Morgan v Martin HC Hamilton CIV 2011-419-1305

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

CIV 2011-419-1305

BETWEEN  TUKUROIRANGI MORGAN Plaintiff

ANDTANIA ERIS MARTIN First Defendant

ANDWAIKATO-TAINUI TE KAUHANGANUI INCORPORATED

Second Defendant

Hearing:         On the papers

Counsel:         D M Salmon & I T K F Hikaka for Plaintiff

W C Pyke for First Defendant
J A McKay & J W J Graham for Second Defendant

Judgment:      20 December 2011

JUDGMENT OF KEANE J [re costs]

This judgment was delivered by  on at pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/ Deputy Registrar

Date:

Solicitors:           Lee Salmon Long, PO Box 2026, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140:

davey.salmon@lsl.co.nz

Chapman Tripp, Auckland: john.mckay@chapmantripp.com

Copy to:            W C Pyke, Barrister, Hamilton: wcpyke@wave.co.nz

TUKUROIRANGI MORGAN V TANIA ERIS MARTIN HC HAM CIV 2011-419-1305 20 December 2011

[1]      On 6 August 2011, at the half yearly general meeting of Te Kauhanganui, the incorporated society of the Waikato iwi, a resolution was passed, as the chairperson of the society, Mrs Martin, held to be by a sufficient majority, disqualifying Mr Morgan from being an elected member of the society.

[2]      The effect of that resolution, which the society confirmed as the rules require by notice to the marae Mr Morgan was elected to represent, Te Hoe O Tainui Marae, was that he ceased to be qualified to represent that marae as from the date on which it received the notice.[1] There was also an immediate consequent effect. Mr Morgan ceased to be able to continue as the chairperson of the executive of the society, Te Arataura.[2]

[1] Waikato-Tainui Te Kohanganui Incorporate Rules, rule 5.3.2(b).

[2] Rule 15.4.1(a).

[3]      At the meeting itself Mr Morgan immediately challenged the validity of the resolution.   Of the 68 marae comprising the society, 65 were represented at the meeting, each entitled to one vote.  Six of the votes cast were ruled to be invalid. There were two abstentions. Twenty-seven voted against the resolution.  Mr Morgan contended that for the resolution to be valid a majority of 30 affirmative votes was not enough. At least 33 were called for.

[4]      Mrs  Martin,  in  the  face  of  that  challenge,  upheld  the  validity  of  the resolution; a declaration that was conclusive as to the fact that the motion had been carried and by a particular majority.[3] Mr Morgan's only recourse, Mrs Martin said to him, if he wished to challenge the validity of the resolution, was to bring an application for relief in this Court.

[3] Rule 12.6.

[5]      In a letter, dated 7 August 2011, the solicitors to Te Kauhanganui expressed an opinion vindicating Mr Morgan's interpretation of the rules. On 31 August 2011, Stace Hammond, on instructions from Mrs Martin, expressed the contrary opinion that the majority had been sufficient because it was the majority of the valid votes cast for or against the motion at the meeting.   So the position was when on 12

September 2011 Mr Morgan brought this case seeking declaratory and other relief.

[6]      In my decision dated 23 September 2011, I granted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Morgan v Martin HC Hamilton CIV 2011-419-1305 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1841
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Tukuroirangi Morgan brought a case against Tania Eris Martin and Waikato-Tainui Te Kauhanganui Incorporated, contesting a resolution passed at the society's general meeting that disqualified him from being an elected member. The legal issues at hand were whether the resolution was valid and what the appropriate majority needed for such a resolution. The court had to decide whether the resolution was valid and if the majority required was correctly applied. The court ruled that the resolution was invalid and that the majority needed was not correctly applied. As a result, Morgan was not disqualified from being an elected member.

The court reasoned that the resolution was invalid because it did not meet the required majority, which should have been 50% or more of the sum of votes of all marae comprising the society, 34 votes, or at least 50% of those present at the meeting, 33 votes. The court granted Morgan the relief he sought, quashing Martin's declaration as to the validity of the resolution and declaring that Morgan was not a disqualified member. The court reserved the issue of costs and, in memoranda filed, both Morgan and Martin sought an indemnity award against the society's fund.

The court concluded that both Morgan and Martin were entitled to an indemnity award against the society's fund. The court acknowledged that the dispute turned on the meaning of a central rule, and it was not unreasonable for Martin to interpret the rule as she did. The court emphasized that this award should not be considered a precedent for future cases and that applications for relief and any for an indemnity award against the society would be assessed with increasing stringency in the future.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established