Mucalo-Connolly v Police

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA AHURIRI ROHE

CRI-2021-441-31

[2021] NZHC 3476

BETWEEN

ETHAN MUCALO-CONNOLLY

Appellant

AND

NEW ZEALAND POLICE

Respondent

Hearing: 15 December 2021

Appearances:

A McPherson for Appellant A V Bryant for Respondent

Judgment:

15 December 2021


JUDGMENT OF ISAC J

[Sentence appeal]


Introduction

[1]    Mr Mucalo-Connolly appeals a sentence of 16 months’ imprisonment imposed on one charge of unlawfully taking a motor vehicle,1 and a charge of possession of instruments to be used in the conversion of a motor vehicle.2

[2]The grounds of appeal advanced are:

(a)the starting point adopted by the District Court was too high;

(b)the uplift applied for previous convictions was disproportionate; and

(c)the credit for personal mitigating factors was insufficient.


1      Crimes Act 1961, s 226(1) (maximum penalty of seven years’ imprisonment).

2      Section 227 (maximum penalty one year’s imprisonment).

MUCALO-CONNOLLY v NEW ZEALAND POLICE [2021] NZHC 3476 [15 December 2021]

[3]All of this is said to have led to a manifestly excessive sentence.

[4]    Finally, Mr Mucalo-Connolly says he ought to have been admitted to home detention at his mother’s address.

Background

[5]    At 3.07am on 16 September 2021, while New Zealand was at Alert Level 4 and in a nationwide lockdown, Mr Mucalo-Connolly and a companion gained entry into a Mazda Demio motor vehicle by smashing a quarterlight window.

[6]    Once the pair had gained entry, they pushed the vehicle down the road to avoid being heard by its owner while they attempted to start it. Police were notified by a passer-by, and shortly after Police confronted Mr Mucalo-Connolly who was found sitting in the driver’s seat attempting to start the vehicle with the ignition barrel pulled out.

[7]    He was also found in possession of a set of vice grips and a screwdriver, tools generally used by car thieves.

[8]    Caught in the act of stealing the car, the appellant unsurprisingly pleaded guilty to the charges.

District Court sentencing decision

[9]    Having outlined the relevant facts,3 Judge R J Collins noted the appellant’s extensive criminal history for dishonesty, including convictions for burglary and “multiple convictions for theft”.4

[10]   The Judge referred to the decision of this Court in Wood v Police,5 where Downs J observed that a single unlawful taking charge can give rise to a starting point


3      New Zealand Police v Mucalo-Connolly [2021] NZDC 19990 at [2].

4 At [3].

5      Wood v Police [2018] NZHC 1629.

of at least 18 months’ imprisonment “if the offence has a significant aggravating feature or features”.6

[11]The aggravating features of the offending were identified as:

(a)premeditation: the offence occurred at 3.00 am in the morning, in the company of another offender, and while Mr Mucalo-Connolly was in possession of tools to convert cars;7 and

(b)damage to the vehicle. A window was smashed and the ignition barrel pulled out.8

[12]   Taking these matters into account, a starting point of 16 months was settled on.9 An uplift of four months was warranted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mucalo-Connolly v Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZHC 3476
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Mucalo-Connolly v Police, the appellant, Mr Mucalo-Connolly, appeals a 16-month imprisonment sentence imposed for unlawfully taking a motor vehicle and possessing instruments to convert a motor vehicle. The grounds for appeal are that the starting point for sentencing was too high, the uplift for previous convictions was disproportionate, and the credit for personal mitigating factors was insufficient. The appeal also argues that the appellant should have been admitted to home detention at his mother’s address.

The court had to decide whether the starting point for sentencing was too high, whether the uplift for previous convictions was disproportionate, and whether the credit for personal mitigating factors was sufficient. It also needed to determine if home detention at the appellant’s mother’s address was an appropriate sentence.

The court found that the starting point adopted by the District Court was in error, as the aggravating features identified were not significant enough to warrant a 16-month starting point. Instead, the court found that a 12-month starting point was more appropriate. Regarding the uplift for previous convictions, the court determined that a 25% uplift was warranted given the appellant’s extensive criminal history. The court found that the 20% discount for the appellant’s guilty plea was appropriate, and there was no error in the Judge’s assessment of the mitigating factors. However, the court found that the overall sentence, after accounting for the adjusted starting point, was manifestly excessive.

The court substituted a sentence of 12 months’ imprisonment for the 16 months’ sentence, calculated as follows: a starting point of 12 months’ imprisonment, a 20% credit for the guilty plea resulting in an adjusted starting point of nine months’ imprisonment, and a three-month uplift for the appellant’s relevant previous criminal history. The court dismissed the appeal regarding the admission to home detention at the appellant’s mother’s address, finding that the Judge’s decision to deem the address unsuitable was correct and well-founded. The appeal was allowed in part, and a sentence of 12 months’ imprisonment was substituted for the 16 months’ sentence. The same standard and special release conditions as imposed by the District Court were to apply for six months following sentence expiry.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.