Mu v Body Corporate 312431

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI-2011-404-4768 [2012] NZHC 571

BETWEEN  DANNI MU Plaintiff

AND  BODY CORPORATE 312431

First Defendant

ANDABOUT BODY CORPORATES LIMITED Second Defendant

ANDSHARRON WYNNE O'SULLIVAN Third Defendant

ANDGRAHAM BELL Fourth Defendant

Hearing:         9 February 2012

Appearances: G M Illingworth QC  and M J Morris for plaintiff

T J Herbert for first defendant
No appearances for second and third defendants

Judgment:      30 March 2012

JUDGMENT OF ALLAN J

In accordance with r 11.5 I direct that the Registrar endorse this judgment with the delivery time of pm on Friday30 March 2012

Solicitors/Counsel :

Steindle Williams Legal Ltd, Auckland  james.stewart@swlegal.co.nz

G M Illingworth QC Auckland  gmi@xtra.co.nz
Adina Thorn Lawyers, Auckland  adina.thorn@grimshaw.co.nz

T J Herbert, Auckland  tim@timherbert.co.nz

MU V BODY CORPORATE 312431 HC AK CRI-2011-404-4768 [30 March 2012]

[1]      The  plaintiff  is  the  owner  of  a  residential  unit  in  a  complex  known  as Normanby Mews, situated in Normanby Road, Mt Eden, Auckland.  The complex comprises 48 residential units.

[2]      The first defendant was originally incorporated under the Unit Titles Act

1972 and, as from June 2011, is incorporated under the Unit Titles Act 2010 (the

Act).

[3]      The first defendant is the Body Corporate for the complex.   The second defendant  is  the secretary of the first  defendant,  and  the third defendant  is  the director  of  the  second  defendant.     The  fourth  defendant,  a  member  of  the management committee of the first defendant, abides the decision of the Court in the substantive proceeding.

[4]      The building has suffered weathertightness problems.  The exterior cladding of the complex is not weathertight and requires replacement.  In this proceeding, the plaintiff seeks declaratory relief in respect of the activities of the first defendant.  She is concerned in particular about the validity of a meeting of the proprietors, or unit holders, held on 26 October 2010, the proper interpretation of r 4 of the Body Corporate Rules, and the inter-relationship between that rule and s 138 of the Act.

[5]      In her amended statement of claim dated 23 November 2011, the plaintiff seeks declarations that:

(a)       A resolution passed by members of the Body Corporate on 26 October

2010 purporting to agree to proceed with a panel system known as

“Rockcote”, is invalid:

(b)The defendants are not authorised to enter into a contract or contracts by or on  behalf  of the  Body Corporate  for the recladding of  the complex, unless the expenditure is approved by special resolution of

75% of the eligible voters.

[6]      The proceeding was set down for hearing on 9 February 2012.  Counsel filed synopses of argument prior to that date.  Mr Herbert, counsel for the first defendant, filed a synopsis which ran to just one and a half pages, but did not address the merits at all.  Rather, he claimed that by reason of the plaintiff’s failure to file a reply to positive allegations and affirmative defences pleaded in the statements of defence of the defendants, the plaintiff was deemed to have admitted those allegations, with the result that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mu v Body Corporate 312431 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 571
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Danni Mu v Body Corporate 312431, the plaintiff, who owns a residential unit in a complex in Auckland, brought an action against the Body Corporate, the secretary, the director, and a member of the management committee. The plaintiff sought declaratory relief regarding the activities of the Body Corporate, specifically in relation to a meeting of unit holders, the interpretation of certain rules, and the relationship between those rules and the Unit Titles Act 2010. The main legal issues in this case were whether the plaintiff was required to file a reply to the affirmative defences and positive allegations in the first defendant's statement of defence, and if not, whether the first defendant was entitled to judgment based on the plaintiff's failure to file a reply.

The court examined the relevant rules and previous cases to determine the nature of affirmative defences and positive allegations. The court concluded that the first defendant was not entitled to a reply from the plaintiff because the paragraph in question contained either propositions of law or factual material pleaded as particulars instead of primary facts. The court also found that the proceeding had lost momentum, and it would not be a valuable use of time to address narrow pleading points. The plaintiff was awarded costs in respect of the first defendant's application for judgment, and the case was referred to Associate Judge Bell for a case management conference.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established