Mortgage Administration Services (Calibre) Limited v Calibre Financial Services

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-3862 [2012] NZHC 1921

UNDER  the District Courts Act 1947

BETWEEN  MORTGAGE ADMINISTRATION SERVICES (CALIBRE) LIMITED First Appellant

ANDCAIRNS LOCKIE LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

Second Appellant

ANDCALIBRE FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing:         4 July 2012

Appearances: S McAnally for Appellants

F Joychild on instructions for Respondent

Judgment:      2 August 2012

JUDGMENT OF PETERS J [re Leave to Appeal]

This judgment was delivered by Justice Peters on 2 August 2012 at 3 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date: ...................................

Solicitors:           Keegan Alexander, Auckland:  smcanally@keegan.co.nz

Sanderson Weir, Auckland:  nicola.robertson@sandersonweir.com

Counsel:            P Rice, Barrister, Auckland – email: phillip.rice@aspx.co.nz

F Joychild, Auckland:  francesjoychild@clear.net.nz

MORTGAGE ADMINISTRATION SERVICES (CALIBRE) LIMITED V CALIBRE FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED HC AK CIV-2011-404-3862 [2 August 2012]

Introduction

[1]      Calibre Financial Services Limited (“Calibre”) seeks leave to appeal to the Court  of  Appeal  against  a  judgment  I  gave  in  this  matter  on  18  April  2012. Mortgage Administration Services (Calibre) Limited (“MAS”) opposes the application.

[2]      My judgment was on appeal from a decision of the District Court at Auckland given on 31 May 2011.  I allowed an appeal by MAS and remitted the case back to the District Court for determination of another point raised on the pleadings.

[3]      To obtain leave to appeal, Calibre must show that its appeal would raise a question of law or fact capable of bona fide and serious argument in a case involving some interest, public or private, of sufficient importance to outweigh the cost both to the Court system and to the parties, and the delay, of a further appeal.[1]

Background

[4]      The issue before the District Court and before me was whether MAS was required to indemnify Calibre in respect of an amount of GST that Calibre had been required to pay to the Inland Revenue Department.

[5]      Calibre had advanced funds to a third party borrower pursuant to the terms of a loan agreement (“loan agreement”).  MAS had introduced the borrower to Calibre pursuant to the terms of an agreement between MAS and Calibre (“agreement”). The borrower defaulted and Calibre exercised its powers under security documentation to conduct a mortgagee sale of property of which the borrower was the registered proprietor.  Calibre was required to pay GST (“the GST amount”) on the proceeds of sale.

[6]      Calibre demanded that MAS indemnify it for the GST amount, MAS failed to do so and Calibre terminated the agreement for breach.  Calibre issued proceedings

seeking an order that MAS indemnify it for the GST amount, and for a declaration that it was entitled to terminate.  MAS defended the proceedings and counterclaimed for commissions it contended were due to it under the agreement.

[7]      Calibre’s case against MAS for the GST amount was based on cl 11.2(a) of the agreement, which reads as follows:

11.2     [MAS] to Indemnify Calibre for Costs

[MAS] must indemnify [Calibre] on demand for:

(a)       all  stamp…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mortgage Administration Services (Calibre) Limited v Calibre... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 1921
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Calibre Financial Services Limited sought leave to appeal against a judgment given in the High Court of New Zealand on 18 April 2012. Mortgage Administration Services (Calibre) Limited opposed the application. The case involved a dispute over whether MAS was required to indemnify Calibre for an amount of GST that Calibre had paid to the Inland Revenue Department. The District Court had found that MAS was required to indemnify Calibre, but the High Court subsequently allowed an appeal by MAS and remitted the case back to the District Court for determination of another point raised on the pleadings.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the GST amount was a tax within the meaning of cl 11.2(a) of the agreement between MAS and Calibre, and whether, if it was, it was “payable on or in connection with” the loan agreement. The Court found that the GST amount was not a tax within the meaning of cl 11.2(a), and that if it was, it was not “payable on or in connection with” the loan agreement. The Court also expressed reservations as to whether the GST amount was “payable by the relevant Borrower” under the loan agreement, in the absence of evidence of a demand or debit. However, the Court found that no question of law, capable of bona fide and serious argument, could arise as to whether the GST amount was payable by the borrower as required by cl 11.2(a).

The Court declined leave to appeal, finding that Calibre had not shown that its appeal would raise a question of law or fact capable of bona fide and serious argument. The Court also found that the case did not involve an interest, public or private, of sufficient importance to outweigh the cost both to the Court system and to the parties, and the delay, of a further appeal. The Court ordered Calibre to pay MAS’s costs on this application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established