Multistop on a solicitor-client basis, with the possibility for Multistop to seek indemnity costs if a memorandum justifying such an award was filed within five working days.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established