Moore v IAG New Zealand Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA356/2019
 [2020] NZCA 319

BETWEEN

GRAEME JOHN MOORE
Appellant

AND

IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

7 May 2020

Court:

Cooper, Gilbert and Courtney JJ

Counsel:

N R Campbell QC and P A Cowey for Appellant
C M Meechan QC, C M Laband and S K Swinerd for Respondent

Judgment:

31 July 2020 at 9.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

BThe answer to the preliminary question set out in [8] is “no”.

CThe respondent must pay costs to the appellant for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.  We certify for second counsel.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Gilbert J)

Introduction

  1. As is well-known, the Christchurch region was hit by three major earthquakes almost a decade ago — on 4 September 2010, 22 February 2011 and 13 June 2011.  The appellant, Mr Moore, owns a home in Scarborough, a suburb of Christchurch.  His house was not damaged at all in the September 2010 earthquake, but it sustained serious damage in the February 2011 earthquake and again in the June 2011 earthquake.  The estimated reinstatement cost is said to be approximately $2.08 million for the damage caused by the February earthquake and $2.77 million for the damage caused by the June earthquake.  It is common ground that these losses are separate in that none of the losses caused by the February earthquake are subsumed in the losses assessed as having been caused by the June earthquake. 

  2. Mr Moore insured his home with IAG New Zealand Ltd (IAG) for the 12‑month period 13 November 2010 to 13 November 2011 (the policy period).  The sum insured under the policy was $2.5 million.  The question on this appeal is whether Mr Moore has cover up to $2.5 million for each loss or whether that is the limit of cover for both losses, even though these occurred four months apart.  The answer turns on the interpretation and operation of the aggregation clause in IAG’s policy.  Aggregation clauses are common in insurance policies.  Their purpose is to enable separate losses to be treated as a single loss in certain circumstances for the purposes of setting the limit of cover.  Such clauses also determine whether one or more deductibles are to be borne by the insured for losses arising in a given set of circumstances.

The policy

  1. The primary insuring clause in part C of the policy reads:

    We cover sudden accidental loss to the house during the period of insurance.

  2. The words in bold are defined terms.  “Accidental” is defined to mean “unexpected and unintended by you”.  “Loss” means “physical loss or physical damage”.  “You” means the “Insured”.

  3. Part C excludes loss which is caused by, among other things, earthquakes, unless cover is provided in part D of the policy.  The relevant clause in part D reads:

    We pay for sudden accidental loss to the house which is caused by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moore v IAG New Zealand Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZCA 319
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Graeme John Moore, the appellant, brought an appeal against IAG New Zealand Limited, the respondent, concerning the interpretation of an aggregation clause in an insurance policy. The clause was intended to determine the limit of cover for insured losses. Mr Moore's property in Christchurch suffered damage from two separate earthquakes in February and June 2011, four months apart. The sum insured under the policy was $2.5 million. The primary issue before the Court was whether the losses from the two earthquakes constituted a series of losses caused by a series of events with the same cause, such that the aggregation clause would apply, limiting IAG's liability to the sum insured.

The Court found that the aggregation clause was to be interpreted in accordance with normal principles of contractual interpretation. The Court rejected the Judge's interpretation that any two or more losses occurring during the policy period constituted a series of losses. Instead, the Court found that a series of losses must be linked in some way and temporally related. The Court further held that a series of events must also occur in a proximate temporal sequence and share a common proximate cause to be considered a series of events with the same cause.

Applying this reasoning to the facts, the Court concluded that the damage caused by the February 2011 earthquake and the June 2011 earthquake were separate losses caused by separate events, without the necessary linkage and common proximate cause. The appeal was allowed, and the Court found that the answer to the preliminary question was "no." The Court further ordered that IAG pay costs to Mr Moore for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Graeme John Moore, the appellant, who owns a home in Scarborough, Christchurch. His house was not damaged in the 4 September 2010 earthquake but sustained serious damage in the 22 February 2011 earthquake and again in the 13 June 2011 earthquake. The estimated reinstatement cost for the damage caused by the February earthquake is approximately $2.08 million, and for the damage caused by the June earthquake, it is approximately $2.77 million. Mr Moore insured his home with IAG New Zealand Ltd (IAG) for the 12-month period from 13 November 2010 to 13 November 2011, with a sum insured of $2.5 million. The central issue in this case is whether Mr Moore has coverage up to $2.5 million for each loss or whether that is the limit of coverage for both losses combined, as determined by the interpretation and operation of the aggregation clause in IAG’s policy.

The matter initially came before the High Court of New Zealand, where Dunningham J found that the losses to the house caused by the February and June 2011 earthquakes were a "series of losses" caused by "a series of events" which had the same cause, being the September 2010 earthquake. This meant that IAG’s liability under the policy was capped at $2.5 million for all losses caused by both the February and June earthquakes. Mr Moore appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, which heard the appeal on 7 May 2020 and delivered its judgment on 31 July 2020.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether two losses four months apart can be considered a "series of losses."
2. Whether two earthquakes four months apart can be considered a "series of events."
3. Whether the aggregation clause applies only if the series of events (acting together) caused the series of losses.
4. Whether IAG proved that the September earthquake was the proximate cause of both the February and June earthquakes.

Held
1. Two losses four months apart cannot be considered a "series of losses" under the aggregation clause in the insurance policy.
2. Two earthquakes four months apart cannot be considered a "series of events" under the aggregation clause in the insurance policy.
3. The aggregation clause applies only if the series of events (acting together) have the same proximate cause and caused the series of losses.
4. IAG did not prove that the September earthquake was the proximate cause of both the February and June earthquakes.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal in New Zealand considered the appeal by Mr. Moore against IAG New Zealand Limited, focusing on the interpretation of the aggregation clause in the insurance policy. The Court held that two losses four months apart cannot be considered a "series of losses" under the aggregation clause. This conclusion was based on the ordinary meaning of the word "series" as a linked sequence of sudden, accidental losses occurring proximately in time. The Court rejected the argument that a series of losses means any two or more losses occurring at any time during the policy period, without any connecting factor. The Court found that the February and June earthquakes, occurring four months apart, were separate events and separate losses, not forming a series of losses.

The Court also held that two earthquakes four months apart cannot be considered a "series of events" under the aggregation clause. The Court applied the proximate causation test, which requires a more direct causal connection than the "but for" test. The September earthquake did not meet this test as the proximate cause of either the February or the June earthquakes, according to the expert evidence presented.

Furthermore, the Court held that the aggregation clause applies only if the series of events (acting together) have the same proximate cause and caused the series of losses. The Court emphasized that a series of events causing a series of losses will have the same cause only if they have the same proximate cause in the usual sense.

Lastly, the Court found that IAG did not prove that the September earthquake was the proximate cause of both the February and June earthquakes. The evidence showed that while the September earthquake contributed to setting the stage for the subsequent earthquakes, it was not the proximate cause of either the February or the June earthquakes.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the aggregation clause in an insurance policy applies to a series of losses that are linked in some way and temporally related, caused by a series of events that have the same proximate cause. The clause does not apply to losses that occur separately in time and are caused by distinct events, even if they share a common underlying cause.