Monaco Management Limited v Boutle HC Nelson CIV-2011-442-314

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CIV-2011-442-314

BETWEEN  MONACO MANAGEMENT LIMITED Appellant

ANDTIM BOUTLE Respondent

Hearing:         13 October 2011

Counsel:         A D Marsh for Appellant

G J Praat for Respondent

Judgment:      16 November 2011 at 4:00 PM

I direct the Registrar to endorse this judgment with a delivery time of 4pm on the

16th day of November 2011.

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF MACKENZIE J

[1]      This is an appeal from a judgment of Judge Tuohy in the District Court at Nelson delivered on 14 June 2011.  In it, the Judge dismissed the appellant’s claim against the respondent for a declaration that the respondent was liable to pay certain hotel outgoings.

[2]      The  appellant  is  a  hotel  management  company,  and  operates  the  Hotel Monaco in Nelson.  The hotel consists of 18 units in a development under the Unit Titles Act  1972.    It  is  part  of  a  wider  development,  including  other  unit  title developments, which are operated separately from the hotel.  The broad structure of the  hotel’s  operation  is  that  the  appellant  is  the  lessee  of  the  18 units  that  are operated as the hotel.   The respondent is the owner of one of the units and consequently one of the lessors to the appellant.  The rent payable is not a fixed sum. Rather, the rent payable to each of the unit owners as lessor is a proportionate part of

the gross revenue from the hotel business, less certain specified deductions.  Some

MONACO MANAGEMENT LIMITED V BOUTLE HC NEL CIV-2011-442-314 16 November 2011

outgoings, for services that are necessary for the operation of the hotel, such as the supply of gas and electricity, do not form part of the rent calculation, because under the lease they are the responsibility of the lessor.  The terms of that responsibility are at the heart of this appeal.  There is provision in the lease for the appellant to manage the payment of these outgoings on behalf of the lessors, and to deduct any amounts paid by the appellant for these outgoings from the rental payments due to the lessors. Until November 2008, the appellant managed the collection and payment of the outgoings  in  that  way.    More  recently,  the  revenue  from  the  hotel  has  been insufficient to provide a rental stream for the unit owners, from which payment of outgoings could be deducted.   The appellant has ceased management of these outgoings.  The appellant is therefore dependent, for the continued supply of gas and electricity from the suppliers, on payment by the lessors, through the body corporate, of the suppliers’ charges.

[3]      The appellant initially sought summary judgment in the District Court on its claim for a declaration that the respondent is liable to pay, directly to the relevant unity companies, all outstanding amounts owing by the appellant for gas and electricity in respect of supplies to the Monaco Hotel, and an order for specific performance requiring him to pay such amounts.  Summary judgment was refused in a judgment delivered by Judge Tuohy on 4 March 2010.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Monaco Management Limited v Boutle HC Nelson CIV-2011-442-31... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1778
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Monaco Management Limited, a hotel management company, appealed against a decision of Judge Tuohy in the District Court at Nelson, which dismissed its claim against Tim Boutle for a declaration that Boutle was liable to pay certain hotel outgoings. The Hotel Monaco, consisting of 18 units, is a part of a larger development under the Unit Titles Act 1972. Monaco Management Limited is the lessee of the 18 units that are operated as the hotel, while Boutle is the owner of one of the units and a lessor to Monaco Management Limited. The rent payable to the lessors is a proportionate part of the gross revenue from the hotel business, less certain specified deductions. Outgoings for services necessary for the operation of the hotel, such as the supply of gas and electricity, are the responsibility of the lessor. The appeal centred on the terms of that responsibility.

The legal issues the court had to decide were whether Boutle was liable to pay all outstanding amounts for gas and electricity in respect of supplies to the Monaco Hotel, and if the lease created an obligation on the lessor, enforceable at the suit of the lessee, to make payment of that share. The court found that Boutle's liability under the lease was only to the extent of the outgoings he was required to pay under the rules of the body corporate, which was a proportionate share of the outgoings. The court also found that the lease did not create an obligation on the lessor to make payment of the share if the body corporate did not require Boutle to pay his share of the gas and electricity charges.

The court's reasoning was that the lease only provided for Boutle to be responsible for the payment of all outgoings in respect of the Hotel Monaco which are specified in the Third Schedule. The outgoings that are to be paid by the lessor for, inter alia, gas and electricity, are those that it pays to the body corporate. The court further found that the outgoings to be paid by the lessor are those specified in the words in bold: "outgoings to be paid by the lessor as part of the amounts it pays to the body corporate". The court held that the clause could not be interpreted as if those words were there and that the lack of obligations on the body corporate could not be cured by implying a term into this contract which would impose on the lessor an obligation to pay electricity and gas suppliers under contracts of supply to which the lessor is not a party.

The appeal was dismissed, and the respondent was entitled to costs which were fixed on a 2B basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established