Muir v Taxation Review Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2016-404-002908 [2017] NZHC 2932

UNDER the Judicial Review Procedure Act 2016

IN THE MATTER

of an application for review pursuant to
Part 1, Judicature Amendment Act 1972

BETWEEN

GARRY ALBERT MUIR Applicant

AND

THE TAXATION REVIEW AUTHORITY

First Respondent

THE COMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE

Second Respondent

Hearing: 27 November 2017

Appearances:

S R Carey for Applicant
No appearance for or on behalf of First Respondent
S Leslie and J Mara for Second Respondent

Judgment:

29 November 2017

JUDGMENT OF JAGOSE J

This judgment is delivered by me on 29 November 2017 at 2.45  pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

..................................................... Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Counsel/Solicitors:

S Carey, Barrister, Auckland

Crown Law, Wellington

MUIR v THE TAXATION REVIEW AUTHORITY & ANOR [2017] NZHC 2932 [29 November 2017]

Introduction

[1]      The applicant, Dr Muir, brings this proceeding for judicial review of the Taxation Review Authority’s (the “Authority”) refusal to accept his “Second Amended Notice of Claim” for filing in a dismissed proceeding.

[2]      The  second  respondent  (the  “Commissioner”)  objects  to  this  Court’s jurisdiction to hear and determine the proceeding,1 and applies on the present application for its dismissal also.2 Alternatively, she applies for the proceeding to be dismissed as an abuse of process.3

Background

[3]      The background to the proceeding lies in the Trinity tax scheme, designed by Dr Muir. This Court held the dominant purpose of the scheme was tax avoidance,4 which decision was affirmed by the Court of Appeal,5 and the Supreme Court.6

[4]      Dr Muir’s challenges to his income tax assessments for the 1997 to 2010 tax years in both the Authority and this Court, stayed pending final determination of the Trinity tax scheme’s legitimacy, were subsequently struck out by the Authority and this Court (both in its original jurisdiction, and on appeal from the Authority).7 This was affirmed again by the Court of Appeal.8 Although granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, Dr Muir there accepted (in oral argument of new grounds) his leave

application should be revoked. The Supreme Court said “The consequence is that the decision of the Court of Appeal will stand, and the appellant’s proceedings will

remain struck out in their entirety”.9

1      HCR 5.49(1).

2      HCR 5.49(3).

3      HCR 15.1(1) and (2).

4      Accent Management Ltd v Commissioner of Inland Revenue (2005) 22 NZTC 19,027.

5      Accent    Management    Ltd     v    Commissioner    of    Inland     Revenue    [2007] NZCA 230, (2007) 23 NZTC 21,323.

6      Ben  Nevis  Forestry  Ventures  Ltd  v  Commissioner  of  Inland  Revenue  [2008] NZSC 115,

[2009] 2 NZLR 289.

7      Muir v Commissioner of Inland Revenue [2011] NZTRA 2, (2011) 25 NZTC 1-006; Muir v

Commissioner of Inland Revenue [2015] NZHC 792, (2015) 27 NZTC 22-004.

8      Muir v Commissioner of Inland Revenue [2015] NZCA 591, (2015) 27 NZTC 22-034.

9      Muir v Commissioner of Inland Revenue [2016] NZSC 113,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Muir v Taxation Review Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 2932
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Dr. Garry Albert Muir, sought judicial review of the Taxation Review Authority's refusal to accept his "Second Amended Notice of Claim" for filing in a dismissed proceeding. The second respondent, the Commissioner of Inland Revenue, objected to the Court's jurisdiction and applied for the proceeding to be dismissed as an abuse of process. Dr. Muir's challenges to his income tax assessments for the 1997 to 2010 tax years were previously struck out by the Authority and this Court, a decision affirmed by the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court. Dr. Muir sought to file an amended pleading in both the Authority and the Court, but the Authority refused to accept the pleading for filing, while the Court inadvertently accepted it. The Commissioner applied for summary judgment on Dr. Muir's unpaid tax liabilities, which was granted by the Court, confirming the Authority proceeding was "at an end."

The legal issues in this case revolved around the Court's jurisdiction to hear and determine the proceeding, and whether the proceeding should be dismissed as an abuse of process. Dr. Muir argued that the Commissioner could not pursue the alternative ground for dismissal because it was founded on an acceptance of the Court's jurisdiction. He also contended that the Authority's decision was reviewable as a commission of inquiry and under Part 30 of the High Court Rules. The Court rejected these arguments and held that the proceeding was at an end, and therefore, there was nothing in which any 'amended' pleading could be filed. The Court found that it had no jurisdiction to review the Authority's refusal to accept the pleading for filing and dismissed the proceeding.

The Court found that Dr. Muir's 'amended' pleadings in the Authority and the Court constituted a collateral attack on the decisions of the Court, the Court of Appeal, and the Supreme Court. It was an abuse of the Court's processes. The Court held that once a proceeding was at an end, it was not possible to file fresh pleadings in the same proceeding to resume the litigation. The Court also held that the Commissioner was entitled to indemnity costs from the time of the Court's decisions on 23 June 2017 and 29 August 2017, as Dr. Muir had acted vexatiously, frivolously, improperly, or unnecessarily in continuing the proceeding. The Court reserved costs for determination on short memoranda of no more than five pages, to be filed and served by the Commissioner and Dr. Muir within specific time frames.

In conclusion, the Court dismissed Dr. Muir's proceeding for judicial review and granted the Commissioner indemnity costs. The Court held that the proceeding was at an end and that Dr. Muir's 'amended' pleadings constituted an abuse of the Court's processes. The Court rejected Dr. Muir's arguments and held that it had no jurisdiction to review the Authority's refusal to accept the pleading for filing. The Court also held that the Commissioner was entitled to indemnity costs from the time of the Court's decisions on 23 June 2017 and 29 August 2017, as Dr. Muir had acted vexatiously, frivolously, improperly, or unnecessarily in continuing the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.